battery question

sevo

Member
Joined
Jan 25, 2007
RO Number
25000
Messages
51
Still trying to figure out the electrical setup on my recently delivered SR 280. I have 3 batteries. 1 for port engine, 1 for SB engine and 1 for Generator. This weekend I thought that the SB batt was dead so I started it with the Port engine's battery using the crossover switch. (batt wasn't dead...i had batt switch only on 1 batt-dumb mistake) But when I tried to trim the SB motor up or down...the SB engine just shut down. The Port engine remained on. Did this happen because the SB engine was still running off the port batt and hitting the SB trim tried to access its own batt.
(by the way the other reason I thought the SB batt was dead was b/c there is a problemn with the SB shifter hitting Neutral EXACTLY so it was not letting me start the engine when I thought it was in N)
Any help would be MOST appreciated!!!
 
It's customary to run your engine on 1 battery... it was NOT a dumb mistake. My guess (but I'm not an expert on Sea Ray wiring) is that at least some your "house" loads (lights, stereo, etc) are on the starboard battery. Had you had your switch on "both" you could have killed both batteries.

It's possible that instead of the battery being dead you may have a loose connection. If it appears to be the shifter the switch in it may need to be adjusted, but this shouldn't cause the shutdown. I'd lean towards a loose connection somewhere. If the engine starts and runs OK on "2" then the problem is with "1". If you have the problem with both batteries then I'd check the wiring from the selector switch to the instrument panel and back.

From what you describe you have only 3 starting batteries and no dedicated "house" battery, which means that your lighting loads etc come off one of your starting batteries, IMO not the best plan. Personally I'd like to see a dedicated house battery bank to run the "house" loads so you don't risk killing the starters.
 
sevo

Why not post your issue on the SR forum? I'm sure you will get definitive answers to your problem there. Who knows SRs better then SR owners??? Good luck!
 
I was going to originally post it on the SR forum but thought that this battery configuration was common to alot of twin engine boats and would get more response from this forum.
I'll try the SR forum too.
Thanks for the input all...
 
Sevo,
My setup is the same for my Silverton 34C. I guess I should invest in another battery for the house. My shifters also have difficulty in finding the neutral position for starting sometimes.
 
Hey Silverton...
I have a question or two I'm sure you could answer then...
Do you mind if I email you?
donovansrna**yahoo.com
Thanks for the help
 
Sevo -

I pulled the manuals on the SR 280 couple of things came to light! First was it says in a couple of places DON NOT switch the battery switches while the engine is running as it will damage the alternator. Second both engines should start from number #1 battery. Since you mention that you are having issues with your neutral position switch that may indeed be your whole problem - The neutral position quadrant does have control neutral position so you don't start in gear - However it also does a second function which is a momentary interupt switch which shuts the engine down while shifting - The lower drive cable controls this quadrant if it where stiff or frozen when you trim the drive it would put pressure on the quadrant and engage the momentary interupt switch which would shut the engine down - If this is the problem you want to have it repaired DO NOT try it yourself as it requires special tools and pulling the drive - while you are there check the boots also!

Mike -
 
Sevo:

I can't quite picture your battery and switch setup so perhaps you could explain it better, more detail (especially of the type of battery switch you have).

I am going to take a guess:

One common battery and switch setup is to have a dedicated battery for each function with an ON/OFF battery switch, and then have an additional "crossover" switch. Thus, for a two battery setup you would have three switches.

If you have this type of configuration then what I think might have happened is that you didn't have the battery switch ON for the starboard engine.

See if this scenario fits:

You went to start the starboard engine and got nothing (because the switch was off). Thinking that the battery was dead you turned on the Crossover switch and then started off the Port battery. Once the engine was running you turned the Crossover switch to OFF.

That would have left the starboard engine running without a battery attached, which can destroy the alternator. The good news is that the alternator isn't totally destroyed because it would have been the only thing providing electrical power to keep the engine running. It could have been damaged, however, such that its maximum output is but a fraction of what it should be.

Okay, so the engine is running fine off the electrical power from its own alternator. The alternator had been regulated back to a very small output. Then you activated the trim motor, which suddenly put a large load on the electrical system. Without a battery in the system the sudden surge drags the voltage down to the point that the ignition system fails and the engine stalls.

Once the engine stalled all electrical to that engine would have been off until you changed the battery switch position.

Does that fit?

Bottom line, NEVER disconnect the battery from a running engine.

Rod
 
I can see about the same scenario with an "off-1-both-2" switch, if there is a bad connection to the #1 battery or if it is completely dead.

