My best 'similar' was a 357 Chevvy in a 29' Boat.
11 GPH at cruise, 13-17 GPH with the throttles into the Four Barrels.
My Plugs hardly showed bad, and changing them did not help.
I think that Ethonal is your problem.
You have EFI which means your injectors might need some help. They are supposed to SPRAY! Not slop or squirt. No Drips, no Runs and no slobbers.
I'd bet the Ethanol and your Injectors are the problem.
Sorry, I've never seen an injector from an EFI, but I did see the Difference in an old VW Injector.
You could have a compression check and get a heat indication off each Exhaust manifold port to see how your engine is doing age wise, but I'd bet, if your not burning oil, your still in good shape except for fuel delivery.