Generator Quote...OUCH

Mumm24

Member
exMember
Joined
Mar 4, 2008
RO Number
29546
Messages
45
INSTALL 5 BCG WESTERBEKE GENERATOR PER ESTIMATE

$6489.000
MISC 1400.000 1,400.00
ORDER PRICE SUMMARY
Total Parts : 7,889.00
Total Labor : 2,040.00
Total Other Charges : 0.00
Miscellaneous Supplies : 0.00
Equipment Charges : 0.00
Freight Charges : 150.00
Mileage Charges - 0.00 Miles : 0.00
Sublet Charges : 0.00
Total Labor Discounts : 0.00
Shop Supplies : 50.00
Sales tax : 709.03
============
Total Work Order : 10,838.03

I have a Carver 36' Mariner.
1. Do I need a 7.0KW?
2. How is the price?
 
A 5KW might not be enough to run everything on your boat. What is the $1400 "misc" - is that for wiring and switches????

The price for the genny seems OK. No one ever said boating was cheap...
 
That sounds OK to me- if it's all-inclusive. Last spring I bought and installed a new Kohler 5KW with sound shield. After negotiations I bought it for $6800 plus they split the shipping (list was 7200). I also bought (from the dealer) a transfer switch, extension cables and remote start switch.

After adding all the other things (Wire, muffler, hose, thruhulls, strainer, fuelsep, yada, yada) my grand total was $8280, not including my time, beer, or the $100 Red Lobster gift card I gave my (electrician) slipmate to do the final electrical connections. Oh yeah, I also had to hire a Kohler tech to verify the installation (for warranty coverage).
 
Hi.
New here...but not new-new.
I'm familiar with your boat and like them quite a lot. One thing about a Mariner - there is a lot of cubic feet of space to cool.
Quick question on your question about the 7kw genny.
Do you have 2 ac units? Or just 1?
If you have 1 ac unit - 5kw is probably enough if you can skip using the hair dryer while the microwave is on.

7kw is one 10Amp 110V electrical circuit more than a 5kw.
 
well, you may be able to get away with a smaller unit but how much will you save? the labor and supplies will be the same...

indeed, if you have 2 ACs, i wouldn't go for a 5kw, especially not anything that runs at 3600rpm like kohlers! FWIW, i had a 7kw west a few years ago on a 37 footer with dual AC, it was fine. i woudln't try anything smaller...

the labor is about 25 hours at average yard rate? is the boat pre wired? if so, it's on the high side. If not, and you must install extra breakers w/slide or rotary, pull the wiring, etc... it's a little high but maybe not by much. Does it include haulout to install seacock/strainer/exhaust? OR are they jsut going to tap into an existing strainer? not good..

if this is an install from scratch, they'll need :
thruhull
sea cock
strainer
backing plate
fuel tank pick up
fuel hose
water lift muffler
exhaust hose
exhaust thruhull
wiring to the panel
a pair of double pole breaker and safety slide or a pair of rotaries

pull a catalog and price all that stuff... probably not $1400 but yards dont' charge Boatfix prices, more like full retail.
 
I had a remanufactured Westerbeke 5k installed in my carver last year. The boat was pre-wired for 110 with automatic relays but everything else needed to be done. My final bill for install accessories and labor was $8,600.

I also have to say this was the best upgrade I've purchased for my boat and I'd never have a boat with out a gen again.
 
I had a new Kohler 7.3LO CO unit installed last year and like it. I have 2 16,000BTU AC units. It can run everything on the boat with it. It isn't that noisy either maybe it's the water muffler system on it? I paid about 9k installed it is wired to my SmartCraft displays and with the optional factory remote in the Salon.

Bill
 
I don't know about your area but here in the SE, boat show prices are in effect for the Westerbeke. The price of the genset runs about $600 less during that time. The rest of the figures are in line. I've got a 5.0 BCG coming in Friday for an install. You sure he didn't quote you for the 5.0 low CO model?
 
$14,000 or a little more in West Michigan. Installing one from scratch is a big job.
 
quote:



7kw is one 10Amp 110V electrical circuit more than a 5kw.






The difference between a 5KW and a 7KW is 2000 watts. 10 amps at 110 volts is only 1100 watts.
 
I went with a diesel 9Kw Kohler with wiring and a remote start for around $11k. We run that thing like crazy...
 
I would prefer a generator running at about 75% to 80% of load rather than 100% flat out. My panel has 2 30amp legs. The generator switching arangement cross connects both 30amp legs with breakers w/sliders to lock out the shore side I prefer this to an automatic transfer switch. I had a new #6 marine grade feeder run from the generator to the panel replacing the old #8 wire.
 
Mumm, the original cost will be nothing compared to the maintenance and repair costs you will incur over its lifetime!

Once you have one, you'll wonder how you ever lived without it
 
Im so frustrated! I expected it to be around $8-9,000 for a 7.0 version. The 5.0 quoted is not the low co version. I bought the boat mid year last and obviously didn't need one. I know it will add to the value of the boat and provide more comfort. I hate to say(type) it but I just wanna give up and buy the parallel Honda's and see how much I would use them instead...
 
I paid mid 7k in 2004 for a 7kw Kohler, I had the seacock.

Walter
 
quote:

Originally posted by cwms

quote:



7kw is one 10Amp 110V electrical circuit more than a 5kw.






The difference between a 5KW and a 7KW is 2000 watts. 10 amps at 110 volts is only 1100 watts.








...whoops - typo. I did the math right, but hit the wrong key typing too fast. ~20amp circuit is what you get from 2000w at 110. A ten amp circuit doesn't make any sense. Sorry about that.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Billylll

I would prefer a generator running at about 75% to 80% of load rather than 100% flat out. My panel has 2 30amp legs. The generator switching arangement cross connects both 30amp legs with breakers w/sliders to lock out the shore side I prefer this to an automatic transfer switch. I had a new #6 marine grade feeder run from the generator to the panel replacing the old #8 wire.






I agree and have the same set up. I have a hard time getting the Admiral to remember to turn off the switches before shutting down the genset though. I worry about the long term affect of the "brown out". It causes the alarm system to trip as well. I think I'll post a note in the electrical panel closet-
 
Is the cost of the generator exempt from sales tax as a capital improvement to a second home? One of the requirements, of course, is that it be affixed permanently.

IMO, five kW is more than enough for a 36 foot boat. You do have to limit the number of heavy loads that can be switched on simultaneously. Very likely you can tee off the head pickup throughhull for the water supply.

If you run a cord and plug into the shore power connections, you can avoid the cost of the fancy switchgear.
 
I changedover from a 6500 gas Onan to a 5000 NextGen diesel in 2003.

Added a 17 gallon fuel tank and gen sep for the exhaust.

It handles my 16,000 btu's just fine, along with everything else. We just avoid running the water heater, 2 burner stove and hair dryer all at the same time.

It actually seems to handle loads better than the gas unit, however that's not fair as the gas unit was TIRED with 2,600 hours on it and 20 years of service.

RWS
 
quote:

Originally posted by Mumm24

Im so frustrated! I expected it to be around $8-9,000 for a 7.0 version. The 5.0 quoted is not the low co version. I bought the boat mid year last and obviously didn't need one. I know it will add to the value of the boat and provide more comfort. I hate to say(type) it but I just wanna give up and buy the parallel Honda's and see how much I would use them instead...






The Hondas are a joke there are definate safety issues using them as well. You probably won't use it as much because you will have to set them up where a permenant system would be just flipping a few switches and safer. The Hondas also add no value to your boat. Not that a boat is an investment! I would shop around for the generator there are some good deals out there.

Bill
 
Back
Top