Noise reduction

not sure of the cost, but JCW has a 4 x 6 for $30, 4 x 24 for $90. its 3/8" thermal and sound reflection.
 
I had a discussion with Alex at Soundaway.com. Very informative. He steered me away from the expensive lead product to carpet underlay (type in the search on their website). It's a foam with a viny backing. Cost $100 with shipping. I'll apply it in October and tell y'all if there is a difference.

-Greg
 
A motor that size shouldn't make that much noise. Is it exhaust noise, vibration, or mechanical clatter??

If it's exhaust noise look into a muffler..

If it's vibration I'd look into different engine mounts. Maybe a couple of sandbags alongside the stringers will help dampen the vibration (just a guess).

If it's the mechanical clatter then sound deadening material should help. I used fire-retardent acoustic ceiling tile on mine.

Many diesels (among them mine) have a "critical" speed at which they vibrate horribly. If you can avoid that RPM it'll run more smoothly (and quieter).
 
Interesting article in Passagemaker, last issue. A lot of noise is vibration. A thrust bearing between your shaft and transmission can make a big difference.
 
quote:

Originally posted by stmbtwle

A motor that size shouldn't make that much noise. Is it exhaust noise, vibration, or mechanical clatter??

If it's exhaust noise look into a muffler..

If it's vibration I'd look into different engine mounts. Maybe a couple of sandbags alongside the stringers will help dampen the vibration (just a guess).

If it's the mechanical clatter then sound deadening material should help. I used fire-retardent acoustic ceiling tile on mine.

Many diesels (among them mine) have a "critical" speed at which they vibrate horribly. If you can avoid that RPM it'll run more smoothly (and quieter).






I'd say it's mechanical clatter and it probably is quiet from a subjective standpoint. I've been quite spoiled. The gasser inboard Carver I owned had it's exhaust through the swim platform, so it was very quiet. Same with my I/O Campion. My goal is to cruise at 2200 to 2500 rpms and barely hear the engine. Probably unrealistic.

-Greg
 
Sound dampening products are usually different for gas than diesel engines. Be sure to get the right stuff.
If you get a product for gas, it might not help at all for diesel.
 
quote:

Originally posted by GeeBee

Interesting article in Passagemaker, last issue. A lot of noise is vibration. A thrust bearing between your shaft and transmission can make a big difference.






Beat me to it again.

The hearing damage I did as a Motor Lifeboatman wasn't nearly as much due to engine noise as vibration and wind noise. Sustained wind noise is nasty business - don't underestimate it in your quest to prserve your hearing (smart idea, BTW)
 
Also check put products at: http://www.soundown.com/AI.htm. I have used their various products thru the years. The lead is best used between layers of foam--with mylar surfaces on the outside of the foam. We used to use actual sheet lead nailed on plywood before the vinyl impregnated with lead came on the scene. The above has several thicker carpet underlays, which include foam and lead. We found that making the engine box as tight as possiable, with a baffle for the air intake. We had the usual soundproofing in the engine room, but made 3/4" plywood boxes, with hinged openings, and gaskets for access to the oil, fill etc--with a good sized baffle air intake infront of the alternator, which had air pulled by it with the engine air intake.

Enjoy the new boat!
 
Having been an acoustical consultant for 15 years and currently the manager of a Noise Laboratory I feel compelled to add my two cents worth.

I think your first approach to solving your problem by gluing the lead to your foam insulation would be the most effective. The noise levels from diesels are primarily low frequency and require a material with more mass to block the airborne noise radiation from the engine.

It is possible that if the engine mounts are not providing much vibration isolation then you could be getting more structure-borne noise in which case the addition of the lead would not be effective. If the noise from the engine definitely sounds like it is radiating from the engine box then the addition of the lead may be effective.

Good luck.
Mike
 
Great advice. Interesting subject. I would think somebody could make a nice living from selling and installing this stuff. Noise is a problem on most boats.

Regarding lead, the soundaway tech. really touted the vinyl/foam combo in the carpet underlay, stating that it was as effective as lead, and much cheaper.

I'll report my progress when we splash her 10/9.

-Greg
 
Back
Top