Floating docks or not?

MrsRobinson

Active member
Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2005
RO Number
19626
Messages
1,074
In a perfect world, all else equal, 2 marianas, one has floating docks, one does not. Remember, all else equal except the docks.

Which one would you prefer to slip your boat at and why?
 
Our marina is currently tearing down the concrete docks and installing floating docks. In my opinion the concrete docks are the best during really bad storms. Of course, you have to ensure your lines are right and if possible I even go out every 3 hours and re-check/adjust them. The floating dock makes it easy to board since the relation of the boat and dock never change. They also make it easier to clean/polish some of the hull and A/C discharge outlets. However, in a really bad storm the floating docks can get torn apart a lot easier than the concrete ones. I quess it's really up to the marina on what they want to spend on maintenance. As long as I have a slip I go with either one.
 
Done both, prefer floaters for ease of boarding.
 
Properly designed floating docks will give much better protection in major storms such as a hurricane.

If the dock is not in protected waters than the type of dock is not going to matter. If the docks/boats are exposed to open water where large waves can build than all bets are off.

In a protected environment the well designed floating dock will protect the boat from rising waters. Docks with fixed tie points just cannot handle a 10 or 12 foot tide,

G
 
had both, floaters are inconvenient unless you boat has low level access such as a sport fish for low boats they are easiest. For areas with a big tide range they are at least consistant when it comes to boarding.
They perform poorly in storm waves so much so that the floaters in this area that were destroyed, along with a lot of boat damage, all have been replaced by fixed concrete.
Floaters are also noisy, the dock flexing and ramps moving set up quite a racket.
 
Love the floating docks at our Marina. We have a swim platform on the back at the same level as the dock. We were caught in the boat during the Mothers Day storm up here in the Northeast and had no problems. The only problem I see with them is if the pilings aren't tall enough for a hurricain surge then your boat could float away with the dock. But then again you can move the boat to a good hurricain hole if needed.
Bill
 
Gcolton has it. If the docks are exposed it really does not matter which type you are on. In anything over 40kts a big sea can develop in a very short distance. This is when the best place to be is on a revolving mooring, in deep water with lots of riding chain. For convenience a floating dock is hard to beat unless you have a slip that you can drive your car right up to & pass stuff right from car to boat. That is when tide consideration is a minor inconvenience.
 
Guys i honestly dont know how one can say a fixed dock is better tehn a floating dock in any situation. A floating dock will raise and fall with the tide allowing u to tie ur boat as tight as possible. There is no reconfiguring for storms or moon tides. Right there is a huge bonus. The dock im on is open to the bay... We get snot rolling in with every westerly or southern wind. The docks hold up fine.. THEY ROll with the waves. Makes walking them in a 30 mph wind a bit of trick but hands down a FLOATING dock is far more preffered.

Rob
 
We much prefer floating docks. Ours are concrete, so they are very stable. No climbing up or down slippery ladders during tide changes, easy access to the boat, easy to clean the hull among some of the other comments that have been made. I always get a splinter whenever I've had to use wooden boarding ladders.
 
Floaters witout a doubt.

Lines are much easier, Boarding easier,
 
Floating docks. Especially where the tide range is big.
 
We have floating docks at the marina where I work. During Isabel all boats at our marina simply floated up with the tidal surge without an issue. At the same time I was at home wading in waist high water out on my own fixed dock constantly adjusting dock lines to keep my boat from sinking or smashing into the poles. If there is ever another bad storm I'm taking my boat to work.
 
Greg, Last year was our 1st year boating. We were assigned a floating slip but were placed into a permanent one while the floating slips were being completed. To get onto the boat from the the fixed dock, we had to climb down a ladder to get onto our boat. After we moved the boat to the floating slip, we realized that we were glad we chose that option. Now, we just walk onto the swim platform and into the boat regardless of the tide. In addition, the admiral had some serious issues getting onto the boat from the fixed dock.

We live 1.5 hrs from the marina and find it impossible to go there repeatably to adjust the lines if we were on a fixed dock during a storm. Something to think about with respect to the distance from your home to the boat. So, if you have a choice, the floating slip is the way to go. Taking your boating supplies on and off is easier and safer too. It might cost a few more $$, but definitely worth it.
 
Floating without a question! Although not in a marina situation, I have a floating dock here at the house, on a river, about a half mile from open ocean. I have 8 to 11 foot tidal swings twice a day, a current that's approaching 2.5 to 3 kts (sometimes higher following heavy rains) and as we're where the river narrows while running between some fairly high banks, I'm in the middle of a wind tunnel that can crank up 20 to 30 kt winds in no time at all. Add to that, we'll pick up occasional swells during a brisk southeasterly with an outgoing tide. That's a lot of dynamics and she just rolls with it all. At high tide, it's a straight walk out to the swim platform that's flush with the dock. Coming back, it's a nice uphill stroll rising 12 feet over a distance of 30 feet. Dealing with a fixed pier is like when you were a kid, trying to climb up that ladder to your girlfriend's window while trying to carry a six pack and avoiding detection by her dad. When things got dicey during the Mother's Day storm that Billy mentioned, we just fired up the engines and barely nudged them into gear to relieve some of the stress. Don't even think we had to do that but it was a good excuse to get out of the house. Floating dock all the way...
 
I agree with the majority....floating dock are just a lot more convenient that a fixed dock (for all the reasons mentioned above) , however, like anything else, if they are built poorly or maintained poorly, they will be a nuisance.
 
Floaters!
As most have said, if built right there are many reasons they are better.
When we travel, marinas with floaters get our business before fixed docks
 
floaters although it may depend on the boat... I'm on a fixed dock and with the high decks of my boat, i like the fact that i can set the stern real close to the dock and just step on and off without use boarding stairs.

Otherwise, floating docks are very convenient and when tides exceed 3', almost a must.

There has been cases of floating docks being wiped out by storms although with tall pilings or telescoping design allow for larger storm surge. as usual, it comes down to location, design, etc....

everything else is NEVER equal!
 
When hurricane "Hugo", I believe, came through Wrightsville Beach the Wrightsville Beach Marina docks had pilings tall enough to survive the storm surge. All the boats tied to it survived. The Bridge Tenders Marina, 100 feet away across the ICW, didn't and everything attached to the docks (power, fuel, boats) disappeared.

When hurricanes or nor'easters threaten Long Beach Island a lot of the boats head for Atlantic City and the Farley (Trump) Marina's floating docks and very tall pilings. The marina is well protected from waves.

"Floating" requires further definition.
 
No tides up here so it depends on the boat. Our last boat floaters were great, this boat fixed are better.
Niles
 
Back
Top