This discussion compares to the synthetic vs dino oil, Pledge vs name brand vinyl cleaner, regular single ply TP vs RV TP, lay-up with full fuel tank vs whatever is in there.... and all those other debates we have on a regular basis. Those of us who are convinced that our way to accomplish something is "the right way" because we've never had any issues will continue to do as we prefer. The "newbie" needs to sort through all the posts made by the more experienced boaters and then make their own decisions.
To the newbies reading this thread and any others of this type:
Some of us tend to lean towards using what, in our opinion, is the safest method of accomplishing a task even though it may be more expensive, more difficult or appear to be overkill. We do this because we want to avoid risk at any cost or, perhaps, because we have been misinformed.
Some of us tend to use what may seem the less expensive or path of least resistance when accomplishing a task because it has always worked or we learned through the experience of others that using the more expensive of more difficult method is simply a waste of money, time or effort, or because we are misinformed.
We are here at BE to share ideas, experience and knowledge. We don't need to agree all the time so the reader needs to take in all the provided information, process it and many times make their own decisions.
Hope this helps....