Gensets

billie1

Member
Joined
Mar 18, 2008
RO Number
29612
Messages
4
Hello again,
I just got a Maxum 1999 2400 SCR it has air conditioning built in but no Generator. Any suggestions on how to supply the aircondtioner. Portable generators, inverters, etc. I will be taking it on Lake Havasu, and you know how hot it can get there in the summer...
 
Up to 10K BTU, a Honda 2000iu will work fine. I had on my Regal 2465 and it ran the A/C, water heater, and microwave with selective power management. If you have a 5K BTU, you may be able to get by with the Honda 1000iu, however, the 1000iu will not run the water heater and you will be stretching it to run the microwave. Tap into your fuel tank for an extended run kit and divert the exhaust below the water to avoid CO while on the hook.

HTH
 
Bille1, I have a 2002 Maxum 2500 SCR with NO genset! Buy the 2ooo honda, it will run the A/C and the lights and the beer cooler. It wont run the mircowave and the a/c. or a/c and water heater. You love the honda top shelf product. I have a friend that bought a honda knock off at Pep Boys. It wont run the heat and it is a noisey little cuss.
 
Tap into your fuel tank for an extended run kit and divert the exhaust below the water to avoid CO while on the hook.

Neither suggestion is a good idea.

Tapping into your fuel tank could create a fire/explosion hazard.

Venting the exhaust under water will do absolutely nothing to eliminate CO, and it will create unwanted back pressure on the genny, potentially damaging it.

Get a good CO detector for you cabin, do not place the genny near any open windows or doors, make sure it is downwind. Remember, the fumes from YOUR genny can travel into other nearby boats and cause illness or death.

Do not store it in the engine compartment. Run the fuel dry after every use.
 
Honda2000's or similar portable generators have no place on a boat they are an accident waiting to happen. Tap into the fuel line? Put backpressure on the exhaust by running it underwater inviting an exhaust leak. Two horrible dangerous ideas in my opinion.
 
see hogans remark, spot on...

we'd used one in the past, but really, since we were back in slip at night, and fridge ran on 12v during the day, found the hassle was not worth it, but of course we were not where it is so hot... Now we use it when the boat is on the hard, for battery charging, lights, etc, during the off season.

If you use one on the platform, make sure you are actually "swinging" on your hook... and it is downwind, and that there IS a wind...

Personally, I would never sleep with one running and of course a few CO dectors are an absolute must.
 
Despite the naysayers, I have BTDT. I can tell you that the 2000iu on the platform (I should have been more clear about the platform mount) does work. As does the exhaust diversion, and tapping into the main tank, again more clarity required, tapping into the main FEED line does indeed work. The exhaust diversion resulted in no CO alarms sounding. Prior to the exhaust mod, a station wagon effect did take place and force the shut down of the gennie. The back pressure is not an issue.

These are my results and my results only.
 
quote:

Originally posted by KiDa

Despite the naysayers, I have BTDT. I can tell you that the 2000iu on the platform (I should have been more clear about the platform mount) does work. As does the exhaust diversion, and tapping into the main tank, again more clarity required, tapping into the main FEED line does indeed work. The exhaust diversion resulted in no CO alarms sounding. Prior to the exhaust mod, a station wagon effect did take place and force the shut down of the gennie. The back pressure is not an issue.

These are my results and my results only.






I've owned both the aforementioned Maxum and Regal, using a Honda 2k on the platform, underway, on the hook, and at the dock. No problems whatsoever. Buy CO sniffers and pay attn. the wind and your neighbors. They aren't particularily quiet.

Another piece of advice. Use a throwaway cushion or something similar underneath it. Cuts down on the annoying vibration.

-Greg
 
All good points. Do some homework on people that have done it. As posted above I have done it on the hook 2 dozen times with no problems. If you MOUNT it on the platform, point the exhaust away from the boat. Buy a MARINE CO detector NOT one from Lowes or Home Depot( they are not set up for the marine use) they take reading differntly than a marine unit. I sleep in the aft cabin so i mounted one near my head. The other is in the main cabin up by the head door.
When at anchor, set the bow anchor and allow the wind to blow the back of the boat around, so the bow is facing the wind and the stern it DOWN wind(where the honda is) taking the CO away from you and your family.
These units use very little fuel! The honda will get better with time.Dont be scared, just be smart!
 
"I have a friend that bought a honda knock off at Pep Boys. It wont run the heat and it is a noisey little cuss."

I have several friends that bought that same Pep-Boys Gen. and they ARE as quiet as a Honda. (see the specs) We've actually had a Honda and one of those running near eachother and if you're blindfolded it's hard to telll which is which. As for running things? It'll run anything the Honda does. Are you sure they (your friends) didn't get the smaller version? There ARE several knock-offs out there.
 
