A good run

Good stuff. It made it's way through here a few months ago
 
Okay, before I even open the link I know what this is going to be. Last year, I smelled an add coming so it didn't moving me at all. After all, an ad is not a sincere thing, just a fancy sales brochure. It's actually kind of insulting if you think about it.

But....I'll try it again and report back if anything changed for me.

bp
 
Nope, still smells like an ad right from the get go. Good idea, but faked sincerity never did anything for me. They should reshoot with real film clips, real folks instead of actors.

bp
 
It's an ad. It's not necessarily supposed to be real but I think it's very well done. It's job is to make people aware of the boating lifestyle and all the quality time spent with friends and family on and around boats. I think it does it's job quite well.

Real home video shot on 8mm back from the 50's by an amateur would not look as good.

Why were you insulted?
 
Ghost, What you said makes me laugh. I guess real life is a little rougher around the edges and doesn't appeal to the audience at large. It reminds me of when my grt. grandmother started loosing it and was buying picture frames, only she was displaying them with the display pictures that came with them. Our family started getting very beautiful. LOL... I too prefer real life but then again, I know my family. It was still moving to me.
 
I guess I'm the odd man out. I was last time. I guess I'll resign myself to it this time too. I agree the ad was done "well". It just doesn't move me at all. I think most of society has no problems interpreting intricate "sets" as being real. It's like the success of all the chain stores and malls. I did a bit of traveling about the country and hated it. Everywhere you go, its the same. There is no "real" culture left, just made up. It's like believing if you eat at the Olive garden your actually at an "Italian" restaurant, yet the real Italian restaurant down the block is going out of business and you hate those folks. Same thing with all the other "theme" stores out there with only faked culture and not real roots to anything real. Obviously, most of the country has no problem with this and is drawn like moths to a flame given the recent explosion of these things. It just doesn't do anything for me. In the last year, I can get "sliders" at just about every one of these places in the bar no matter what it says on the outside.

I thrive on the "real" stores and little holes in the wall, barely making it, at the expense of all the "made up" culture. I mean, I want to believe in a real story about boating, not something made up. It's like having a movie star as your "hero". Never made sense to me.

Here's another example that drives me nuts. Real life. Remember when Johnsonville had all those commercials showing people eating those good ole traditional Johnsonville Brats. Well, it just so happens I like brats and brought them to our family 4th of July picnic for years. I'd bring a bunch of sides of kraut, onions and chopped up peppers. I'd be the only one eating them and my wife would shake her head at the trouble I would go through, but that's okay, cause I liked them. All of a sudden my brother in law sees the commercials and starts talking about how great those things were for years, but he would always say "Johnsonville". He fell in love with a commercial. He made up some kind of coveted childhood memory out of thin air and suddenly he loves the things. I'm glad he likes them, but it drives me crazy that 90% of our population these days can't distinguish between their own "real" memories and these illusions that are put in front of them.

This kind of "fake" advertising never did anything for me, but I suspect many many of you are like my brother in law and will suddenly cherish those old time memories of grandpa and the 17 styles of boats he never owned, including his cherished love of that water skiing party boat that wasn't even around at an age he could still walk down the dock.

Every year this is some kind of weird boating replay of the equivalent of the movie Josie and the *****cats. "Orange is the new Red, ha"

bp
 
Ghost,

You ever consider drinking or therapy ?

You remind me of a guy I once met who’s Mother - In - Law hated him. A long story short. This guy’s was asked to see his M.I.L on her death bed. When he gets there she proceeds to tell him how much she hates him right before she dies. His moral to the story “ it wasn’t like he always saw it in the movies “

Mark
 
It hit me a little more than others in the room: I'll admit. Why? They don't have 35 years of boating experience in them like I do.

I learned to boat from my Grandfather. The first time I took the helm of a boat, I was sitting on his lap. I was two. I grew up on that boat.....and it's the same boat I own today.

That old guy reminded me a lot of my grandfather. His fondest memories - and mine - have been asociated with the love of boating.

Many people don't have my experience and I pity them.
 
Ghost ... you have my sympathy .... This is the second time I have seen this and I enjoyed it both times... I have been boating over 50 years, started out with my Dad, brought my girls up around boats and now am working on mhy grandchildren. Many great memories.
 
Ghost - I absolutely see your point and would tend to agree. (I don't like chain joints, sit-coms, or TV/movies in general) But in this case, the scenario played out hits close to home. I grew up on boats, my kids are growing up on boats. The oldest one is a senior in high school and will be leaving us to attend college next year. My wife of 24 years and I are starting to think what it will be like to watch the kids move out and start our next "phase" of life. I also look forward to taking my future grand-kids boating and fishing. I'm not living some obscure life through the "commercial", it only reminds me of good time had, and good times to come. That's gotta make you smile.

As commercials go, the vast majority of them are pretty lame these days. At least this one has some class to it. It makes you pay attention.
 
S'alright Ghost. I'll still take what you and Pascal say about boating to the bank. Just not this one.
 
Hey no problem folks, your all still my friends. I told you from the beginning I was not going to be popular on this one.

That said...."Who wants a Johnsonville brat?"
 
The problem is, the ad is supposed to remind one of some of their real life memories.
If you don't have fond memories similar to those depicted by the add, the ad would most likely be meaningless to you.
You have my sympathy.
 
Back
Top