How old are the batteries? Sometimes a used-up battery will show a charge, but won't carry any load.
 
ABdiver your idea seems right on. I do have a 1-2-both-off battery switch. There are two things in the scenario that I still can't figure out.
Although I may have had the battery switch off to the SB engine I never touched the switch while an engine was running so hopefully I didn't damage the alt that way. The crossover switch automatically resets when you let it go so there is no way to keep it "crossed-over." So I am wondering why SR would wire it that way if running the engine off the other engine's battery would damage the alt. It seems realistic that activating the trim may have overloaded something but again why would SR allow it to be "crossed-over." if it would cause damage? It seems like that would be sacrificing an alt for a startup. Seems more appropriate to get the boat back on one engine if it were emergent.
Side point: the batteries are brand new as I just took delivery of the boat last week.
I think I should have gotten a tutorial from the dealer. I looked everywhere in the manuals and nothing addressed the issue.
I appreciate the brainstorming!!!
 
Sevo:

It sounds like the cross over is a helm station operated function that was intended to just get one engine started off the other engine's battery. They would have it deactivate immediatly so that you didn't accidentially leave it on and thus risk running both batteries down. If you wanted to have both batteries connected continuously then use the main 1-both-2 switch.

If the main battery to the starboard engine was turned off, and then started off via the cross over, then when the cross over deactivated it would be EXACTLY the same as turning the battery switch to OFF. Very bad for the alternator and could also be very bad for any electronics.

Running the engine with the Cross Over switch activated would not damage anything. Had the main battery switch for the starboard engine been turned on then everything would have been fine.

The trim motors didn't really overload anything. When the starboard engine was running without a battery attached then the only destination for the alternator current was to the ingition system and any other loads that may have been turned on. This probably was a very low amount, probably around 5 amps or so. The voltage regulator would have cut back the output of the alternator to regulate the voltage down to something reasonable. The voltage regulator and alternator do not respond instantly to voltage changes, it relies on the battery to either provide current for a quick surge or accept excess current when a heavy load is turned off.

Just prior to your operation of the trim motor the votlage regulator and engine were very happy with the minimal output of the alternator. Then you pushed a button and suddenly the trim motor wants 10 amps (perhaps more, stalled motors draw a lot of current). In an instant the current demand went from 5 amps to 15 and the altnerator can't provide it. The voltage drops to something very low, perhaps only a few volts. The voltage regulator sees this and wants to increase the alternator output, but there is one problem: It takes current to make current. The voltage regulator needs to drive more current into the field winding of the alternator so that it will start cranking out more amps. Unfortunately, the voltage source for the regulator has just been knocked down from ~13 volts to only a few volts and the alternator can't even continue producing the current that it had been. The result is that relatively minor surge current load just smacks the alternator output to zero and then the engine dies.

That scenario is "safe" in that it doesn't destroy anything. The opposite scenario is what can get you into a lot of trouble. Let's say that you had been running the engine off the alternator alone with the blower running. Let's say the engine draws 5 amps and the blower was drawing 10, so the alternator was providing 13 volts at 15 amps. Now you turn the blower off. 10 amps of load has suddenly been removed. Again, the voltage regulator won't respond immediatly so for a short period of time 15 amps will be forced down the throat of whatever is still on. If the load was pure resistive then the voltage would jump to three times the previous value, or 36 volts. If there was anything electronic in there, however, the current consumed may not increase linearly as the voltage increases so the voltage may jump much higher. It is possible that the voltage jumps to several hundred volts, enough to damage electronics, pop light bulbs or destroy the diodes in the alternator itself.

Bottom line: Do not operate your engine without the battery connected.

Rod
 
My "87 SR originally had only two batteries, one house and one starting. The emergency cross over is a relay that connects both banks together for emergency starting(duh) so that's why they call it that. The only change I've made was to install a second house battery paralleled. AS to why it stalled on you I could only guess the battery was weak and the alternator wasn't producing enough to drive the motor and ignition. This is possible with new batteries too.
 
My "87 SR originally had only two batteries, one house and one starting. The emergency cross over is a relay that connects both banks together for emergency starting(duh) so that's why they call it that. The only change I've made was to install a second house battery paralleled. AS to why it stalled on you I could only guess the battery was weak and the alternator wasn't producing enough to drive the motor and ignition. This is possible with new batteries too.
 
All is well...I had it checked and the SB battery switch was not connecting. So the scenario you provided was correct Rod! The alt continues to put out 14-15 Volts so we are assuming there is no damage.
I appreciate all the input! Amazing how much you learn when things go wrong as opposed to when things go right...
 
Back
Top