Deposit question

MEfirst

Member
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
RO Number
21005
Messages
331
Thought I'd get some input on this one. Had a couple people lined up to see my boat this weekend. First guy shows up and after looking over the boat we strike a deal. He then gives me a deposit check and says he'll arrange to pick up the boat this week. So I call the other interested parties and say the boat is sold.

Well, the buyer calls this morning to say he's changed his mind. Obviously I'm not too happy and I'll be contacting the other parties to see if they are still interested. Question is, what to do with the check he gave me for a deposit. There was a discussion that it would be returned should something catastrophic happened to either one of us, but I don't view someone changing their mind as catastrophic. Any thoughts would be appreciated.
 
To me a deposit is just that. You took the boat off the market and you should keep the check unless there really are extenuating circumstances.
 
I believe you legally must return the deposit, unless it is written into a binding contract that specifically specifies the terms which would make the deposite non-refundable.
 
Give him the money back. Even if you have the right to keep it, its just the nice thing to do. Plus, you don't seem to have a written contract.

Shel
 
I'd be annoyed but I agree I'd probably return it. I'd sleep better. But, if you incurred any specific costs, like say having to buy a new ad someplace or whatever, because of him changing his mind, it seems only fair he share in that cost.

I think this is why many people keep showing a boat, car, house even though they have a deposit from someone. As long as you tell the other buyers what the situation is before they go to any trouble to come look, you should be able to do that.
 
My neighbor is selling a boat and he does it this way. In his for sale add he sets the time and place to view the boat. This way he doesn't get random calls and random visits all day long. Everybody shows up at one time and can either walk, make an offer or even make counter offers. Sounds like a good way to do it to eliminate some hassle.

Oops sorry, I see this really has nothing to do with your question. Yes I would most likely give the money back as well. Call the other interested parties right away.
 
Then why bother even accepting a deposit? And please don't waste my time showing me houses or boats that someone has already put a deposit on.
 
Just a clarification - the exact words use when the deposit was given was that it would be returned in the event of something "catastrophic" like "the death of either party". To me, the buyer changing his mind does not qualify as a catastrophic event.

I was taught that oral agreements that are to be completed in less than a year are enforceable in the state of Michigan. I wouldn't want to go to court and find out if that is true. I also don't feel that I should keep the entire deposit as that doesn't strike me as fair either. But time, and possibly expense, were lost on my part, for which I do feel some compensation is justified.
 
Well, not a lot of detail given in the first post. Is there a written contract that spells out the T&C's? Did you discuss taking the boat off the market and not continuing to show it? How much is this check?

The would be buyer may have already issued a stop payment anyway.

I would just give it back and say sorry it did not work out.

Greg - I have to agree with you to a point. Almost all of my boat purchases included T&C's that gave me an out should I change my mind.
 
All private sales of anything of value should have a written purchase and sale agreement signed at the time a deposit is taken or agreement reached. The PSA should clearly state the terms for deposit refund.
 
I would give it back. Maybe his wife found out and it became catastrophic.
Niles
 
I have given deposits back. Selling the boat is your problem and not his...why make him suffer for "cold feet"?

FWIW - I purchased a home in which the previous buyer backed out AFTER contract. The two parties attornies negociated how much the seller kept. I think it was about $2,000 of the $43,000 deposit.
 
Call me old fashioned, but I tend to trust people if they give me their word and a handshake. For a sale that is less than $10k, I'm not about to change my ways, even if it costs me a little, like with this incident. A bigger purchase would of course be in writing.

I probably will send the check back. I know the buyer can have a stop payment issued, to me it's a matter of principle.
 
I wouldn't send it back. I'd just tear it up and be done with it .......and him....
Let him worry about wether or not you deposited it or whatever. He'll have to pay a fee to stop payment on a check that's in the trash somewhere.
 
I've never understood the concept of the use of purchase deposits to remove the item from availablitity for sale to others if the deposit is refundable, except in the case the (boat) does not meet declared condition at the time papers & funds are exchanged. . That makes the deposit completely meaningless to me. The otherwise non-refundable deposit should be the means to persuade the buyer to follow through on his/her confirmation the balance will be paid in return for the removal of the item from the market.

That said , I'd probably still refund the deposit and feel much the better for it. We all have second thoughts about some large purchases, especially these days. If it was a nominal amount you really won't miss it and if it was 10% or so you probably can't really feel you earned that much. Did the buyer say he expected his not so earnest "earnest" money back?

Does Michigan by any chance have consumer protection laws giving the buyer the opportunity to change his/her mind without penalty within a certain period of time, such as 1 or 3 days?
 
Sandy, the only contingency placed on the return of the deposit was in the event of something catastrophic, like death. And I agree with you that why even bother taking the deposit if there is no penalty for backing out, kind of defeats the purpose. The only protection Michigan gives that I've seen is on the finance or refinance of a home, and then you have 3 business days to declare it void.

Unfortunately, there are quite a few boats like mine for sale in this area, including a '91, '96, and '98 which are essentially the same make and model. I know that one of the other buyers interested in mine looked at the '96 and it sounds like he has made a deal on that one, so there goes one potential buyer.
 
Ok, I've now heard from the two other parties that were supposed to look at my boat this weekend and they both made offers on other boats. I'm beginning to think this is going to cost me, at least in advertising dollars. Someone remind me why I should return the full deposit amount.
 
You still didn't give us details. How much was the check? If it was 10%, I think I'd give it back. If it was fairly small, maybe 1-2%, I might keep it to pay for additional advertising and tell the guy that after you accected his check, you called 2 people and told them the boat was sold and now they have found other boats and purchased them.
 
Check was for $1000, a little over 10%. Have already notified him that the other buyers have moved on. I'm obviously not keeping the check since that is not fair in my opinion. I'm sure if I deposited it he would put a stop payment on it anyway.

Michigan's been having their own little one state recession for about 6 years, so finding another buyer will be interesting .... and if one doesn't come along you'll find me out on the water. :-)
 
I believe that most state laws provide a 72 hour buyers remorse period. In real estate deals that deposit is called earnest money and is not refundable except if there is a problem such as with a deed or mortgage title.
 
Back
Top