Joe Cool update

rduhon

Active member
exMember
Joined
Jan 28, 2008
RO Number
29321
Messages
3,348
MIAMI - A federal judge in Miami has thrown out weapons convictions for a man tried in the slayings of four people aboard the "Joe Cool" charter boat.

U.S. District Judge Paul Huck said Wednesday that jurors were confused and given improper legal instructions in the case against 20-year-old Guillermo Zarabozo. Jurors in September convicted Zarabozo of four counts of using a weapon during a crime and he could have faced life in prison.

They could not agree on murder, kidnapping or robbery counts and he is facing a new trial on those counts.

Federal prosecutors likely will appeal the ruling throwing out the weapons convictions.

Zarabozo claimed he was unaware crimes would be committed aboard the boat chartered from Miami in 2007. He blamed the killings on another man who pleaded guilty to murder.
 
I'm normally not a fan of vigilante action, but when these a-h***s were found floating in the Joe Cool's life raft, it would've been a great time for a more swift form of justice...
 
Did he think he was just going for a joy ride? I really wonder about the judicial system.
 
We cannot harm any feelings that the criminals have.
That would not be a good thing.
They can kill innocent people, but we cannot hurt their feelings.
If they go to jail, I would hope they send them to Maricopa Co. Az.
Pink underwear and tent city in the middle of the desert.
 
its not neccesary to convict the lads of anything, just put them back where they started so they can finish their boat ride.
 
This would be a good case for ITK's "target practice"...
 
My wife's best friend was on that jury. In her opinion the prosecution did a miserable, disorganized job and the judge's guidance in light of what was presented made it almost impossible to apply some of the arcane principals of law to the evidence presented. Remember a jury has to base it's decision purely on what is presented in the courtroom, framed by rules "explained" by the judge. Needless to say she was extremely frustrated with how things turned out, but understood exactly why some jurors voted the way they did. What they were really saying was a do-over was necessary with a different judge and prosecutors. Not sure I understand that exactly, but then, we are a nation of law.
 
quote:

Originally posted by caltexfla

My wife's best friend was on that jury. In her opinion the prosecution did a miserable, disorganized job and the judge's guidance in light of what was presented made it almost impossible to apply some of the arcane principals of law to the evidence presented. Remember a jury has to base it's decision purely on what is presented in the courtroom, framed by rules "explained" by the judge. Needless to say she was extremely frustrated with how things turned out, but understood exactly why some jurors voted the way they did. What they were really saying was a do-over was necessary with a different judge and prosecutors. Not sure I understand that exactly, but then, we are a nation of law.






Was she confused as U.S. District Judge Paul Huck said the jurors were?

Not trying to be sarcastic, honestly trying to figure out how an appelas judge knows that the original jurors were confused.
 
it's fairly easy to see if the jurors are confused by reviewing the questions they ask during deliberations. The judge also reviews the jury instructions issued by the trial judge to see if they are clear or confusing in his opinion (which is why it called a judicial opinion after all).
 
Once again, its more important to you all to get the outcome you are looking for than it is to evaluate the case on its merits.

I think it sucks that this needs to be done over, but if I'm ever in a court of law, I want the process to work as intended.

I'm not hear arguments as to why the judge was wrong, just arguments that the perp was a bad guy and did bad things.

Typical.
 
Yes the jurors complained, and besides, all of their follow inquiries to the judge are part of the record. She won't go into a lot of detail, but made it pretty clear the whole thing was a real cluster ____ on the part of the judge and the prosecution. Apparently the latter went in to it with the idea it was an easy slam dunk, so short armed the thing right off the rim.

Georg
 
I for one want the legal aspects to this and any case done correctly. If it needs to be redone then fine and take action against the incompetent prosecution. Although I'm sure this guy needs to go to jail, it should be done with all the safeguards the legal system supplies.
 
I agree, Crossroads.! Let's make sure the conviction and pending punishment will not be thrown out on a technicality. These guys must not "walk"!
 
The primary perp already confessed. The disputed trial is for the guy he brought along (Dumb and Dumber). Besides the court issues, the case itself revolves around one guy's word against the other. As said, getting him for at least accessory should be a no brainer.

George
 
Back
Top