Prop Scan

Gregory S

Well-known member
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
2620
Messages
5,967
Pulled the props off my boat today. they "look" OK. Thinking seriously about sending them for Prop Scan. Do you guys recommend it?
 
Greg,
I highly recommend you have them checked. Propscan does it for free. I went to the North Coast Prop tech in Huron, Ohio, and they scanned all four of mine.
The smaller Volvo duoprops are not that critical, compared to yours. In fact, 3 of mine were out, but still within specs, so i did not have mine done. I had no problems with performance or vibration before they were scanned.
I went there in person, and was shown the procedure they use to check the props. They give you a computer printout of each prop, before and after the repairs are made, so you have a reference for the next time.
Let us know how you make out.
 
If you have inboards and you have not tuned them in a few years I'd say go for it. The only reason I'd hold back is a lack of vibration. Once tuned I can stand on the floor in the aft cabin right over the struts and not feel a thing. Otherwise, there's always something vibrating back there.
 
If GHI, will pick up the tab then yes. Otherwise I don't recommend it, unless you have hit bottom, have a loss in RPM, or have a vibration.

Since you do not have a high performance boat, and have not met the criteria above, it will be a waste of money. Just polish them up and put them back on.
 
Definitely worth while. Not very expensive, and will recover the cost with less wear on the cutlass bearing on an inboard--bearings and seals on an I/O.
 
FWIW, I highly recommend taking them to a scan shop and watching them perform the free simple scan so you can easily comprehend what the prinout graphics & data represent and know it's accurate. Have them explain the results printout you keep & service options for you to consider. The shop I've been going to in RI is very friendly and surprisingly happy to answer & expand upon all my questions, practical & theoretical .

I believe it's worth making sure your props conform to ISO class 1 specs ( though others may be satisfied with ISO 2 at slightly lower tuning cost), and the bar graphs nicely show any deviation from this at any of several radius points of each & all blades, as well as not-uncommon average pitch differences between port & stbd wheels. These can be corrected to balance & match the pair much better than could be done with the no-scan old method. The preliminary printout you get will list which minimum ISO spec your props presently conform to in their pre-service condition. Make sure you confirm to what ISO class spec your props would be tuned to if they quote you a price. Class S tuning is generally pretty pricey & the difference between S and Class 1 is probably not noticeable except on larger or very high-end prop systems, but I'm convinced 've felt the difference between class 1 and class 2 condition of my own 17" 3 blade props.

If your props aren't matched, the engines bear uneven loads resulting in possible fuel usage and other annoying mysteries. Out of balance can cause vibration and cutlass or other bearing and/or seal wear. Either condition reduces propulsion efficiency.

Even if they look great, the contact with pot buoys or other flotsam and jetsam or brief, even unnoticed, soft groundings in shallow channels, etc., most all of us encounter at some point in the season will effect the efficiency of the prop and a lot of new props are unbalanced right out of the box . Few pairs are matched right out of the box unless specifically ordered matched. Even if you decline the prop work, if the scan is free ( & there are some shops where it isn't- call 1st), why not have them scanned unless there just isn't a scan shop anywhere at all near you?

I had mine scanned and tuned to ISO class 1 last year and Prop-Scanned again about a month ago. Port prop was still just as the "after service" scan showed last year but the stbd was down to mid ISO 2 so I left that to be matched to the new scan record of the port stored in their computer file . If I needed to replace one or both props , I could call up the prop-scan shop and have them tune the one or a new set to be identical to the tuned specs on file if desired. Nice.

A little more info: http://www.blackdogprops.com/2.html

http://www.blackdogprops.com/6.html
 
The props are the only things pushing you forward. Fine tuning them is very worth while.
 
Thanks for the feed back guys. A lot of debate as I expected. Wish I was close enough to a shop to walk in.
 
I had my props scanned when the boat was brand new but broken in. Top speed went from 39MPH to 41MPH. While not a practical difference, performance did improve which is a good thing. Boat is a Tiara 32 open.
 
Absolutely recommend them. I dont think there is a charge to check the props. After wasting a lot of money using a non propscan shop I tried them and got significant improvement because the scan data showed that the original shops work was not good.
 
Greg,
It is well worth the drive. If nothing else, drop them off in person, get an education, and have them ship them back to you ups. Not sure of the turn around time this time of year, but give them a shot.
 
In board props will bend out of shape afer a while depending on how you run. The bad part of having the rating brought up is that you will notice a difference the first time you whack a stick or something.
 
Tried to get in contact with the shop in Ohio several times today. Kept getting voice mail. Called Blackdog Props in Maryland. One week turn around time on avg. Props went out today.
Ron, no decreased performance issues, but I haven't had the props off since I bought the boat. I do have a little bit of vibration at about 1500 rpm. Ken, no duoprops, Crusader inboards with 18X15 cupped NIBRAL props.
 
Back
Top