Chartplotter vs. PC

I use the Garmin NRoute PC system in the pilothouse which is where I run the boat 95+% of the time – I use the GPS18 puck stuck to the windshield

I have multiple Laptops with the software loaded so that if I have a issue with one I can hot swap them – I have never needed to do so
I also have a couple of NorthStar 951’s as backup – I usually have them displaying ‘other’ data such as Knts/ Latitude and Longitude etc - And yes I do have paper charts of wherever we’re going

I think under these conditions the PC setup beats the Chart Plotter hands down-HOWEVER if on the bridge or on a express style boat I would use a Garmin 4000x/5000x or a NorthStar 6100x
 
Quote: "Which GPS works best with a Laptop and Maptech chart navigator. Has anyone used this combo?"
I would think that any Garmin with a USB interface would work fine. I have one that I use with my laptop and The Cap’n. I forget the model number; it’s down on the boat. There are also very basic GPS units with no readout, probably the cheapest way to go.

As a bonus, you can also use it on the road with Microsoft Streets & Trips but you have to add a small program to convert the USB input to the serial format. I use Franson GPS Gate and it works fine. I find it very odd that this Microsoft product can’t use a USB input directly.
 
I've had experience with both the PC and chartplotter. I prefer the chartplotter. There's nothing more frustrating that trying to work a keyboard or do a reboot underway.

A few other observations:

EVERY chart is out of date, electronic or paper.

Everyone says paper charts are THE backup, but they're no substitute for common sense.

If you like to screw around with the PC, downloading charts and fighting the occasional conflicts with operating systems, drivers and other programs, get a laptop; otherwise, a chartplotter might be your best bet.
 
I have both a chartplotter (Garmin) and a Thinkpad loaded with an older (cheaper) Nobeltec version. Both have advantages and disadvantages. Rather than pick one, I feel best having both on board, just in case.

-Greg
 
GABoy, Maptech and others sell a GPS puck for about $115 which gets its power from the USP port. I run that for Offshore Navigator as well as MS "Streets and Trips" when on land.

Reboot?? I didn't think anyone had to do that anymore. Whadda you running, Windows 98?

When underway, the Maptech doesn't need any keyboard or mouse (should be trackball if necessary) input. It keeps your vessel centered and switches charts as necessary.
 
quote:

Originally posted by rbmitchell

GABoy, Maptech and others sell a GPS puck for about $115 which gets its power from the USP port.




This is what I use, Less than $110 from boatfix
http://www.boatfix.com/cart2/Scripts/prodView.asp?idproduct=4963

16476.gif
 
quote:

Originally posted by eclips

I use a weather-resistant/convenient daylight viewing Raymarine "C" chartplotter at the helm. But to create my routes, I use the free version of the Raymarine planner software:

http://www.raymarine.com/raymarine/Default.asp?site=1&Section=2&Page=1535&Parent=710

and this unit to transfer routes, waypoints, etc...between the chartplotter and my laptop:

http://www.raymarine.com/raymarine/ProductDetail.asp?site=1&SECtion=2&page=714&product_id=3752






I am playing around with the free Raymarine Planner and my maptech Navigator info. Unfortunetly it doesn't appear that the maptech exports the correct file format, so I've reformated the excel file and it does then work.

anyway.... do you NEED the card reader or can't I just save the correct file (they also have a utility program to do this) on a CF card, plug it in the C80, and import the data?

I guess I'm a litte confused on using the special Navionics reader (except that it will read the Chart cards maybe?)

I am a Garmin guy, but just got the C80 on a different boat.

thanks.
 
Can you interface a laptop to an autopilot to have the autopilot follow a route?
 
Depending on the software, yes you can. I interface my autopilot from time to time with "Offshore Navigator" by Maptech... Generally though I prefer to keep them separate; watch the plot and make my adjustments manually. I get fewer surprises that way.
 
What's the interface between the PC and the autopilot? I love using my autopilot to follow a course. It lets me keep my eyes ahead more of the time, instead of having to keep looking at the plotter or compass to make sure I'm on course.
 
