Engine Strangness

rich356

Member
exMember
Joined
Apr 3, 2007
RO Number
25751
Messages
249
Wanted to get everyone's opinions on this. Yesterday we were driving our boat back from Saugatuck, MI and it was a little rough, but not too bad by any means (about 3s-5s). Soon after we got underway I noticed that my port engine was lagging behind my starboard engine in terms of rpms so I had to give it more throttle to get them even. I stopped and backed a few times thinking there was maybe something stuck on the port prop, and it got a little better, but not completely. The port engine also used about double the fuel that the starboard engine used over the course of the cruise. The weird thing is that as we got close to our harbor it got much better; the rpms were almost equal with the same amount of throttle. The scary thing is that the alarm which I believe is for the transmission would sound when I backed the port engine. It did not sounds while going forward or at higher rpms, and the temperature (and all other guages) was normal. Could this be a prop problem? Transmission problem? I'm getting the marina service people to look at it, but they probably won't be able to for over a week. I also felt a slight vibration. Any ideas?
 
it woudl help if you'd tell us what kind of engine and tranny you have. Diesel or gas ?

if diesels, the fact that it happened in rougher waters would point to dirty fuel/tanks clogging up filters although it rarely gets better. it usually gets worst.

if gas, i'd also start by changing the filter(s) on that engine.

when you said the port used twice as much fuel, is that per flow meters or actual fill up back at the dock ? twice as much is huge, i'm guessin flaky reading on the flow meter, maybe some air was being sucked in the line.

the first thing to do when an engine alarm sounds is why. again, i don't know what kind of engine/trannies you have but on gas Mercs inboards/vee drives you have one alarm that will sound for low engine pressure, overheating and also for vee drive/tranny overheat.

you have gauges for the first two, but not for the tranny, do you ? so when the buzzer sounds and your oil/temp gauges are in the green, the first thing you need to do is go down in the ER and check the tranny temp. you can use an IR thermometer but touching them will tell you the story right away.

I dont' think merc vee drives have oil pressure sensors connected to the alarm.

why would the tranny temp alarm go off on reducing RPM ? not sure... maybe the reduced water flow at lower RPM is just enough to send fluid temp over the edge ? although usually if a tranny is going to overheat it's going to be at higher RPM, not low.

but again the first thing to do when something odd occurs (alarm, engine running rough, etc...)is to inspect your ER RIGHT AWAY. either stop the boat if you have someone with you have them drive the boat, at reduced speed if needed, open the hatch and check things out with your eyes nose and ears :-)

for instance you could have a water leak at higher RPM that sends a little spray on connectors causing ignition issues or triggering an alarm.

slowing down is usually not enough to clear something on the prop. stopping the boat then reversing for a few seconds is more likely to to the trick.

I woudln't set the mechanic loose on the boat jsut yet, I'd take it out myself and try to duplicate the problem then check the above. Before you do, inspect that port engine carefully look for sign of water/srpay, go under and check your prop/shaft, etc...
 
Some more info:

I have gas Mercruiser 7.4L EFI's with vee drives. The fuel filters were just changed right before it went in this season. I do have guages for the oil pressure and temp. Both were normal. About using twice as much fuel, the starboard engine was set up to use the starboard tank and used about half a tank on the trip. The port engine used half of both the port tank and aux tank (I wasn't running the genset). I did check the engine room and everything seemed normal. No leaking or strange sounds that I could see/hear. You're right Pascal, I don't have a guage for tranny temp, but obviously could get a IR thermometer as you suggested. I didn't just slow down BTW. I stopped, backed both engines together and separately. The alarm sounded only when the port engine was backed with a bit of throttle. I just think it was really strange that the rpms seemed to even out at the very end of the trip. That's why I was thinking it might have been something with the prop. Going under and taking a look myself may be the best thing to do. Not looking forward to that option though as my dog has fallen in twice and gotten sick both times! The water in our harbor is very stagnant and there are tons of ducks crapping in it so it probably has some e coli problems. Oh well, I'll just make sure I don't drink the water! Actually, maybe I'll just take the boat out and anchor somewhere.
 
