Chartplotter vs. PC

HarlenW

Member
Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2007
RO Number
25699
Messages
473
I am looking at navigational tools. An important decision is whether to use integrated chartplotters like Raymarine or a computer based system running navigation software like Nobeltec. The system would be installed in a pilothouse.

It seems to me that using a PC allows one to upgrade to the latest software more easily and cheaply than the integrated systems since you don't have to buy the hardware at major upgrade time. The initial cost seems less, too, though I know a marine capable monitor is needed.

What type of system have you used and what is your preference?

Thanks.
 
Neither one is a "navigational system" but rather a tool, just one of the tools that could be used. Paper charts, a compass, knowledge of speed, and a watch are the most important. That said, I would get the chart plotter.
 
depending on your use, an old laptop with the software might be the ticket. i use mine as a spare on offshore trips. make a real nice battery operated chartplotter.
 
With the PC the chartscan be downloaded for free and you can always have the latest version of the charts. With a chartplotter the charts are out of date as soon as you buy them and it costs a lot to get updated charts.
With the PC software you can print the latest chart on demand and hence have the paper and the plotter.
Trip plannning with the PC is much easier.
 
I use a laptop as a trip planner and back up only. I would hate to wait for a reboot under the wrong circumstances.
 
We've been grappling with this same subject. Our boat needs a new chartplotter; I wanted to get a Northstar 6000. But my wife bought a laptop, Maptech Pro, a bluetooth GPS receiver, and a wireless internet card. We used it recently on our trip to RI. My wife planned our entire trip on the laptop weeks before we left. We usually travel with other boats who always do the planning. This time we felt we had more control over our trip.

During the cruise we found that the laptop is versatile; one can watch DVDs, get e-mail and surf the web, plan routes for side trips, etc. when not underway (or even underway if you need to). The major problems we found with the laptop is daylight viewing and short battery life. In a trawler pilothouse, these issues probably almost become non-issues, but for our current boat we're now contemplating a marine display that will fit into the spot currently taken by the old Cetrek Chartnav connected to the laptop, and an inverter.

So I have come to change my mind about a PC onboard. I suspect that when we eventually get our trawler we'll have both a desktop and a laptop, although I'd still like a Northstar or Raymarine unit as a backup.
 
BillyIII
The paper charts are the backup if you need a reboot.

I find that the PC gives a great deal of flexibility on routing as you can drag a waypoint while the route is active if needed. This allows to offset a route from the direct route between turning points if there is a large volume of traffic. Some routes on the chesapeake have boates every hundred yards following the same route. All I do is offset my routes to avoid the direct path adn everything passes several hundred yards away. To do the with a chart plotter is not as easy.

Since marks are often reset every year after the freeze is over, most chartplotter charts get out of date quite fast. I just download the updated charts each spring.
 
I have and use both a laptop running Maptech "Offshore Navigator" and the 2005 version of Raymarine's chart plotter. The Raymarine is useful for the bigger picture. When I want detail, like the ICW or harbor entrances, I use the laptop. On the Meridian 408 its fairly well protected but on the Bayliner 265 the computer is below, out of the spray, but feeding a cheap but sunlight readable monitor.

The laptop I have anyway, the monitor is $140 and the Maptech program and charts from Nantucket to Key West and ALL the water inbetween is less than $1000. My normal travel has been from Atlantic City past Key West to the Dry Tortugas plus excursions to the Bahamas.

I find no choice between the PC and the Plotter. I find the plotter remarkably inadequate.

And I have the program, charts and tides loaded on computers at home, at work as well as on the boat in NJ and the boat in FL.
 
For use at the helm ( or if I have a choice of only one device ) get the chartplotter, as it is designed for maritime (ab)use.

For a second unit, in an enclosed compartment, on a "slow vessel" or one that does not get the pounding of a go fast, a properly equipped PC is quite desirable.
 
I agree with Bill's comment, I have a Raymarine E-80 at the helm and a laptop running Chart Navigator Pro (aka Coastal Explorer) below. When the conditions get tricky it's MUCH better to have the weather-resistant chartplotter at the ready. But for doing what-if route planning it's hard to beat the flexibility of a PC. That and the hard-buttons on the chart plotter are much less distracting to use on a regular basis that fiddling around with a mouse (or, worse, a touchscreen).
 
One aspect of a PC not mentioned, is it's importance recording maintenance and repairs. If you are keyboard friendly, a PC/laptop is very useful in scheduling preventative maintenance and recording maintenance performed. It is very easy to track spare parts inventories and locations. All that is needed, is a basic word processor program.

That it can be used a a navigational tool, is a bonus. Jay
 
HARLEN: Our new set up is Ray.E120 in PH and E80 up above both being independant. I drive PH withlaptop using Nobeltec, and have bluetooth to all flat screens in boat if desired. I like the quickness of the laptop for redraw, and various info when needed. I realize this is redundant, however three seperate systems, that all can talk together, along with paper as my old backup.
 
Dusty,

Sounds like a great setup. I am not that familiar with Bluetooth can you tell me how that works in your setup? Do I understand you correctly that your laptop can communicate with your E120 and E80? Also, do you have the SeaTalk network for the Raymainre units?

Thanks.
 
Harlen: I have SeaTalk, and my bluetooth off the comp. will send info to the flat screens and also my cell phone. It is a PDA type, so it rec's. signals, and will actually show chart on phone. My eyes are too old to see it though !! I am considering the new G or F series, however I understand it just a larger monitor for alot more $. Our new HP comp. will put a touch screen 19" in the pilothouse, so I probably won't spend the $ for the Raymarine. A new review was just done at Panbo on them, but I haven't read it yet.
 
If the only choice is between the chartplotter or a laptop go with the Chartplotter. I run both a new Northstar 6100I and a laptop 17" screen using Nobeltec 8.1 along with Tides & charts. Although there is much more you can do with the laptop I find it's not practical to use underway. Screen is delicate, mouse moves are too much to fast. One wrong touch & start over or figure out what happened? Not at all good underway...The Northstar is just FANTASTIC underway. I do use the laptop for trip planning and looking around at where I'm going at home & it's very helpful but as an addition to a real good chartplotter. PS - The Northstar 6000I is all you need. The extra 3D of the Northstar 6100i is not enough to warrant the extra cost IMHO. Cute but not important unless you're an avid fisherman?
 
Go for it guys, hope you're not around me. You have to know where you are, unless you keep track, when the plotters give up, where are you.
 
We have both. A C-80 Chartploter and a Motion computing tablet PC with a bluetooth GPS as a back up. Trips are plannded on the PC and transferred to the chartplotter. While underway, the PC runs as a back up. If all else fails, the paper charts are at hand. The tablet is small enough to stand up at the helm if the need woudl arise. Usually, it is running on the cockpit table. We started running a PC on board about 5 years ago and now would not go out without it just as we wouldn't go out without a chartbook onboard.
 
Jim, is your knowledge of using chartplotters as good as your knowledge about what the song YMCA is about????

Always carry a paper chart, compass, etc, as a backup.....but why not use the best technology you can????? Think we still use NDB's for aircraft?????

Nobody here as said lets only use a computer etc.....what's the issue???

Does new fangled radar suck as well???

You scare me.
 
Which GPS works best with a Laptop and Maptech chart navigator. Has anyone used this combo?
 
Back
Top