ICW Condition

A fellow club member is on an extended vacation in his 4788 Bayliner. He has already kissed bottom twice since March 1 "INSIDE THE MARKERS"!!! The ICW is in drastic need of maintenance. If you look at earmarks by various members of congress (read BILLIONS), none that I have found relate to ICW maintenance.

As for my friend, he is running outside. Seems like a missed opportunity for waterfront stops along the way.

Just whose side is Congress on?
 
Jim

where was that exacly? I ran the ICW a couple of weeks ago from Sav. south, a god chunk of it at low tide because low tide was around mid day :-( We "tapped" something in the channel in new smyrna, jsut south of the southern channel to the Ponce inlet. We were well in the channel, alhough off center due to traffic, and i saw the bottom coming up. I was already in neutral when the bow touched a shoal.

would be good to know where that exact spot was. Most of the bottom is soft so normally you should get away with a slow encounter...

"if a vessel can not opperate outside a narrow channel due to thier draft it is considered a vessel restrained by its draft. Which in turn gives it the athority of the stand on vessel unless a vessel is restricted in its abilty to manuever due to the nature of her work. "

now this is even more confusing... There is no such thing as a vessel restrained/constrained by draft in the inland rules... rule 9 doesn't designate such a vessel, it only gives stand on status to a vessel which cannot operate outside a narrow channel... And a vessel which can only operate in the narrow channel, will not only have to give way to a RAM but also a NUC (not under command).
 
David
It's a sure bet that the ICW and other treasures the boating world has are going to fade until better times. With the war on terror, a rotten economy and a population swelling at a level that needs social(ist) services, we can forget about things like the ICW.
 
"now this is even more confusing... There is no such thing as a vessel restrained/constrained by draft in the inland rules... rule 9 doesn't designate such a vessel, it only gives stand on status to a vessel which cannot operate outside a narrow channel... And a vessel which can only operate in the narrow channel, will not only have to give way to a RAM but also a NUC (not under command)."

When obtaining a Inland Merchant Marine Officers Licence International Rules Apply.
 
well, yeah, you have to learn the international rules if that's what you mean but Constrained by Draft doens't exist under inland rules. that's international only.

unless I'm mistaken... if that's the case you are welcome to tell us where does CBD appear in inland nav rules.
 
Somehow I don't see any problem. The Inland rules are pretty specific about vessels "which can safely navigate only within a narrow channel or fairway". This pretty well covers "constrained by her draft" even if it doesn't say so. If there is any doubt then you fall back to Special Circumstances. Slow down or stop if need be, communicate, and work it out.
 
the problem is that reading some of the posts, one may thing that there is such a thing as Constrained By Draft under the inland rules. For instance a boat with a 5' draft operating in a 6' bay with shoals doens't have any special privileges because of her draft.

it's my understanding that Special Circumstances apply when multiple vessels are involved in a situation, not draft, work, problems or anything else. that woudl be covered by NUC, RAM or CBD status (international only), NOT special circumstances.
 
"The Inland rules are pretty specific about vessels "which can safely navigate only within a narrow channel or fairway". This pretty well covers "constrained by her draft" even if it doesn't say so. If there is any doubt then you fall back to Special Circumstances. Slow down or stop if need be, communicate, and work it out."

This explains it all. I just couldn't quite figure out how to explain it
 
IMO "special circumstances" covers any circumstances not otherwise covered by the rules; that's why they're "special". The presence of shoals "dangers of navigation..." is addressed (2b).

Ultimately it really doesn't matter HOW you avoid a collision; just that you DO.
 
In my opinion the ICW is no different than our interstate highway system and it should be maintained. It is imperitive for commercial traffic, but also benefits recreational boaters which in turn benefit local economies along the ICW. I can't comment on the Gulf Coast sections, but anyone who understands a little bit about how commerce system works in the US can understand how import the ICW and river system is in that area. As far as the east coast, I would think recreational use has a bigger impact, imagine what would happen along the Carolina's, GA and FL coast if recreational boaters could not use the ICW, I think you might see a lot of local economies take a nose dive. I suspect the bi-annual migration north/south dumps millions of dollars along the coast fromo FL to NY. Plus, imagine if all those people who could not run their boats north/south end up on I-95 in motorhomes!
 
I'm not sure about the east coast, but here on the west coast of FL I doubt there's anywhere near enough "commerce" generated by pleasure boats to justify the expense of dredging the ICW, especially considering the fact that most of the bigger pleasure boats are fully capable of making the run offshore, just like much of the commercial traffic. Bear in mind that ALL the taxpayers get charged for what only the locals may use. With all the commotion about "pork barreling" these days I'm not going to hold my breath.

