MacInCt,
Never saw a rat in any restaurant in Bimini.... there are several restaurants on the main road that serve excellent local seafood. Make sure that you have the cracked conch as it is excellent.
The night life scene has shifted down the road from the Compleat Angler to a new development on the site of the old Brown's Hotel. I hear that the bands from the Compleat are now playing down there. It is down by the End of the World bar so you can't miss it.
If Captain Bob's is not open for breakfast, try C.J.'s as a good second.
Also for dinner, the Bluewater restaurant has a great sunset view and decent food, there is also a very informal beach bar overlooking Radio Beach where you can have a strong rum and something + while you watch the sun sink into the Atlantic. Green flash opportunity. As I recall this is called Sherry's Bar.
The Bluewater Marina or the Seacrest are excellent places to stay aboard while you are in Bimini.
While you are there, take the time to travel south and visit Gun Cay and Cat. Snorkling is excellent along the way at Turtle Rocks and the concrete ship Sapona which you will be able to see from South Bimini.
Good snorkling at Honeymoon Harbour on Gun as well.
Don't know about the Berry's.
DaveS