Bunk versus Roller Trailers

psugar

Member
Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2002
RO Number
8116
Messages
527
Advantages/disadvantages?

27ft Chesapeake Deadrise with Inboard.
 
Depends on how you launch/retrieve. I was taught to never get the bearings wet. Accordingly, a roller trailer with at least a geared down manual winch and preferably a power winch was the optimum setup. A (good) roller trailer will self center the boat. I have seen folks even set the power winch at the end of a block and tackle arrangement to lessen the stress on the winch.

You indicate an inboard boat so you may be limited to a skid trailer. I have never seen a roller trailer made for inboards. Doesn't mean they do not exist, I have just never seen one.

If you retrieve by powering onto the trailer, it doesn't matter which type you have. Bush league is bush league as it eventually destroys the ramp.
 
I fear that rollers will concentrate stress on certain parts of the hull where the rollers come into contact with the boat, but I have no experience with this, so take that with a grain of salt.
 
I live a block from the water, hence I won't be using too much, however, the storage fees versus a trailer behind my house end up giving me an ROI of less than two years.

Looked at used, but like pickup trucks these things hold their value and since they can be used very hard new is better.
 
i bought mine without a trailer and couldn't find a used one. the local manufacturer, magnum, said it was cheaper to go through a dealer to buy one as they protect their distributors by charging more. i was in the same situation with water close by, the cheaper gas helps pay for the trailer too.
 
Yes, off road diesel at $2.49 a gallon right now 1 mile from my house from a BP that sells it to farmers by the truckload, doesn't hurt either.

I'm in a unique situation....easy walking distance to a free boat ramp, perfect space behind my house, slips are in very tight quarters, free public docks for overnight usage, lottery for really cheap town docks, so I don't think it is going to be all that more inconvenient.

The paid docks are $2,500/season which is really reasonable but then factor in winter storage, and we're talking 1 year payback, new trailer is $3,400. Guy selling them says I want bunks for that boat. I really wanted to keep in the water, but its not like I am going to hang out on the boat at the marina (that's why I have a nice house), or lose that much time launching,

I found used ones were at least $1,500, then you have to modify a bit, etc, etc...so for about $1,000 difference you have a brand new trailer with a warranty....what a difference from a boat where you lose 5 figures out the door.
 
Had both. Bunk trailer is the only one in my future.
Saw a couple launching a 23 foot cruiser with a roller trailer. Disconnected cable and safety at the top of the ramp. You can imagine what happened next. Two tow trucks to lift it back onto the trailer.
 
bunk trailers all of the way.

you can get bearings wet, just get bearing buddies and bras...you will be good to go.
 
A properly set up roller trailer will support your boat better than a bunk trailer. eventually the only points of support on a bunk trailer are at the brackets.

I have both. Never unhook the boat from a roller trailer until it's in the water.

I just had a tubular EZ-Loader trailer rust out so I cut it up and made up a combination roller/bunk trailer. Bunks for the stern and roller for the bow. It does help center as you pull out of the water.
 
I had a EZ Loader aluminum bunk trailer with tandem axles. I would drive the boat onto the trailer almost the whole way. In the Keys the shallow ramps gave us some trouble off loading because of friction on the bunks. I changed the seals and repacked the bearings each year. With EZ loader it is CRITICAL to use their seal. The others will leak and pit the axle surface. Had bearing buddies as well. No problems ever.
 
Bunks better than rollers but the combo setup above worked the best for me.
 
I have a bunk trailer to tow a 26 foot CC with twins. I don't think I've seen more than two roller trailers down here on the Gulf Coast. I put my trailer all the way in the water until my rear truck tires are getting wet. And it couldn't be easier to just take the bow rope and pull it right into place on the trailer. The winch strap hasn't been rolled out more than two feet and I really don't pull any stress on it because the boat is already in place when I hook it up.

I have seen some funny things when watching some people attempt to load their boats, some way smaller than mine.

I have read boat manufacturors recomendations which if I remember correctly stressed not to use roller trailers. If I remember correctly you can check the users manuals for the Hydra Sports boats online. I believe that's where I saw it.
 
Bunks it is. I found a one guy shop in Baltimore that sells a TON of trailers cheap. Checked his references with the manufacturer Venture said he was great.

Sells an aluminum trailer with mag wheels for $1k less than everybody else sells galvanized with galvanized wheels.

He wouldn't bad mouth galvanized either. Said they'll last just as long. Its a cosmetic deal, and he moves a ton of aluminum. He said he would only bad mouth painted.
 
Phil -

What is the name of the shop / guy in Baltimore? We might get a new trailer next spring. Our is painted and rusting from the inside out. It came with our used boat that we bought from a fresh water area. But, we frequently go in salt. We're looking for galvanized or aluminium. I think the one advantage of aluminum over galvanized is less weight to tow. Other than that, they're probably both good.

Thanks.
 
Bunks for my inboard ski boat. Had to replace a rotten bunk not long after getting the boat, but it was pretty easy. Docked the boat after skiing one day, my ski buddy helped me take the old one off and put the new one on. I cut it to length and covered it with carpet beforehand so it was just a matter of removing the old one and bolting the new one on. Have to make sure to use lag bolts that do not poke through the top side of the bunk.

The launch I use handles mainly inboard/v drive boats so the concrete extends far enough into the water that power loading does not damage anything.
 
I purchased a Venture tandem axle bunk trailer rated for 7200 lbs. Last fall. I used it several times this year and had no issues launching or retrieving the boat. My only issue was the pole the winch mounts on was too high and I had to cut a foot off of it. You can't beat the price either. I shopped used and found nothing in decent shape, then I found this trailer much cheaper than most other brands. I paid $3150 and they fit it for my boat.

MJK
 
David Schmitt, EMI Marine, 717.577.7451 emiwiz at msn.com

Called Venture. Receptionist new him instantly said he is good.

Called other places all wanted to sell me venture trailers but for much more...can't be any difference in the trailer and they say he is good.

Told me he sold his other marina businesses and is a one man shop and loves not managing anybody and makes as much money. I like people that don't try to pretend they are something they are not and most people are hesitant to admit look I am the sales guy, the delivery guy, marketing guy, receptionist, accountant, etc....but he came right out and said it an why.
 
KiDa says: "Depends on how you launch/retrieve. I was taught to never get the bearings wet". If that is the case,how would you ever get the boat off the trailer?
 
Back
Top