CO2 Detectors problem?

Capt. Art

Active member
exMember
Joined
Apr 17, 2007
RO Number
25924
Messages
1,538
I have 3 hard wired detectors with no batteries inside them that I can see to run low. I notice that even if the boat was not run for 3 days (no possible CO2) they can go off? I think if one is bad it may set off all 3. It also may be the hot interior that sets it off? I'm trying to determine what it causing these to Error signal as I don't want to keep disconnecting them when I leave the boat. I want to fix this to again have confidence in the signal if it goes off. Now, I always think it's another error? How can I check these?
 
It is actually a CO detector, not CO2.

Low battery could cause them to go off. Also, CO from another boat could get into your cabin, even if your boat is off, and set them off.
 
I'm pretty sure no other boat is doing it. I'm going to check all the boat batteries ? Other then that any other suggestions? Maybe I'm making those drinks too strong?
 
Off gassing can set them off and/or injure the sensors, so I would think that a) yes, the increased heat might initiate the alarm, and b) if the sensors are "old" you might need to replace them. Check w/ the manufacturer site for sensor replacement times, but it is ( imho ) fairly often.

Don't forget, cleaning supplies and curing plastic are sources for false positives...
 
if all three are going off, i'd suspect low voltage... by hard wired you mean that they are connected to your DC system, right ? not part of a central alarm which could maybe trigger an alarm in all of them.

i doubt gassing is an issue on a 6 year old boat, cleaning supplies (or hard drinks:-) ) woudl not affect all three unless whoever cleans spray tons of cleaners everywher !!

sounds like a voltage issue to me... measure voltage when you leave the boat and again when the detectors go off. how old are your batteries ? it's possible that your charger has a problem and that the house batteries are the first one to go... depends on how the boat is setup. The starting batteries may not loose voltage so your engines / genset fire up easily, then recharge the house bank form the alternators...

first thing is to check voltage and charger output on all 3 (?) output terminal.
 
CO detectors do age and cleaners and air sprays seem to harm them. If you suspect low voltage that is easy enough to measure but all of mine went bad after 3-4 years and would go off after a few hours of being turned on with no engines in the area. I suspect some spray stuff but just replaced them and that ended the problem.
 
If they are over 5 years old, go to a hardware store and get new ones that take 9 volt batteries. They are about $40 each for a decent one. If you are a purist, "A proper marine CO detector, incidentally, will have the UL 1524 marine mark, which means it was tested by Underwriters Laboratories standard 1524." (BoatUS.org) I think 1524 may be dated though.
 
Interesting NEW development - all my DC Power died? Neither my Shore Power or Genny won't even turn on my DC lights, bilge pumps etc.
I think a connection is corroded? On the good side I think this is the problem why my CO Detectors were going off & if you read my older Ice Maker HAUNTED this folks is probably the elusive answer to all these questions? I have the mechanic on call so I hope I'll have all these problems solved once & for all. This is really a welcome problem? Especially, that it happened at the dock.
 
"I think a connection is corroded? "

i doubt it... well, i guess it's possible, but it sounds to me like your charger is out... a bad connection could result in low voltage, but not no voltage... follow the wire from the charger but check the charger output first. is there an indicator light, a voltmeter, an ammeter on it ?

start your engines (the starting banks shoudl be isolated and still charged), you alternator should recharge the batteries...

normally icemakers are AC, not DC, so it shouldn't have anythign to do with a charger problem...
 
if everything died the batteries or battery connections must be the issue. Easy to chgeck with a hydrometer and a voltmeter across each connection while current is flowing. V should =zero.
 
I appreciate the help & direction. Personally, I don't have a clue? As soon as I can find out the cause I'll do an update. The reason I thought it may have been a corroded wire was that shortly after I had put a binder on the boat, I had a complete power loss of all the bridge helm controls. It turned out that the main power bar to the bridge had a ground corrode. The captain got real close to the barrier wall before he regained control from the lower helm.
 
i can't imagine corrosion on a 6 year old 50 footer being an such an issue that you loose all DC !!! most 37 year old connections on my boat that are still clean ...

what do you mean "put a binder on the boat" ?

it could be a number of thing... even a melted battery terminal... but chances are your batteries are dead because the charger isn't off/out
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Art

I had a complete power loss of all the bridge helm controls. It turned out that the main power bar to the bridge had a ground corrode. The captain got real close to the barrier wall before he regained control from the lower helm.






Is your steering by wire in addition to your throttle/gear shift?

I have a Morse electronic throttle and shift on my boat. It has two separate power sources for redundency. If one of the power inputs should drop below acceptable levels it will continue to operate off the other but it will complain loudly!

If both power input were to be lost, switching helm stations wouldn't help at all.

I am curious what system your boat has that could have a single failure result in loss of control.

Rod
 
I agree distributed electrical problems should not exist. Look for a common problem but after you fix it spray everything with corrosion pro.
 
Please take this in the spirit is is meant. You need to understand what is going on in your boat, and not depend on a mechanic or electrician. Buy one of the books on boat electrical systems, or Nigel Calder's Boat Owners Mechanical and Electrical guide. Learn to trace out circuits in the 12 volt DC system. Buy a decent digital volt meter and learn to use it. The reason is that electrical problems (as well as mechanical) can strike at any time--even with a new boat. It may be in a situation where you cannot get vessel assist or a mechanic immediately. I consider being able to trouble shoot systems right up there with learning the rules of the road and boating safety.

