Bad fuel Question

dsmboosted

Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2008
RO Number
29579
Messages
97
I just bought a 34 foot 1989 Silverton. And started taking it home (a 100 mile journey). About 15 minutes in the starboard engine started cutting out at about 2000-3000 rpm. It would fluctiate from 3000 rpms and bounce to 200, then back up, then down, until it either died or we slowed to idle. The boat idles perfectly and runs perfectly, untill we get to the higher RPM's. The gas on the boat is over a year old (possibly 2 years old), so that has to be the problem.

My question: There is about 125 gallons of gas left in the 250 gallon tank (regular gas, not diesel). We are going to change all of the filter and plugs. Do you think we can add new gas to the old gas and it should be ok? Or should we siphen the 125 gallons out (ouch!!!, about $500-$600) and start from fresh???.

Please help me!!!

Zach
 
I have a 88 34 silverton with 350/270 crusaders - you probably have 454.
First question - do you have a manual fuel pump?
Second question - did you add anything to the fuel?

Dont rule out the engines ignition system yet!
 
If the port engine is running ok, I would suspect clogged filter on the starboard side. Did it help to change the filter?
 
quote:

Originally posted by Britanic

I have a 88 34 silverton with 350/270 crusaders - you probably have 454.
First question - do you have a manual fuel pump?
Second question - did you add anything to the fuel?

Dont rule out the engines ignition system yet!






First Question-
I am not sure if its manual or not? How do I tell? I know to start the boat I turn the key and pump the throttle a few quick times. (Man do I sound like a newbie!!)

Second Question- No, I did not add anything to the fuel yet. Its still sitting in the harbor. Is there something I can add?

What may be wrong with the engine ignition system?
 
If you do top it off with fresh gas, get the highest octane you can find.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Ted Williams

If the port engine is running ok, I would suspect clogged filter on the starboard side. Did it help to change the filter?






I believe there are 3 fuel filter on this engine. Its the crusader 454. Do I need to change all 3? Anything else I should change?
 
If the gas has phase-separated (which is highly likely), adding fresh gas will only exacerbate (new word) your problem. You can stick a copper tube to the bottom of your tank and get a sample: if it looks like italian dressing, you will need to pump out the old gas. When I had this problem, I had to pump the tanks and get the carbs rebuilt. Of course, you will need new filters.
 
Old (stale) or contaminated (water) gas may be the problem. But, until you can confirm it I wouldn't go adding new fuel to the tanks as you might make matters worse. Since it ran well at idle you should verify that you don't have vent line problems. Does it show the same problem running above 2000 rpm in neutral, or is it only under load? If you can duplicate the problem at the dock in neutral, try removing the fuel filler plate or cap and see if the problem remains (you could also do this running under load).

If you still believe it is bad fuel, the first thing to do is get a sample from the bottom of the tank to see what it looks like. Does it show water? What happens to it when you add known good gas to it? It may be best to get a good marine fuel service guy to do this for you.

What to do next depends on what you find along with the probability that the old gas contained ethanol. If it did and there is any sign of water or crud, your best bet would be remove all the old stuff, clean the tanks, change the filters and start over. If it has never seen any E-gas, then you might get by with removing the water alone, but doing so will be tricky. There was a recent and lively discussion on this in a recent thread, here:
http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=113427

If what's in the tanks looks alright, then I would change the filters and add a mix of Pri-G and Sea Foam, both at the maximum recommended dosing, and try running it then. If the problem abates or is resolved I would try to run as much of the old gas as I could out of the boat before adding new fuel. If the problem continues you might look elsewhere - fuel pump, carburetor, ignition, etc.
 
One other thing to consider, On the fuel line from the tank, there should be an anti-siphon valve. Thsi valave basially ensures that a pump is needd to pull fuel from the tank instead of a siphoning affect. These valves look like the hose connector and are usually a simple change for $15 or so.

I had very similar symptoms on my boat last summer. If I continued to try to run the engines, eventually the engine would not run due to vapor lock.

If you run the boat again, does it run at RPMs for a few minutes and then cut out? Or will it not run at load at all now? In my case, I coudl run the boat for about 15 minutes at speeed and then the engine would begin to stall. (rapid drop in RPM's then eventually stall)

You still need to look at the fuel and other areas but it is probably worth chanig out the anti-siphon valves in any case. My boat is a 1990 so the ages are similar.
 
