Fun Question

  • Thread starter Thread starter CW
  • Start date Start date
Onboard a slow boat the drinking can start right away. You are much less likely to hit a wave & spill good alcohol.

It is winter. Some people have waay too much spare time.
 
<<..."A boater has two bullets. He puts one in his gun and fires it off his bow perfectly parallel to a dead calm sea. The other bullet is dropped overboard from the same height, and at the exact same time the trigger is pulled on the gun. Which bullet hits the water first?"...>>

If the earth was flat, they would hit the water at the same time. But, because of the curvature of the earth, the bullet fired down range will have slightly farther to fall before it hits the water. So, the bullet dropped overboard hits the water ever so slightly sooner.
 
Actually, assuming that the bullet was fired out of a rifled barrel the rotation of the bullet will also cause a small amount of lift.
 
I came into this too late and the answers are already given, but my first thought was that the question was ambiguous as you did not specify whether the 20mph was sog, leaving it to the reader to decide for you.

Another good question, one that I have not taken the time to figure out is very similar. If I'm traveling up an inlet at say 9 knots and the inlet is screaming with a head current of 5 or 6, leaving me little headway of around 3 knots or so. Also lets say the inlet is roughly 10 miles or so (Scatchet head to Pt. wilson if anyone cares). Also the boat gets over 2 nautical miles per gallon at hull speed and half that at planing speeds (say 1mpg at 13kts). At the end of the inlet the water opens up substantially and the current speed drops significantly and might even be a back current, so the quicker that I get out of the inlet, the better. Am I better to slug it out at hull speed or plane the boat to get through the area quicker. Ultimately which one saves me the most fuel? Like I said, I have not taken the time to do the math, but its a real situation that I have faced and will face again. Anyone want to work the problem? :) I'll just sit back and be the benefactor of the answer for once!

bp
 
quote:

Originally posted by Philyteach

Actually, assuming that the bullet was fired out of a rifled barrel the rotation of the bullet will also cause a small amount of lift.






Possible, but only if it's fired in the right direction.
 
Ghost
You will use 1.7 gal. at hull speed and 1.4 gal at planing speed to get through the inlet. The 5 to 6 knot current is a function of time. The longer you are in it, the more it affects you. In your case even burning twice as much fuel per hour you are still better off to travel at planing speed, plus you will have more time to fish when you get there. However, going back home you would only save .03 gals. at planing speed.
 
Since most of the fesh water, river, fishing boats I am familiar with won't slow down to 20 MPH, I would have to say that cruising at 60+ that current effect will not be that significant. The thing that would bother me the most would be life of the TM batteries fighting that current at the fishin' hole.
 
Wait a minute, wait a minute! Ghost will only use 1.7 gallons going that distance in his 48' Tolly?????
Lets do the math.

Distance to Travel = 10 NM
Current = 6nm/hr
Fuel economy = 2gal/nm at 9 knots
Fuel economy = 1gal/nm at 13 knots

First calculate at 9 knot boat speed
Time to destination = Distance to travel/(boat speed - current)
= 10/(9-6)
= 10/3
= 3.33 hours to reach destination

How much fuel does he use per hour at 9 knots

Gal/hr = distance traveled / fuel used per nm
= 9 / 2
= 4.5 gallons/hr at 9 knots

Thus fuel used to cover distance at 9 knots
Fuel used = time to distance * gal/hr
= 3.33 * 4.5
= 15 gallons to cover distance at 9 knots

Now at 13 knots

Time to distance = 10/(13-6)
= 10/7
=1.43 hours

Gal/hour at 13 knots?
Gal/hr = 13 / 1
= 13 gal/hr at 13 knots

Fuel used to cover distance at 13 knots?
fuel used = Time to distance * gal/hr
= 1.33 * 13
= 17.29 gallons

Summary:
Ghost will use 17.29 gallon of diesel at 13 knots or will use 15 gallons at 9 knots

Dave
 
Back
Top