It certainly depends on the size of the boat and the use it is going to get. It also depends how deep your pockets are if you want diesel for a smaller boat that gas would be fine for.
Forget about the fuel savings, IMHO, it should not be a consideration for the follwing reasons. First off is the additional cost to upgrade to diesel, second is how many hours you put on your boat, third is the cost for maintenence, forth is how long will you own this boat before you buy another.
I have 8.1 Crusader motors (385 hp each) in my boat, the 40to 60k upgrade to diesel just put me over the edge on what I wanted to spend(it was not so much the money but I felt it was a rip off) My boat is 19k dry and no gear, with fuel,water, gear and people I would think I would be close to 24k in weight. If I was to buy the 42c or larger then there is no choice, diesel is the way to go.
So in answer to your question:
If the boat is small, 38 feet or less, you do not need to have diesel.
If you put little hours on your boat, then you do not want diesel, diesel motors like to be run and run hard.
If you want a bigger heavier boat and just put around with it, you do not need to have diesel.
If you want a bigger heavier boat and want to take long trips and really want to use the hell out of it then you want diesel.
If money is not a consideration and you will use the boat then diesel would be my choice for any size boat.
Walter