You might start by observing the "mechanic" and see what he does. I also keep one AGM battery, totally isolated, so that if for some reason I loose power, I can use this battery with jumper cable/wires to run the critical systems on the boat. Especially if you have "fly by wire" controls, you need to have back ups quickly available.
 
I understand your suggestions. Only the DC system was out. Both the Genny & engines run in spite of all else being out. It only would effect the house battery DC systems. I still have all my electronics, refrigeration, engines, generator etc. The boat is very well equiped with redundant systems. But, here is what we found learned tonight...

UPDATE _ UPDATE _ UPDATE - It does appear the batteries for the house was fully discharged. We learned the dock had an outage. We don't know for how long? The whole boat was left on with the inverter & shore power working to make ice, water pressure head vaccume. We think the power outage went on for a while & drained the House Batteries. The inverter was not getting any shore power going to the boat. Once shore power was restored since the systems were left on there was too much draw & it was overloading the charger? Shutting most things off appear to allow the charger to start working (I'll know more in the morning).This is as far as we could get tonight.
Question- My current charger is a Freedom 25 marine 2500 watt 130 AMP charger. Model 81-2511-12 (212). If this charger is working properly shouldn't it work & not overload even with everything turned on? I'm thinking Pascal is right & it's the charger? Should I just replace it anyway ? Even if everything appears ok in the morning?
 
i have a freedom 30, operation is completely automatic... dockside power shuts down, inverter comes on line... power comes back on, it switches to charger mode.

Mine is connected to a dedicated inverter bank, so when that bank drops to below a certain voltage the inverter shuts down to protect the battery bank.

My house bank (32v) is not completly independent and charged by another charger.

What i suspect in your case is that when the inverter sensed voltage was getting too low, it shut down. Other house loads like CO detectors, bilge pumps, vacuflushes, maybe your fridge if dual voltage, brought the bank to 0. When power came back, the inverter/charger didn't sense enough voltage to switch back to charger mode. I dont' remember off hand but i think i saw something in the manual mentioning that... not sure.. double check.

If that's the case, the inverter should be fine but your batteries probably took a hit from being completly discharged.

It's not an overload issue, the charger will have no problem with the loads, i think it's just that it sensed no voltage and didn't go into charge mode.

If so, it's an ideal setup. is it a factory install ? I'm surprised that you have a 12v system (judging by the model nr) on a 50 something footer and diesels. Usually larger boats have higher voltage DC systems... Hatteras went even further with 32v but' i'd expect 24v on any 50 footer. the reason it's not ideal is that you want the charger to re charge the batteries when power comes back on... that keeps the bilge pumps on duty if needed.

I woudn't call that a redundant system... this was one of the reason i decided to go for a completly independent inverter and inverter bank when i added an inverter, i wanted the inverter not to interfere with the basic DC system.

how many batteries do you have and what type for your house bank, how old are they? if wet cells and a few years, they might not fully recover.
 
Like Pascal, I advocate separate banks of batteries for critical inverters--and Art's situation shows why. The arguement is that you can get buy with smaller total banks--and that is true. But if the inverter banks are sized and typed (deep cycle--golf carts), plus there is a low voltage cut off on the inverter (I have owned a couple of the Freedom 25's and they do have an adjustable low voltage cut out--but many folks set it at 11 volts, which is way too low.) By 11 volts, the batteries have sustained some damage. I try and not discharge to less than 12.2 volts--max 12 volts--which is 75% discharged. Art may have a separate bank for the inverter--but it sounds as if the CO alarms are on that circuit. The electronics may be on separate batteries, as should the engine starters. It is probably a good idea to have some alarm which will sound when the 110V power goes off--at least a flashing light etc. This would alert Marina management that there is a problem on that boat.

If there was a wiring problem, sometimes the Freedom inverters will not reset. If that happens, disconnect them from the batteries, and use a manual charger to start charging the batteries. After the batteries are 50% charged, then re attatch the Freedom charger. I like to either have a portable 30 amp charger or 30 to 40 amp charger which will work on the main house bank, and the inverter bank when necessary.

Many of the production boats still do have 12 volt systems, because it is cheaper--or at least the manufacture precieves it is cheaper. One of the advantanges of higher DC voltage is that you can use smaller wiring--and with the price of copper as high as it is, that may more than make up for the added expense of 24 or 32 volt appliances. As cars go to 40 volts, then we will probably see boats going to 40 volt battery systems sometimes in the future.
 
I'll try & get more info in the AM? I know my bow thruster runs 4 seperate batteries at 24 volt. If I recall there are 8 more huge batteries that run the house & Engines plus another for the Generator? I may be wrong but this is what I recall at the moment? Gentleman, thanks for the help.
 
Another update - My batteries are set up as follows: 2 8DA run the house, 4 8DA run the engine, 4 31 CASE run the bow thruster, 1 31 CASE runs the generator. That's a total of 11 batteries for the boat. Now that the charger cooled off or was able to begin charging everything is back to normal. Everything is reading ok. I'll keep an eye out for any power drops but everything appears normal right now. Thanks again. Looks like I caught a break?
 
Back
Top