David,
I just sold my 1996 250 Sundancer, I got about what I was asking. In fact it brought above average of what they are posted for on Boat Trader and also Yacht World. I actually sold it on Craigslist. Everyone talks about how cheap boats are, go look at the cheapies and you will be shocked at what some people call clean, pristine, like new & etc., I am convinced the really clean ones will still bring decent money. I will venture a guess you can get close to what you gave for it.
good luck.
H