Boat explosion

yzer

Active member
Member
Joined
Jul 21, 2004
RO Number
14523
Messages
1,924
This happened during the first week of the month. It's a sad thing for the family, but an object lesson in the care and attention needed to maintain and operate a classic boat (or any boat, for that matter).

Stalled engine while waiting for fuel, blower off and automotive alternators.

http://www.midhudsonnews.com/News/boat_expl-07Aug07.html

I never completely trusted the passive ventilation system on my boat. It's just no good if the boat is not moving and there is no breeze. Passive ventilation doesn't work well when underway in a following wind, either. The blower is always running on my boat while underway.
 
The article noted that the "Alternators were not seals(ed?)" It also noted that because of the boat's age it was not subject to the current safety regulations--I find that hard to believe. Ignition proof alternators and starters were on a wooden boat I owned in the early 60's as were blowers. On gas inboards I run the blowers at any low speed or before starting. At high speeds, the engines air intake moves far more air than blowers do.

Always hard to know what happened, but one wonders if automotive type of a starter was used instead of an ignition proofed marine starter.
 
oh come one bob, you know better than drawing conclusion from an aricle in the paper written by a "journalist" who doens't eve know what an alternator is ! :-)

there were a couple of long threads on this tragic accident earlier this week. very sad...

but you got to wonder what people are thinking... a fume detector woudl have saved them.
 
Having taken a few Marine Ford AND GM starter apart, I didn't find anything different between them and auto starters other than the Ford starter had a hose clamp holding the cover to the linkage of the bendix gear/electro magnet. The only thing different on the Delco alt I worked on was the screen on the front and back. There's nothing sealing either unit. The starters don't have an opening large enuff to allow a flame to pass thru and the body is strong enuff to hold in an explosion. Same with alternators. The screen allows gas fumes to pass thru but won't allow a flame to pass thru. That's not to say the end cap on starters aren't stronger or have smaller vent holes, they may very well have closer tolerances or each unit has to be inspected or other things to make them 'marine'. What they do have is a marine rating which satisfies insurance companies and the rating itself is not without cost.
 
Charlie, the article referred to alternators rather than starters.
 
My 1955 boat came with a marine generator and it's still on the boat. The unit is sealed. The starter is sealed, too. In one repect the old marine engines were actually more safe: mine has no belts, all of the bolt-ons run off of power take-offs.
 
Following Pascal's lead, I just found another thread on this incident. It's on the HRCC forum.
 
Back
Top