Which anchor?

Steve P.

Member
exMember
Joined
Feb 18, 2008
RO Number
29424
Messages
59
If you had a choice between a Danforth or a Bruce anchor, which one would you choose? Which one has more holding power under a variety of conditions? I currently use a Danforth. The Bruce is sitting in my basement. The Danforth is easier to stow and I don't have a windlass on my boat.
 
Can't speak for the Bruce but been using a Danforth since '76 & never had one break free on me. Mostly sandy/grassy bottoms.
 
nobody can answer your question, it depends on the condition. Danforth won't get in grass for instance and they wont' reset very after a shift if they get clogged with mud.

It also depends on what danforth... they're not all created equal. Alum fortress for instance hold much better than the cheap "economy" models.

My FX55 has tremendous holding power and almost never fails to set in mud or sand but as mentioned above resetting is an issue in some conditions.

I found a high tensile 110lbs North Star Bruce for just $300 including shipping, I'm going to give it a try.

bottom line there are no bad anchors... just bad choices for the specific conditions. ... and bad anchoring techniques!
 
agreed different results in different conditions. The danforth will not work in grass and even a large clam between flukes will mess it up. I prefer the plow style such as the Bruce but your area conditions aren’t difficult for any anchor if you say out of rocks and grass.
On you size boat a windlass would be a great addition. Then you could use a larger anchor and more chain and anchor at the flick of a switch.
 
I certainly agree with above. The Bruce anchors are very popular in the Pacific Northwest. (Incidently Bruce were made in Brazil if they are available at all. There are copies and I don't know the quality of the copies). My personal experience with the Bruce is limited, but it was bad enough that I crossed it off my list. In sand, the Danforth High Test are excellent. However, I use mostly Delta Quick set, or the Ronca/Manson Supreme. I recently did a number of anchor tests for another forum--and was surprised (shouldn't have been) that my 8 lb Danforth standard, did not even set, in a bottom of compacted mud, shells and sand. The best holding was a Manson Supreme--which is a knock off of the Ronca.

So it does depend on the bottom conditions. Anchors which are popular--with good reasons--are The Danforth High Test, the Fortress, the CQR or Delta Quick Set, the SuperMax by Creative marine, the Spade, the Ronca/Manson Supreme, and the Hydrobubble. The latter I personally have not tried--and would not for a storm anchor--but that is a personal preference based on the question in my mind if that anchor, with a float, would bury deep enough in storm conditons. Incidently even in my smaller boats I carry several different type of anchors--for example--Manson Supreme, Delta, Two Fortress (small and large) and a Northill is the compliment in one of my boats.
 
I gave up on my Fortress as it was prone to sailing and hard to set in anything but calm conditions. So IMO, you should only consider a Fortress if you have all chain. I only had 10' of chain and this with the Fortress was a horrible combination. Sometimes, in rougher water it was basically impossible to set, even doing everything 'by the book'.

On the same boat, I changed to a Delta FastSet anchor and it always set in the FIRST try and held extremely well, even though it had the same amount of chain.

From now on, when given a choice, I'll probably opt for the heavier anchor and the most chain possible, and the Delta has been so great that I won't even bother with others as my primary anchor (I always have a danforth on board as a second anchor though).
 
I have a Rocna that I've been using for a year. It's never failed on me. I've dived and watched it set and it's just like the videos on their site. It hooks immediately in just about any bottom I've found in Georgian Bay
 
We just had a chance to try out our new 35# Delta. We previously had a 22# danforth that had drifted 3 or 4 times over 12 months. I managed to bend th control arm (between the flukes) so I bought the Delta while the Danforth was in for repairs.

Here's what we found:

Two weeks ago a huge front blew through Florida. We were caught underway (actually we knew this was coming) and found a nice little cove to ride it out in. Well, the area we anchored in was so small that we only had room for a 7 to 1 scope. We set the anchor and swung in winds up to 50 knots for the next three days.

After 3 days of a serious blow from every direction, the Delta hadn't moved even an inch! My wife and I were commenting on how we wouldn't have been able to do that with the Danforth based on past performance. This was a pretty serious storm for the gulf. Were were hidded behind an island just South of Venice and we could see 16' and bigger waves crashing on the beach just 2 blocks away.
 