How long have the old filters been in there & full tune-up been performed? If it has been quite a while, I'd dump the contents of the primary into a clear container and see what I was dealing with. If it looks good and smells like good gas I'd then pour it back into the tank through a clean cloth or paint filter, and change the primary for starters. No sense replacing fuel if it's just old filters.

You might also put an inductive timing light on the plug wires to make sure a cylinder isn't temporarily missing.
 
I had a similar problem when I picked up my Silverton 34C a few years ago. Replaced many things, fuel sep filters, filter on carb, plugs, cap rotor, fuel pump, etc, etc until I finally heard about the antisiphon valve at the tank. Took it off and cleaned it with choke and carb cleaner while pushing on the SS ball inside. Quite a bit of crud came out. Problem never came back. The cheapest, and easiest thing to do was the fix. Good luck!
 
Deifnitely sounds like a clogged filter (don't ask me how I know). Engine is starving under load, but idles fine. The filter would be the first thing I would check. Then go down the list of what everybody says in this thread, until it's cured. Good luck, and keep us posted.
 
quote:

Originally posted by wvorris

If the gas has phase-separated (which is highly likely), adding fresh gas will only exacerbate (new word) your problem. You can stick a copper tube to the bottom of your tank and get a sample: if it looks like italian dressing, you will need to pump out the old gas. When I had this problem, I had to pump the tanks and get the carbs rebuilt. Of course, you will need new filters.






When you say if it looks like italian dressign are you meaning italian dressing that hasnt been mixed (when the oil and vinegar seperates?) Or are you meaning chunky?
 
DSM, it still sounds like a clogged filter. Does the port engine run ok? Are both engines drawing from the same tank? Do the engines run ok at idle?

If the port engine is running fine using the same gas, then the gas is not the (worst) problem. I would change all 3 filters if you have them available.
 
Change all of the fuel filters. Classic symptoms you have.

If you have the pancake filter, clean it out, then change the canister filter, my Silverton has small Racors.

If you change them out now you now have a baseline and you know where you stand with them.
 
I had the exact same thing happen to me . I thought of all the scenarios that have been talked about here. I called a mechanic and he came out and took the ignition coil off and shook it. He said no oil in it. I didn't even know there was supposed to have oil in it. He changed it and it ran fine. No more going up to 3000 rpm and back down to 300 rpm. It was a real easy fix. I had all the things in my mind that would have cost big bucks. Change it. I have 454's 1985.
 
As others have said, you may have a few things going on in the fuel tank. Phase separation would be the worst, but your symptoms were the same as mine when I had water in the tank (I believe pumped to me from the gas dock) and the ethanol started scouring the varnish (old fuel) out of the tank. Multiple filter changes and I was fine.

I think phase separation would require you to empty the tank.
 
I have a 1990 34, like Xtasea I had the same issues 2 years ago. My issue was mixing ethanol gas with my old gas. The filters were clogged with water, debris and lots of other stuff from the tank. I put Racor filters on the engines so I could just drain the water out - I would highly recommed getting them. I then took the fuel tank sender out and put a tube down as far as it would go, and hand pumped as much water and gunk out as I could. Your fuel tank is 300 gallons single tank, on my boat the port side pickup is lower than the starboard, that is the engine that is always giving me trouble.
 
Since one engine runs OK and the other does not, it is highly unlikely that bad fuel is the problem.

Check all of the other items that have been mentioned and I will bet that you will then have two engines running OK.

G
 
Most harbors have a "fuel polishing" service (I do my own, with a Walbro pump and Racor filter)--basically the fuel is drawn from the bottom of the tank, and put back in the top. This should help to clean out any matter or water in the fuel. A year ago I purchased a boat which had 150 gallons of 3 year old gas (it did have Stabil--fuel stabalizer in it). I pumped the fuel all into plastic barrels thru a filter, and the back thru another filter. I took half of this fuel and burned it in my cars other boats etc...the other half was burned in the boat, after several filterings and then adding an equal amount of new gas--no problems.
 
Back
Top