Hudson River Map question.

Radiowaves

Active member
Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2004
RO Number
14642
Messages
2,612
A friend of mine e-mailed me a picture of his map taken from his chart plotter. He is using C-Map and questioned why there was a 6 mile block of missing detail. However when zooming in at about .02NM you do get detail, but running at 25knots that is not practical. He contacted C-map and tech support says it is because of the chart set up in that area.

So I go to my Garmin / Mapsource and I have the same issue in the exact same spot. See picture below.

Any Ideas why?

HRChart.jpg
 
Yep, it's missing on paper charts too.

The only explanation I ever heard was there are wrecks down there that the government doesn't want people to know about. Not sure how true that is. Also, a couple years ago, a detailed topography of the land under the Hudson and NY Harbor was performed. Again, the findings were not released.

Also, the GWB is in that area. As was many battles between Fort Lee and Washington Heights during the revolution. The original chaining of the Hudson was performed there as well. There's alot of history in that section.
 
Same thing with Navionics and C-Map. The detail is there but only at certain zoom levels. It's not like it's missing. It's there if you zoom in a lot or zoom out but not at the normal zoom level.

It has nothing to do with the hardware. And the chart cartridges are based on the paper charts.
 
This is how the subject started

Brad,
You know more about the GPS software than I do but this does not make sense. C-map tech support says it is because of the chart set ups of the area. In all 4 pics The curser is in the same spot. The area is of about midtown Manhattan to the GW Bridge central on the Hudson River. The first shows 12 nm radius with no detail. The second is 6 nm showing detail of the river north and south of an area that says " no chart data ". The third pic is 3 nm with no information at all. The fourth is 1.5 nm with detail. I have never had this problem before and it makes no sense to me. It also is a potential hazardous situation, never mind having to flip two ranges but who would run 25 knots an hour on a 1.5 nm screen. What do you think? Billy K.

0903081115.jpg


0903081115a.jpg


0903081116.jpg


0903081116a.jpg


I have maptech charts and software that do not block out the area. It is probably a glitch in the program, but it should have been corrected by now. Billy K.
 
that section is chart 12341_1, fully detailed, it's pulling up nicely with Chart Navigator or Sea Clear

There are some areas where the large scale charts dont' have some details, your software/plotter should let you pull in the smaller scale chart.
 
"It also is a potential hazardous situation, never mind having to flip two ranges but who would run 25 knots an hour on a 1.5 nm screen. What do you think? Billy K."

there is nothing hazardous in this section of the hudson unless you're driving an ocean going tanker with a 40' draft!!!

http://www.charts.noaa.gov/OnLineViewer/12341.shtml

call it a minor inconvenient glitch but certainly not something hazardous...
 
I have an older version of Maptech Chart Navigator on my PC. That entire area from below Guttenberg to the GWB is listed as General, Special and Naval anchorage areas on the Manhattan side of the river. The fact that much of it is designated as a Naval anchorage may or may not be the reason for lack of detail.

Regardless, there is little opportunity to run aground or to get lost here so it really isn't hazardous.
 
I have the same issue as Billyk with a different GPS and Software.

Agree the detail is there, but at a range that no one would have their GPS zoomed in to. The fact that it could be hazardous is more to the point that if it was in a spot that you needed to see the detail at more of a distance it would not be there. Are there other places that C-map or Mapsource eliminated detail at a normal zoom range? It is true that this area of the Hudson is wide open and deep with no obstacles that I could see zoomed in.
 
check the online chart link i posted above... it's all clear!
 
Okay point taken, the Hudson is mighty and deep. I paid about $200 for what is supposed to be state of the art technology. Why can't one of the genius's fix it instead of arrogantly telling me to range in and out instead of watching where I am going in a heavy traffic area.
 
I hope no one here was arrogant but my apologies if it appeared that way.

Please note - we haven't eliminated any data, this is likely a situation where there is no paper chart data available at that scale level in that location. As you are scaling down through the layers, you are actually viewing different actual paper charts, at different scale levels. To try to display, for example, 1:20,000 scale chart and bordering 1:40,000 scale chart at the same time would require manipulating the data, making it less accurate. It can be done, but it's not generally a good idea in most locations.

Let me check into this a little and get back to you.
 
My Garmin does the same thing. Always thought it was odd but I'm not there too often and it's a deep/wide section of river so didn't worry about it too much.
 
Brad
I use Garmin Mapsource exclusively and have run the Hudson many times threw this area.
The charting between 79th st in NYC and north to about 170th st (just south of the GW Bridge) only shows detail at .5 mile resolution or less
And as JohnC said its deep and wide (25-70 ft) so I never gave it a second thought, As long as you use the chart and don't follow anyone ;-)
 
I double checked with GIS and find that my previous statements are correct. There are some things that can be done however.

BillyK - it looks like your screen shots are from a RayMarine chartplotter. You may find that setting the "PLOTTER MODE" to "OFF" will help by skipping blank scale levels, zooming automatically to the next level with chart data.

Users with MAX compliant chartplotters may have an 'over-zoom' or 'flexi-zoom' feature, which acts in a similar way to the Plotter Mode (which is specific to RayMarine).

Feel free to speak with Brandy, our Tech Manager, if you need assistance with these set ups or have further questions: 800-424-2627.
 
Ah heck, I thought it was the home of the lock ness monster. Best kept secret of the all mighty Hudson!
 
I have to say:

Okay point taken, the Hudson is mighty and deep.

At the LIYC that was the statment for the weekend.

Other than where is HANNA ?
 
Back
Top