Liability question

GilBry210

Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2006
RO Number
24489
Messages
74
I bought a used boat from a dealer last October and have had problem after problem ever since. My most recent problem is loosing a wheel and tire while trailering to the lake. The wheel was thrown at approx 40 mph and hit another passing truck. No injuries thank god. Now I take it to a mechanic who tells me this wear has probably been going on for a long time (before I owned it). The dealer also replaced one of the axels right after I bought it, I don't think they checked the other one. I see that my trailer is rated for 4100 lbs, my dry weight of my boat is 3900 lbs. Should'nt my boat be on a stronger trailer? What action can I take with the dealership? Please help, Thanks in advance.
 
I don't think you can take any action. Did you buy it as is or with a warranty? Was the trailer under warranty?
 
I don't know what the Texas small claims courts are like, but in Kalifornia, you can file a claim up to $5,000 in small claims court. No lawyers are allowed. You state your case to the judge, the other side states theirs, both present whatever documentation they might have, and the judge makes as ruling as to whether you are entitled to be reimbursed for any monetary loss.
 
To complete terrycoxusa's statement: If the defendant does not show in court, you win by default.
 
Having been through this with a crooked mechanic however, be cautioned that winning the case, and actually getting paid are two different challenges.
 
Knowing if a warranty was given or not would go a long way.
 
I know a warranty would be great, however they have a "26 point inspection checklist" that states on it that the trailer parts in question were in good condition. This was proved untrue by them when they had to replace one axle shortly after the purchase. Should'nt that have been done upon intial inspection? Another is that I have now had a catastrauphic failure of that part and it could have caused serious damage to property and people. The shop that my trailer is at now says that the wear and tear he see's is not caused by short term damage. He said that the damage to the parts had been going on for a long time, before I owned it.
 
It all depends upon the conditions of the sale when you bought your rig. Most used items are sold "as is" unless a warranty is specifically stated. You really need to find some paperwork from the sale that at least provides an implied warranty.

G
 
Well I don't know. If they have that inspection thing in writing (with the 26 points checked off) he might have a case. What would make his case stronger would be testimony from his new mechanic. Small claims is great. Its only like 15 bucks here and most times the def. doesn't show up. Most businesses pony up the judgment to get it off their credit reports.
 
I think I am going to get a written inspection and statement from the other mechanic.
 
Even a "as is" sale carries, in most states, a warranty of merchantability. If the dealer sold you a trailer that is not suited for the boat, it's his problem.
 
I suspect you will have difficulty collecting anything. Almost a year ago, and a used boat/trailer. I agree that the trailer marginal. Have you weighed the boat on a scale? I would do that before going any further. Next I would get a statement from the mechanic (I suspect he will not give a written statement). Good luck. You might be in the market for upgrades on the trailer, or a new trailer. But the limiting parts can be the frame, the axels, the wheels and the tires --so there are lots of parts which have to pass muster.
 
Back
Top