Packing failure

32carv

Well-known member
Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2006
RO Number
24150
Messages
1,309
I have a 1985 Carver 3227 with Crusader 270 hp motors and v-drives. I had the couplings repacked in the spring by my mechanic. Normal drip before but I've had the boat for five years and have never had it done so I thought it was time. When they put the boat in the water there was no drip at all. Possibly too tight? The first time out I was up on plane and smelled something burning and looked in the engine compartment and saw the couplings streaming water. Called mechanic and he came over and tightened them.
Was Ok for a while but to had to tighten again after about three hours of run time. I was at the boat today and water on starboard side is a drip per second and the port side is a steady stream. The water slows after it sits for a while but the bilge pump kicks on occasionally.
Now my question. I believe that the packing nuts were too tight at the beginning and the friction burned the packing, causing issue that I have now. Does this sound reasonable and is it fair for me ask my mechanic to pull the boat and redo the packing at his expense?
 
No need to pull the boat. Who ever you get to repack it. Make sure they clean the shaft and the packing gland well. And that they use GFO packing this time. It's made to run dripless.
 
Did you tell the mechanic that you smelled something burning? If you did and he went ahead and tightened the packing, you obviously cheaped out on doing your homework and getting a decent mechanic who would not make such serious rookie move. Once the packing is burned, the WORST thing you can do is tighten it. If you continued to tighten packing that had already scorched, you very like have now scored the shaft that needs to come out. At a minimum, you need to change the log length to get onto some good shaft material (if you have room).

You don't need to pull the boat to put new packing in, but likely would need to if the shaft is scored. Also, if the packing is being difficult to get set up, you likely have alignment and/or other running gear issues that no amount of packing replacement and tightening is going to solve. Did the mechanic recommend or do an alignment before putting new packing in? Again, if not, serious rookie move.

Finally, yes, if the packing did not drip at all when you first put the boat back in, the mechanic likely screwed up putting it in and did the rookie move of over packing the gland. Packing needs to go in gently, then tighten up 1/4 turn at a time in the water until they are settled in.

Your suspicions are correct, and then some.
 
"If you continued to tighten packing that had already scorched, you very like have now scored the shaft that needs to come out. At a minimum, you need to change the log length to get onto some good shaft material (if you have room)."

Perhaps. But I wouldn't panic just yet and pull the shaft. I'd clean it up and polish it out. I've seen some deeply scored shafts that the packing still worked just fine on. And it doesn't sound like he ran it all that long when they were over tight.

"Also, if the packing is being difficult to get set up, you likely have alignment and/or other running gear issues that no amount of packing replacement and tightening is going to solve."

Again, no need to panic yet. While you should get the alignment checked every year. The stuffing box is normaly attached to a fairly fexible piece of hose, so it takes a lot of misalignment to cause a serious problem.

But Ghost is right, get another mechanic.
 
If you use GFO packing, make sure they just hand tighten it. GFO is easy to over tighten. Been there, done that. Good luck.
 
i agree with all of the above... :-) it's normal for a packing gland to need a little tightening / adjustment after the first run but NOT if it was running hot and dry!

packing is very basic, if your "mechanic" can't do it right, don't let him touch anything else on the boat...

and as Bill suggested, switch to GFO packing... it's almost dripless, much better than conventional.
 
--- and I am told that W*** sells GFU. I know nothing about it. You have the best advice you're going to get above. Replace with GFO.
 
Yes WM does sell GFU. But from what I can tell, it's not the same as real GFO. Which it seems you can only get online.
 
GFU ? or GFO ?

AFIK there is only one place that sells GFO online, google GFO Packing and it will come up.
 
There seems to be a lot of misconception about accepatable drip rates with packing. No packing, GFO or conventional should drip at rest with the shaft not turning. The drip rates always referred to are at idle in gear, with a turning shaft.
 
"you obviously cheaped out on doing your homework and getting a decent mechanic who would not make such serious rookie move."

Whoa there Ghost! No need to insult the poster without knowledge of what he did. You have no idea about his knowledge about this mechanic.

G
 
"you obviously cheaped out on doing your homework and getting a decent mechanic who would not make such serious rookie move."
I'm not offended, just amused. The mechanic who did the original work has been an excellent boat mechanic for 40 years and worked on my boat for the last 15 years without a problem. The kids who did the follow up work, who knows? As far me "cheaping out"... What does that mean? Relax, it's only a hobby!
 
Okay okay, too pointed, my apologies. But I stand by my comment that if you smelled something burning and the guy still went and tightened the packing gland, you need to get a new mechanic. Maybe he's just not familiar with inboards.
 
Could be a good opportunity to switch to dripless seals as employed by the vast majority of new power vessels, as long as your shafts are not presently scored. Just a thought...
 
GFO is dripless. Even underway. And it's a lot cheaper then new dripless packing boxes.
 
well, dripless are nice but when they fail (rarely) it's usually catastrophic... GFO is really a nice alternative although on a boat with Vee drives and the stuffing boxes buried under the engines, i'd probably go with PSS dripless is budget allows.
 
Back
Top