Blocking nightmare

BillyBo

Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2008
RO Number
29723
Messages
81
Last week I took my boat out of the water for the winter, I blocked the boat (310 Larson), stern and at the bow where the "SLING" sign is, after an hour or so we heard a loud crack, looked under my boat, the bow blocks had gone through the hull about 2" in and caved in about another 6". I was devistated, we got it jacked up and moved the blocks, I went into the boat to inspect interior, the colapse happened right where my fresh water tank was. Looking back, this was the worst possible place to put the blocks as there is no cross-member because of water tank, if I had went 18' either side of sling mark I would have been fine......
 
Something sounds very wrong here. How old is the boat? any pictures of how far back the blocks were?
 
Its a 95, after I took water tank out, it looked like there had been a patch in that area before.... no biggie, its fixed now.
 
No biggie??? sounds like a big deal to me. I'd be curious about the what the manufacturer recommends about blocks and sling indicators and location.
 
I am willing to bet that blocking and slinging are two different things. I would expect a minimum of 3 to 4 blocking points on the keel. One under the engines, and others at key points along the keel. How many blocking points did you have?
Was the landing soft, and is there any water intrusion?
 
It was only blocked 2 places 1 at bow, other at stern plus 2 stands
 
I agree Rommer, but as I said it was repaired before, I don't know the history...
 
We have a 28 ft. boat up in the yard right now. The boat yard has 3 blocks under it.
If it is blocked under the keel, there shouldn't be any damage. That is the toughest
area on the boat. There may be better places to block her, but anywhere along the keel
should have been good.
 
Sling locations are ONLY for load balance. They do not tell the viewer if there is any structural material in that location. DO NOT use those locations expecting there to by any structure behind.

G
 
quote:

Originally posted by BillyBo

Its a 95, after I took water tank out, it looked like there had been a patch in that area before.... no biggie, its fixed now.





Fixed now? How is it fixed now?...
 
Had my fiberglass guy re-inforce it all, stronger now than ever before
 
Paranoia time for me now... An hour ago I hauled my 310 ('05) and had it trailored to the house. She's blocked at the stern and 3 feet forward of the "lift" point. I have 3 sets of stands - one set at the stern, one at the forward lift point and the third set at the bow. All's looking fine so far...
 
Shouldn't you have two points of support at the stern and two more further up forward? That is what I have seen, but I have no experience with this issue.
 
The patch would make me suspicious that this has happened before with that hull.

But as for blocking at sling points - as someone mentioned, these are mostly for the hoist operator to have an idea of the most stable points to hoist from - if his slings are on those points, you would HAVE to block elsewhere, unless he didn't mind leaving the sling pinned between the keel and the blocks all winter. Many larger boats have blocking plans figured by a naval architect that tell you exactly where the incumbent force of gravity can safely be focused without punching the hull. Absent a blocking plan, it takes some consideration to avoid doing so. Lot of weight focused on small area.
 
Blocking should be placed every 10ft or so with a min of 3 sets. Larger the blocks the better as well, since the smaller ones concentrate the load on a smaller contact point. For my 30', I'm not blocked at the sling points.
 
quote:

Originally posted by gcolton

Sling locations are ONLY for load balance. They do not tell the viewer if there is any structural material in that location. DO NOT use those locations expecting there to by any structure behind.

G






This isn't correct. Sling locations align with internal bulkheads that add rigidity at that point.
 
Um, I think I'd have a cow if this happened to a boat of mine!
 
Pixs and/or exact discription of type/size of blocks and position of all supports would help determine what went wrong.
 
whiskywizard
You are incorrect...the sling marks on my boat are DIREECTLY in line with the fresh water tank as I explained earlier, there is NO bulk head or support of any kind at that point, in fact, that is the only area on the boat that does not have any cross supports within the 5 foot length of the fresh water tank.
 
Back
Top