The interface will depend on the equipment you have. I'm using the old NMEA0183 format working through the serial port on the computer. Once you figure out how to hook it up you have to make sure the computer software is sending out the "sentences" that the autopilot is listening for. It's a matter of reading (and following) directions, mostly. However I'm not sure it's worth the trouble at least not in my case. It only takes a few seconds to check the plotter and compass and if necessary bump the autopilot over a few degrees. The rest of the time I'm just kicking back keeping a lookout. That way I stay in the "loop".
 
We are using a hand held Garmin that is plugged into an HP laptop which is running SeaClear software and we downloaded the NOAA charts (my wife uses this setup). I have my Garmin 2006 chartplotter wired in to a Dell laptop that runs Maptech Navigator Lite. We also have a Furuno GPS running by its self. All of this is on our enclosed flybridge. We also have paper charts (Maptech, Richardsons, etc.) Sound like a lot of overkill? Well it may be, but we just completed 3,000 plus miles from Kenosha, Wis. to Solomons Island, Md. and now are on the way to Florida. To quote another member, my 2 cents.
 
I have used both (and still do). I prefer two chart plotters--one on large scale and the other on small scale. Separate depth sounder/fishfinder (for bottom contours and degree of shoaling), Plus a separate Radar. This gives more screen area and both good visual view of the charts and excellent detail. I prefer the chart plotter and radar to be just off the straight ahead vision. That way I don't have to look around to find the screen.

The chart plotters are made to be a chart plotter, they have better screen dimming and different colors for night running. (although this can be done on PC's). You just push dedicated keys or soft keys--no working with arrows and mouses etc. Not distracting as the PC can be. I have yet to have a chart plotter crash (cannot say that for PC's). You can get "updated" charts in all of the formats. But just because the chart is down loaded from an internet ENC--it does not mean that the survey is the latests--many NOAA charts are based on survey's 30 years old. The chartplotter chart chips are more likely to be corrected by user input. Also many of the chart chip manufacturers use other than NOAA chart sources--such as the Lewis charts of the Abacos. The redraw time and quilting is better on chart plotters than PC's in general.

I use the PC more for planning--and it is on the boats--but not the primary navigation tool--it is a secondary--and the paper charts/compass/sextant is the tertiary back up.
 
The question was asked about which gps disc to use. I've used Garmin's along with it's Scanner program. Unfortunately, that combo has caused freezes from time to time. Also, there is the hassle of putting the disc outside the car or boat.

I got a better solution now. I have just bought Sprints broadband service for $59.99/mo. along with their USB card for $29. Nothing remarkable there, except that it serves as a very efficient GPS receiver. It works beautifully on both MS Streets and Nobeltec.

No more hockey puckin.

-Greg
 
Isn't it an advantage of chartplotters that you can mount them at the helm, where it's a quick glance down from looking ahead while underway, whereas a laptop has to be sitting on a horizontal surface that on most boats is not in as good a place?

Also, many brands of chartplotters can interface with your radar, allowing radar overlay on the chart, which is a nice feature.
 
That is one of the advantages; the average laptop would NOT be at home on an exposed fly bridge or a center-console boat. However most larger boats with an enclosed wheelhouse have room for a laptop or even a regular PC, and the big screen that you get with the computer is NICE.

The advantage of the laptop is it's price and versatility; you can keep your logs on it, go online for updated charts, maybe even check email, surf the net or watch a video when you're NOT underway. Mine is also connected to a rear-view TV camera. As far as interfacing with radars and other equipment, that's all a matter of the software. I don't doubt you can find software that will do what you want.

My laptop (an old Gateway) even in it's dimmest setting can sometimes be too bright. When that's the case I simply set the backlight to time out in one minute. After that the screen goes dark; no problem. If I want a look I just tap the spacebar and the light comes back on, for a minute.
 
I use nobeltec and have the garmin software that came with the charts. Between the two, Nobeltec is more intuitive and easier to use. Especially when laying down routes. I use the garmin hand held GPS 76C to drive the PC, and it's an IBM T31/W2000.
We have a furuno plotter/radar unit and I wish I had just bought radar. The only tricky part about using the laptops is mounting them. In a pilot house it's relatively simple but up on the fly it's a pain. I have yet to find a mount that I am comfortable with.
 
quote:

Originally posted by stmbtwle

However most larger boats with an enclosed wheelhouse have room for a laptop or even a regular PC, and the big screen that you get with the computer is NICE.




Like this :D
gps.jpg
 
Back
Top