acboyd, did you see my thread in the "Ask the Captain" forum? I just restored my finish this past week. I used 3M Heavy Duty Compound, 3M Finesse-It II and Waxing Frenzy wax, plus another compound which you shouldn't need. I'm certainly not saying what you may use is not right, I'm just a true believer in the 3M products and the Waxing Frenzy wax.
Also, you need to have a seperate terricolth application pad (don't use a rag) for each step. If you use the same pad for each step you risk getting the products mixed together on the next step. Use a wet application pad for the compound, a dry for the polish, and a wet one for the wax (unless the manufacturer's directions differ.)
Buffing pads? You need good pads to get good results and the right pad for the right application. I use the 3M Superbuff pad for compounding (it's white) and the 3M Superbuff Polishing pad for the polish and wax (it's yellow). Although the yellow will work for the compounding, the white "cuts" better. And don't forget to "score" your buffing pad on occasion so it's clean and fluffy.
Good luck!
MardiGrasTexan