For what its worth, we boat on inland lakes and canal lakes in Ontario.The Danforth just doesn't set in weedy bottoms... The bruce has never let me down and it always resets when you swing.
 
My Boat is 50K lbs wet and has a good size sail area - I have a 66lb Bruce on the boat and it’s not failed me yet regardless of where we’ve been throughout the LI sound area–BUT I have all chain and that will help any anchor- We had a Bruce on our 41PC and it worked great as well- but again it was all chain
Had a Danford of our 37 Sundancer and even with all chain it would break free sometimes –
Had a CQR on a 33 Cruisers with very little chain (old Good Windless) and it work great
Since Bruce is no longer in the “yacht and boat market”- only oil rigs etc… I would most likely get a Ronca or Manson Supreme in I needed one

I just reread your post and I see you don’t have a windless- so all chain would not be a good option
Of the two you have- My first choice would be the Bruce- but since you own both I would try to compare the two-
With no windless and if you were to buy new, I would go with a fortress- I have a small FX-23(15lb) that I use as a stern anchor- it has no chain at all and yet it has never broken loose
 
good to hear some more good feedback on the bruce... i'm waiting for North Star to receive a batch of 110lbs in april to order one...

I've only used a Delta once, an 88 lbs on a 58 footer and i had to try 3 times to get it to set (all chain, scope up to 9:1) in the exact same spot my FX55 sets every time. wasn't impressed but could have been a fluke :-) or maybe just the mud was too soft.
 
Where we drop the hook we have problems with Danforths getting fouled with small rocks. I gave up on Danforths and Fortress anchors for this reason.

After having used a Spade anchor for 10 years with great success, I just took delivery on a new Rocna and am looking forward to trying it out if the snow ever stops - over 8 feet this year and still counting!
 
pascal -- 88lbs on a 58 might be a smidge on the light side. still should have set and held especially with 9:1 scope. seems like a fluke.
 
not really, it's one size up. 88 delta is for 60 to 75'.
although i think the shape of the delta prevents it from holding really well in soft mud because of the angles of it's surfaces, unlike others.
 
the holding strenght and ease with which your hook will set is governed mostly by the ratio of anchor rode to depth rather than the type of anchor unless you are trying to anchor in unusual conditions like rocks. if you measure from the top of the pulpit to the bottom and multiply by 5, that will give you a good ratio for normal wind/current conditions. if you use a significant amount of chain or all chain that ratio can be reduced somewhat.

certain types of anchors typically hold better in specific bottom conditions. the best way to answer the question is find out what the local proffesional skippers are using and why, then you can make your selection knowing what your typical bottom conditions are.
 
I agree, local anchoring conditions mean a lot in selecting an anchor and rode. Talking with boaters experienced in your anchorage areas will tell you the most.

I anchor in an estuary with tide and river current, mud bottoms and plenty of wind at times. No anchor windlass. A 16# Danforth Standard with 30' of chain works good enough for me to sleep comfortably at anchor.

All fluke anchors are the biggest favorites around here, so you see plenty of Danforths of all types and Fortresses used with a lot of success. Buy a good make for fluke anchors and avoid the generic versions. In my experience none of the fluke anchors are worth a darn for overnight anchoring where grass and weeds are involved. Around here the guys with plow anchors like the CQR do best in weeds.
 
Both Delta and CQR will not be good mud anchors. This is well known. Certainly the Fortress, even in Mud setting (45 degree fluke angle, instead of the 32 degree angle of the Danforth and standard Fortress setting) and the Super Max are superior mud anchors. I suspect that the Ronca and Spade will also be good in mud, if they get in deep enough.

Not all mud is equal. What will vary is particle size and cohesiveness. The soupy mud, has to allow the anchor to settle thru it and set into a more solid substrait, such as clay or sands.

The worse anchoring condition is what might be better called ball bearing rocks. Round rocks from 2 to 8" in diameter. I have seen conditions in these rocks where no anchor will hold when it is really blowing--and have once had to put to sea, and in another situation move 20 miles to better holding when it blew up.
 
Back
Top