There are a lot of neighborhoods around here that have discovered that if they want the waterways dredged (not the ICW) they have to pay for it themselves. I expect that may be the case for the ICW in the future. Either that or we can buy shallow-draft boats.
 
Here are some excerpts from a recent article in "Soundings" magazine entitled "Prospects Brighten for ICW Dredging": "North Carolina has allocated $4 million to help maintain its stretch of the ICW. . . . the waterways impact on its economy . . . generates $500 million a year." Georgia is ready to partner with the Corps of Engineers and will do an economic impact study. "Florida spends about $16 million a year on dredging. . . . The economic impact of Florida's ICW is $1.8 Billion." The article does recognize that yearly Congressional allocations for dredging are slim, so the AIWA (Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway Association) sees the long-term solution in a partnership of federal and state cost-sharing. There is also discussion of the use of marine fuel-tax money that goes into the Inland Water Trust Fund to be used for the ICW. But: "In boater surveys in North Carolina a large majority of respondents say they would be willing to spend up to $90 annually for a better-maintained waterway." So, perhaps not total gloom and doom??
 
Reading all this with great interest as I am making a trip from FT Myers to Charleston, SC end of this month.

Only have Great Lakes experience and 2 months down in Ft Myers- almost exclusively on the river and bay. I did go once from FTM to FT Lauderdale and back and the seas were all but calm for us and never saw a wave.

So, I planned this trip on the outside assuming it wouldn't be too bad and as stated, I have never been in anything but calm seas or light chop in the bay. It seems like a no brainer to me to avoid the ICW with the shoaling and shallowness, but i guess, 4-6+ all day could change my mind.

Not interested in the journey per se, just want to run at 22k, burn diesel, find some more cheap diesel to burn and end up in SC in 5d.

I take it the biggest draw of the ICW is the journey and calmness of the waters?
 
So...if I am getting all this, by the time (10yrs) I want to become a snow bird I will have to run outside all the way? Actually, that probably makes a few people happy...less snowbirds:)
Niles
 
if you want to make in 5 days and run 20+ kts, indeed go outside. down the west coast to Marathon, 7 mile bridge, up hawk channel and the coast.

that's fine although you'll be missing some nice sights along the way. if you draw under 5', the ICW is a good alternative although there are a handful of tricky spots where you might have to play the tides. worth it though.

running outside, you still have a few issues with inlets, some of them are not easy to navigate due to shoaling and can be dangerous depending on conditions.
 
Tugboat Kevin,
Your point about stern squat is well taken. I had been running at very slow speeds to try to avoid this problem. The shoal I hit came up so fast it didn't even register on the depth finder until after I was "in it".

Pascal,
The location I had problems with is just north of Haulover Canal just above Cape Kennedy... Northbound, on exiting the canal, you make a 90 degree turn to port and hug the beach of an island (dredge materials?) for several miles. I was in the channel about 1.5 miles north of the turn when I kissed the bottomed, while the depth finder was reading 7.2 feet (it came up that fast... At idle in reverse backing down to free myself, I definately hit something solid on the bottom submerged while still in the channel. Maybe it was gear lost from another craft or something. The net result was "swiss cheese" on the newly rebuilt props and a week layover in Daytona getting repairs.

Delaware Jim
 
Jim

I remember that stretch, wasn't too bad but i got a couple of sub 7' readings which is more or less where i'd pull back from 9 kts to as low as idle as needed.

I often look at the churn behind the boat. When it gets close, under 100' it's time to slow donw. when it gets down to one boat length, it's time for idle!
 
One year ago this week I went to Ft Lauderdale to bring my new used boat home to the Chesapeake Bay. I hired a capt to bring her back with me. I wanted to take the ICW to see all the sights.

I was amazed at all the skinny spots with little or no water. Lack of markers, neglect, all the things talked about in this thread. The boat needs 5' Good thing the capt makes the trip 4 or 5 times per year. Local knowledge is key in some areas.

But it was an amazing trip from FL to MD. Beautiful. Very diverse. Huge yachts and magnificent homes in Lauderdale. Northern FL different. Georgia, Carolina much different. Norfolk with it's "Carrier Row".

Can't wait to do it again.

It would be nice to have a dredged and marked channel. Would 6' water be too much to ask?
 
Back
Top