ok... i had merc 7.4 with the infamous velvet vee drives on my 98 maxum 37...

if your engine temp and press where good, the alarm was caused by the tranny overheat sensor.

first thing is to make sure it's actually running hotter. believe me, touch the tranny and you will know if it's running hotter than the other one.

so the fuel difference is real, not from flow meter ? how big is the aux tank ? how do you know it used half, you're not relying on the gauges, are you ?

if the water is bad, don't go under ! anchor outside...

where feasible, it's a good idea to check your running gear... easier here in so fl obviously and i do that at least once a month. i often find some line wrapped around the shaft.

Are your Vee drive originals ? have they been upgraded, replaced, etc ? I forgot the model nr when most of merc's velvet vee drives produced between 98 and 00 had some oil pump issues and had to be replaced/repaired. usually you can tell from the casing, different paint.

by now most must have failed and have been replaced but if the boat is low hours and was never operated on longer runs at cruise, well... they maybe original and ... you dont want to know.

when mine where replaced, on under full warranty, one under parts only, merc supplied a large tranny cooler in addition to the upgraded tranny with the upgraded oil pump and relief valve which was the cuprit.

that said, tranny problem should not result in rough running. the symptoms were overheating (running at low cruise would prevent or delay the problem) or complete failure of the pump resulting in instant loss of drive (and hitting the rev limiter)

so i don't think you're having a tranny issue...but be aware of the tranny hitory.

did you check the flow out the eahxust ? it maybe enough to cool the engine but not enough to cool the tranny keeping it on the edge.
 
Thanks Pascal. I'll check the tranny temp next time I go out just to be sure. The vee drives are original. I'm not completely relying on the fuel guages. The starboard engine used about the same amount of fuel on the way up as it did on the way back. The side tanks are about 100 gallons each and the aux tank is about 118 gallons (I say almost because I may be 5 gallons off in the side tanks). I filled up when I left port yesterday and based on where the guages were before I filled up and how much gas we put in they seem accurate. Thankfully Lake Michigan is at about 70 degrees now where I am so going under shouldn't be too bad!
 
Don't forget to check the tranny fluid too. If it smells burnt change it don't just add to it.
 
Well, this is really strange. Now everything seems fine with the boat. I checked the tranny fluid; fine, not burnt. I checked the sea water strainers; fine. Took the boat out; no alarms, rpms were fine and I was able to easily go above 3200 rpms. Some of my dock mates are speculating that it could have been from sediment in the fuel tanks getting stirred up due to rough water (it was pretty rough the day we have problems).
 
That's what I thought Bruce. Don't know why they're thinking sediment in the fuel tanks. Doesn't matter though because the price to fix it was certainly right! Free!
 
Rich, I'd be really surprised if you have v-drives. The only v-drive aft-cabin boats I've seen have twin berths in each corner of the aft stateroom with the engines below. Aren't your engines under the salon attached to straight shafts?
 
SLW-Sorry, this kind of confuses me actually. The reduction gear boxes are Borg Warner Velvet drives (as per my survey and what I saw in the engine room. The shafts, as you said, are straight.
 
yup, the best kind, self healing boat problems.
 
that makes sense. The "V" of velvet probably stood out in your mind... Velvet Drive is a series/model designation. V-drive is a configuration where the engines are mounted far astern in a boat, facing the rear. (belts facing the transom) The tranny then sits fwd, so the prop shaft goes back under the engine to the seals, hence the "V".
 
SLW-Ah, now it makes sense. I thought that was what a v-drive was, but people seem to use the term interchangeably (obviously not correctly). So it's possible to have a v drive and Velvet Drive transmissions then?
 
If you had an alarm for a transmission overheat, it's a good idea to change the trans fluid, even if you can't tell if it's burnt.

Thought you should read this.

Jonathan
 
Rich, yup! (in other words "Velvet V-drive" is NOT redundant)
 
Back
Top