Best dink engine?

JeffN

Active member
Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2001
RO Number
3672
Messages
1,369
Any opinions on what's the best 4-6hp engine these days? I'd consider a leftover model also. It should be light to schlepp a few 100 feet from water to car trunk also.
 
I have a 4hp Evinrude you can have... Not pretty but I'm pretty sure it runs. 2-stroke, weighs about 35#.
 
Get a motor that is light weight, has a built in gas tank and local service. Honda, Merc and Yamaha are the big players. Some like the Tohatsu/Nissan motors.

The Yamaha has a nice handle for carrying it from place to place.
 
A friend bought a Honda. It's a 2HP 4 stroke, less than what you want, but it is far lighter than competing models.

Honda outboards are a little hard to get because Honda expects them to be sold with a boat or rigged by a dealer. How do you rig a 2HP motor?
 
I love my Merc 5hp 2-stoke. I think it had the best hp to weight among all the 4-6hp models.
I've never used the internal tank and after 9 years of steady use, it still fires on the second pull, every time.
It'll plane out my Avon with just me and some gear, but I can still carry it easily with one hand.
 
I have a 12 year old Nissan 8hp 2-stroke. Runs great, starts every time.

I think just about any japanese 2 stroke will be a good choice.
 
I have a 4 hp Mariner 2 stoke and love the motor. I also do not use the internal tank.
 
I have a Honda 2HP, 4 stroke, and for me, the BIG thing is that it is air cooled. May run a bit noisier than a water cooled engine, but no flushing and no impellers to worry about.
 
I have a 3.5 hp Merc (Tohatsu) 2 stroke and 2.5 hp Suzuki 4 stroke as dinghy engines. Both are excellent engines and weigh about 30 lbs. These are easy to carry and put on the dinghy from the boat. This size of engine is good for dinghies at displacement speeds and will push an inflatable against most wind (don't go too small). If you want to go at planing speeds you will need to go to 8 hp (although 6 hp may semi plane)--and weights from 55 to 80 lbs.

Consider what you want-and if you want speeds over 5 knots. We find that 5 knots is fine for most of our dinghy use. In the past we have had 12 to 13 foot RIB's with 25 hp which were planing and suitable for longer on the water excursions.
 
Wow, lots of praise all around. I guess I may be pipe dreaming of having an 8-10 inflatable that'll carry 2 of us comfortably to tool around the river and town with a 6hp 50# engine. hull speed is fine I guess also with 2 of us.

The main limitation is that the boat will dry out, fold up and live in the condo with the motor in the car trunk(unless I can bribe the superintendant to store it in the maintenance area-too many condo commandos about though).

Merc 6hp is a Nissan/Tohatsu still? Shame to have to buy a foreign motor.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Roy

I have a Honda 2HP, 4 stroke, and for me, the BIG thing is that it is air cooled. May run a bit noisier than a water cooled engine, but no flushing and no impellers to worry about.






That's the one my friend bought. After seeing it, another friend bought one.
 
quote:

Originally posted by JeffN

The main limitation is that the boat will dry out, fold up and live in the condo with the motor in the car trunk(unless I can bribe the superintendant to store it in the maintenance area-too many condo commandos about though).






Storing gasoline inside a building can be a safety issue, especially in a multi family residence. If it can be stored where they store their lawn equipment (if they do their own lawn maintenance) you may be OK.

Remember, a four cycle engine has to be stored vertically or on one particular side only (spark plug up) so the oil won't run out. Two cycle engines don't have this problem.
 
"Best Dink engine?" as in cheaper or less messy?
The older Evinrude/johnsons are a little messy and stinky but they are undoubtedly the cheapest to come up with.

The newer Jap stuff is not messy or stinky at all. But its pretty expensive.

So now, which is better?
 
I saw a magazine last year that tested small outboards for dinks.
They rated Tahotsu(spelling???) the best, then Mecury which is made
by Tahotsu but it has a few more features and cost a little more.
The Tahotsu was rated best due to low noise, low cost, high
reliability, low vibration and ease of starting.
 
If you don't need a 4 stroke, you could get almost twice the horsepower for the same weight. A Johnson/Evinrude 9.9/15hp weighs around 75 lbs, compared to a 6hp 4 stroke at around 80-85 pounds. The 9.9/15s are abundant on ebay for about $300-800 depending on year and condition.

Dan
 
Thanks again all. I was hoping to stay under 60# so as not to shrivel a disk even further...and dep[endability is paramount also in the gator infested rivers...
 
quote:

Originally posted by JeffN

Thanks again all. I was hoping to stay under 60# so as not to shrivel a disk even further...





You know you can buy a cart for it. Still, 60 lb is a little much to fool with.
 
There is another possibility which will give you the best of all worlds--that is get an air floor inflatable--Use a 10'2" air floor boat, which will take up to 10 hp, and mount transom pneumatic wheels, Get a 2 stroke 9.9 hp outboard (probably have to be used) in the 75 lb range, and roll it right out of the SUV onto the boat with wheels--and you can roll that down to the water with very little weight on the bow handle of the inflatable-- The large pneumatic wheels are designed to be used with moderately heavy dinghies on sand beaches--and either detatch or swing up when you are in the water.

In your case, I would have a remote tank, and run the fuel out of the motor. That way the tank can be stored in a safe place--and no gas in the outboard.
 
Jeff,

I also have the Honda 2 HP. As mentioned,it's air cooled...a big plus. Another couple features I like (and the admiral loves) are:

1. Centrifugal clutch on the prop so the boat doesn't take off when the motor is started. The prop only turns when the throttle is increased.

2. The motor has no reverse gear. The tiller arm is engineered so you can spin the motor half-way, then while keeping your hand on the tiller, rotate the tiller arm/throttle to the other side of the motor and continue turning the motor to go in reverse. It sounds more complex than it actually is in practice...it's a seemless transition to reverse without taking your hand off the tiller. Great engineering.

I have this motor on an Achilles 9.6 with a wood floor. I've checked the speed on GPS and it easily hits 5 kts. A buddy with a Merc 3.3 on his 10' Achilles can beat me in a foot race, but not by much. 27 lbs, easy maintenance without an impeller, reliability and it burns a qt of gas an hour. That's about 20 miles per gallon! I'm loving this motor!!

BTW, I bought mine on craigslist for $475. The deals are out there.
 
quote:

Originally posted by HOGAN

I have a 12 year old Nissan 8hp 2-stroke. Runs great, starts every time.







Hogan,

How fast will the LEX-96 go with an 8 HP 2-stroke pushing it?
 
Back
Top