GPS/fish

dritter

Member
exMember
Joined
Oct 18, 2005
RO Number
19332
Messages
216
Looking to replace old electronics and with so many out there don't know which way to go. I have not had any luck with. Would you get a combo or would you go with seperate units? Any benifit to one unit besides saving space?
Thanks for any help!
Duane
 
Personally, if you have the money and space I would go with seperate. I am finding it a little difficule to learn to "operate" a combo unit.

G
 
Easier to upgrade to the latest "thing" or replace if broken, if they're seperate, too.
 
I was thinking about having keeping them apart in case something did happen to one, but other people say to get a combo. I saw another thread down a little from this one and there were some that said to get a big enough one because the smaller ones with split screens are hard to see. I think I will stay away from the combo.
 
I have both. A 7" GPS hard drive/potter with fish finder. Plus a separate 5" fish finder and a separate 7" chart plotter, plus a 7" radar. Normally I run the combo on long range for the chart ploter--the pure chart plotter is on the large scale, zoomed in. The separate fish finder is zoomed on the bottom, the combo shows the full range of the water column. I like as much screen realestate as is practical for the boat.

I have yet to have a GPS or Sat Nav fail (using satellite navigation for 25 years)-- But it does happen.
 
Sorry to jump in on your thread, but I too have been looking at a combo, The Humminbird 161. I have only a 18' b/r, so not alot of dash space, and all I am really interested in is the water depth and gps coordinates. Any feed back on Humminbird in general or the model 161 in particular. Also in as short supply as dash space is the dinero.

James
 
James,
I do not like humminbird. I had a couple on my other boat and the transducers went bad every year. Of course they were just ouside of the warrenty. I was talking to someone that said they have had problems with the transducers in colder climates. They get cold over the winter and the cold does something to them. Don't know if anyone else has had this problem.
Duane
 
Eagle is a Lowrance with a few Bells and Whistles left out. Actually makes them MUCH easier to use. I have had several 'Birds and never liked any of them. Eagle and Lowrance are top notch and Eagles save a significant amount of money off Lowrance.

YMMV
 
Duane, you didn’t say what size and type of boat that you are outfitting, recommendation typically depend on that. For example, on my 47’ S/F I have the Furuno NavNet with two 10” screens. While on my 23’ CC I have a single Lowrance GPS/DF combo 7” screen, it really depends on the application and use. I do recommend both the Furuno NavNet and the Lowrance LCX 28C HD. Todays combo units are very reliable and save space. Good luck, Jerry
 
I am looking at the Garmin 545s which also has the sonar option. I agree the dual screen might be small but I don't know how much I will use the split screen I hope to use one or the other.
Al
 
Jerry,
I have a 32' wellcraft st. tropez. I don't fish that much, but would use the gps a lot. The fish finder will be used for water depth and a little fishing. Thinking about doing some cruising this summer so a new gps would be used a lot.
 
Duane, With the San Tropez you may not have enough space for 2 separate units, so a combo may be the unit for you. With only an occasional fishing trip displaying the chart as well as the FF on separate screens may not be all that important to you (but I love the two 10” screens that I have with the NavNet when fishing). With that said my Lowrence combo does do the job in a relatively small space. Jerry
 
I have a 22 ft boat, so space is tight. I prefer and small installed FF/depth finder and a handheld GPS. I bought low end models which have lasted a long time. And I've never have any trouble with with my transducer which I've had for 16 yrs! The water gets down to about 40-45 here in the winter.
 
Thanks to all who replied, guess it's back to the hunt.

James
 
Back
Top