Another conceptual question

footloose

Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2001
RO Number
6963
Messages
619
Why doesnt the market not make more large single diesel performance crusiers (30 mph cruise) with newer technology (large yanmar with pocket prop or surface drive and a bow thruster for around the dock)?

One big reliable diesel in the middle of an engine room is easier to work on and maintain than two stuffed into a small space. Diesel genny with a PTO could give you a limp home if the big diesel craps.

Entire package would be lighter, more fuel efficient, and easier to own/maintain. Why not?

I did a google and found one company only that is doing this and they are in prototype stage.

Is it a technical issue?
 
footloose, I don't know much about it, but I would suspect the problem is more political then technical. JMHO.........
 
O- Pocket props are not necessarily more efficient or give increased performance though they do reduce draft of the vulnerable gear and can reduce shaft angle. Your surface drives seem to have an expensive learning curve that most boaters would rather not mess with.

The limp-home PTO from the genny is a GREAT idea!! I'd think that would require a pretty darn large ratio reduction gear to get the load equal to normal operating parameters. Could a "typically-sized" genny turn a diesel-size screw fast enough to afford a relatively big heavy boat decent steerage in any kind of seas, wind & current without too much power loss through the gears? Interesting.....
 
Probably because the hp needed is at the edge of capability for semi continuous operation unless you get to 10L size engines and they are big and tall. The albin boats do that at 30’ and 18 kts but 30 kts is another story
 
Google "Shannon SRD" would that fit your specifications? Although available in twins they will produce a single power option. I don't think any of his power options will get to the magical 30 knots though.
 
I noticed in a yachting magazine that the designers for the ocean going boats are shifting to twin engines instead of the single engine with a 'come home'. Increased stability and reliability seemed to be the primary reasons. But I'd take a single engine 44' Krogen is someone wants to get rid of theirs. Luck. Dale
 
limited market maybe the reason ?

besides the Shannon SRD (that's one nice boat !!! ) you also have the Hinckley picnic boats... the 36 will cruise at 25kts ona single 435 volvo, the 40 will cruise 30+ on twin yanmars...

We saw a georgeous red Hinckley yesterday at no name harbor... the lines on that boat are perfect ! pure beauty.

there are other semi customs builders of picnic/lobester style boats, not sure what the performances are...

not sure why anywone woudl insist on a single once you get into 35 to 40 LOA. sure, it's a little lighter but once you get close to 40 space shoudln't be a big issue as the boat gets beamy enough.

single diesels are great for economy... those who want performance wont' care much about economy.
 
30 knots is a bit rapid for an inboard boat with amenities and any pretense of fuel economy. If you can rein in your need for speed to the point where 22-25 knots is enough, then you will find that there are lobster type boats aplenty that have everything a cruiser could want. My understanding is that you can power a downeast hull to go 30 knots, but you won't like the handling. Another option might be a Carolina style hull. I am not sure how small you can go with one of those and still have it work, but many of the boats in the charter fishing industry out of the Carolinas have one big single diesel. These boats are typically 50' or so. Some of them cruise at 25+ knots.
 
There are a number of semi displacement boats in this category, but you are looking at 15 to 18 knots. Why take a large boat and go 30 knots? Range will be very limited (the more fuel the more weight and lower range)

Agree that prop pockets have a number of problems, as do surface piecing drive.

I don't see many long range boats going to twins--there have always been occasiona one, but I suspect the magazine article was more hype to promote a specific boat or class fo boast. Most are single, with a separate back up get home engine. The genset, requires either a large electric motor or hyraulics. Some get homes have a chain drive, when set right over the shaft. But having separate prop and shaft is a real advantage. I personally like a separate rudder on the wing engine. I know of one boat where this was counter rotating from the main, and could be used for maneuvering. A bow thruster is nice, but not at all essentail. I have done many thousands of ocean miles in single engine boats with no thruster--the times a thruster was essentail would be almost zero--a good kedge anchor or inflatable as a tug can accomplish the same thing in a pinch with a large boat.
 
That was a very interesting read. I was quite intrigued by the pocket vent that accomplishes a surface piercing condition in the pocket at vertually all speeds. Quite an amazing concept. I've seen it before but never paid much attention to what it's purpose was.

I believe it has/is a potentially revolutionary concept that may change boating sometime in the future. I can see Merc et al fighting it, though.
 
Back
Top