I would like to know how the portable generator's exhaust was connected so that it was discharged underwater. I have a 1992 Regal 260 Valanti and a Yamaha 1000EF generator. Back around 1996/1997 this generator was the quietest thing on the market. Used it ocassional when weekending on the boat to power the water heater, recharge batteries, microwave, stove, coffee pot, etc. It was too noisy to let running for any length of time. I would normally just run it in the morning for an hour or so. My boat is kept on land on a trailer without access to power. I just recently purchased a 2000(4500 peak) watt pure sine wave inverter and plan on using my boat more often which means I'll be needing the generator more to recharge the batteries. By eliminating some of the noise from the exhaust, I feel I should be able to run the generator for a longer period of time. Perhaps later in the evening while watching TV.
 
"I would like to know how the portable generator's exhaust was connected so that it was discharged underwater."

Screw a 45* or a 90* elbow depending on your setup and preferably Marelon into the black muffler guard. Use a high temp gasket to seal the joint between the fitting and the muffler (my mechanic shot the muffler with a thermal gun and it only read 116 degrees. He was amazed at how cool it remained) so no real worries with melting. Attach a screw in fitting to a piece of PVC and Screw a section of PVC on the other end of the elbow and let it hang into the water. the concept is not a lot different than the setup Rommer has on his Regal to muffle the reverberation from his under platform gennie exhaust. Depending on your setup, you would have to play with what made it right for you.

YMMV

You will reduce some of the noise. I suppose you could build a sound shield for the rest.
 
Hey Ki da,

right now our glasses our full of beer, but today we went to a honda dealter, they said our air would not run on a honda 2000, we are going to call Cabin Mate, our air conditoner that is built in. it is air cooled in cant tell how many watts or btus by the manual it will run. Let us know anything you know we rely on boatheads, you guys have the experience.
 
Comfort over safety.

What is more important to you?

Talk about multiplying your risks!

Let's see,

increased risk potential for electrical fire
increased risk potential for fiberglass catching on fire (hot genset close to transom)
increased risk potential for gasoline fume fire or explosion
increased risk potential for carbon monoxide poisioning - can be fatal
increased risk potential for loss of vessel and loss of lives.

no matter how much you jury rig this to try to make it "safe" it still increases the exposure to potentially deadly risk.

for the difference in price and increased value and use of your vessel, why not avoid all of this risk and additional work every time you set it up and tear it down and get the correct genset and install it properly?

Just my own 0.02

RWS
 
Whether you add a portable generator or a marine generator, there are the above potential risks. Granted, the marine genset if properly installed and used will minimize the risks. Running a portable generator unattended posses an issue of CO. Here is where I see the most danger. It is when the air current is not sufficient to swing the boat in relationship to the water current. The boat could be facing up river, for those boating on a river, due to the water current and no wind to slight wind coming from down river. That scenario would blow exhaust fumes into the boat/cabin. Running the generator while people are still awake and moving in and out of the cabin may notice how the boat is positioned in regards to wind direction.
What is difference of a home CO detector versus a marine CO detector? From what I read a home CO detector does some averaging to minimize alarms.
 
I either read it on a boating forum or in a magazine that humidity adversly affects home CO detectors. If I read it in a forum, then that may not be fact, but I cannot remember where I got that information from.
I have a marine 120 vac and a battery operated CO detector.
 
I agree a marine gen set is best. An inverter while you could get an inverter big enough would would need far too many batts to make it worthwile. I see many boats with the honda gen sitting on the platform. One guy I saw seemed to solve the co problem by having a tygon hose hooked to the tail pipe. the hose was about 25 or 30 feet long and was attached to a float. it floated away from the boat and always was downwind of the boat. I actualled marveled on that because on the same day my marine co detector kept going off from my factory gen set. was actually thinking or some kind of hose attached to mine to carry away the co.

I have also seen a honda sitting on a tube floating away from the boat. I didnt like the idea of this because of the electric cord in the water. not sure how far away it could shock people but made me cringe.
 
I would like to see some posts of actual damage or deaths due to portable generators. I uas mine while on thehook to charge the batteries, make coffee and pancakes in the am and run microwave if needed. I never run it at night. Its not that I am affraid of dying from Co, I dont want the noise to bother anyone. Here in the Northeast , it gets steamy in the summer, but on the hook I turn on a fan hooked up to a small inverter and thats it. I have never had the need to turn on the ac when away from the dock.It always seems cooler on the hook.
 
quote:

Originally posted by billie1

Hey Ki da,

right now our glasses our full of beer, but today we went to a honda dealter, they said our air would not run on a honda 2000, we are going to call Cabin Mate, our air conditoner that is built in. it is air cooled in cant tell how many watts or btus by the manual it will run. Let us know anything you know we rely on boatheads, you guys have the experience.






The only Cabin Mate I know of is water cooled and manufactured by Marine Air Systems, a child of the parent Dometic Corportation.

If your A/C is the one I am describing and is 10K BTU or less, the Honda 2K will indeed run it. The 1K would most likely not, only because of the startup amps required.

My Cruisair Zephyr was also a Dometic product, and very close to the Cabin Mate. The difference can be likened to a Buick vs a Chevy.
 
Back
Top