Piracy--the FUTURE

saltysam

Active member
Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2000
RO Number
26
Messages
1,117
The US Naval Institure blog has an interesting comment regarding the next movements in what is shaping up as a major concern:

“Abdullahi Lami, one of the pirates holding the Greek ship anchored in the Somali town of Gaan, said: ‘Every country will be treated the way it treats us. In the future, America will be the one mourning and crying,' he told The Associated Press. ‘We will retaliate (for) the killings of our men.'"

This is an interesting quotation... as it relays the pirate's sense of entitlement. For some reason, he thinks that they have a right to seize property and detain foreign citizens. The man quoted above seems to be as sure of his right to rob as we are sure of our right to freedom on the high seas. I wonder what led him to think this? Perhaps they've been conditioned to consider it a right given that payment of ransom is the standard procedure of dealing with pirates.

Anyway, we seem to be dealing with an ideology and not just a criminal enterprise. They truly think they have a right to rob, and it will take force to convince them that it is not in their interests to keep pursuing this “right."
 
Another Question about this stuff. We've learned from the White House that the Man himself was involved in the decision making process. I respect his desire to be a major cog in such important matters. Yet is seems to me that a great amount of policy decisions musy give way to a considerable body of authority granted to on-scene military commanders. This piracy habit seems to be well rooted in the African litterol and there will be additional actions. Can't have all decisions flowing up to the Washington folk. Not in my book.
 
"...and it will take force to convince them that it is not in their interests to keep pursuing this “right.”"

Ditto on the FORCE. This has been brewing for a long time.
 
I'm curious... do you think that now perhaps, there will be a demand for "security for hire" such as a "Blackwater" type, on these merchant ships? Trying to lesson the pirate threats on the seas?
 
I understand there has been some movement on these lines.
The most activity has to embark "Trainers" in some convenient port. They do not remain to fight the ship but conduct appropriate training for a crew and then leave at some other port prior to the ship entering the "danger zone". Insurance policie are very constrictive as are some International Law provisions.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Reel Antsy

I'm curious... do you think that now perhaps, there will be a demand for "security for hire" such as a "Blackwater" type, on these merchant ships? Trying to lesson the pirate threats on the seas?






Its becoming more and more feasible to hire out security. The revenues at risk are too high, and the savings from attack can pay the contracted security. As the probability gets higher and higher of being pirated, the feasibility gets higher and higher to look for outside protection. Sure would hate to be in a business that requires using this area of the world for anything! Hard decisions are upon the businesses, as well as the country and our policy decisions.
 
NPR this morning said at any point in time there are 20,000 boats (big and small) in this area and the odds are very low for any one vessle. There are also laws in some countries about the crews being armed and thus the boat will not be allowed into some ports.
 
I've read several places that it's 20,000 ships per year transiting the Gulf of Aden.

Which is about 55 a day. Even if they take several days to go through there, there should only be 200 or so large ships at a time in the area.

Why not have groups of armed guards, maybe 10 per ship, put on board at one end, taken off and put on a ship headed the reverse direction at the other end.

Might be a great job for UN peacekeepers. It's a multinational responsibility, and, they probably would not need to shoot anybody. These guys have shown no talent or stomach for action so far (speaking of the pirates, not the peacekeepers there...)

It solves the problem of armed crew/ships entering various ports - they never would. And it would take a force of maybe 2000 men, plus whatever support those men would need. I don't see why the world can't come up with that. I don't see why the US can't come up with that.

Or, the WWII solution - escorted convoys. Would it cost these guys too much to pause at a rendezvous point for a day? The threat is pretty lightweight so you would not need anything heavy duty for escorts.
 
I don't like the idea that the US would somehow be responsible for funding any new task given to any part of the UN. The Blue Hat guys have a bad reputation for any type of efficiency. I also believe that the US shipping in that area is a drop in the bucket when compared to other nations. It seems reasonable to me that the longterm design of a protective scheme should fall on those who use the area and who should be most interested in saving their own skin. But in recognition that we really are the preminent naval power (Ha!) we should be willing to fire off some shells if that is part of the necessary support of others.It all boils down to money, doesn't it.
 
Saltysam,

I believe the media snippet that said the POTUS personally authorized last night’s action is nothing more than publicity to show the POTUS is supportive of the action.

Basic rules of engagement that every service member receives before a deployment cover the right of self defense and that to protect the lives of others in a situation such as last night. Taking the right of self defense, that situation where negotiations were failing, and the Capt was in imminent danger, provide the moral and legal basis for the snipers taking the shot. IMO the POTUS was not calling the shots, although the outcome and means by way the outcome was achieved will no doubt begin to shape strategic policy on how we deal with pirates.
 
Jim There will always be specific ROE tailored to the forces under whatever commander is involved. I have no idea what the specifics are of the USCENTCOM Naval Force but I do know they can be very restrictive and will most often require adherence to specific actions that must be cleared with higher authority. In the U S Navy in particular there is a heavy thread that sends mucho authority to the Commanding Officer. So I really don't worry about what the USN does in response to a situation involving a US flagged ship.

My interest is directed to ensuring those flags that have many ships in the area assume their proper responsibilities.
 
Interesting question raised by a commentator last night.

Is piracy something that we should treat as an act of war? Or is it a law inforcement problem? The POTUS seems to want to treat is as a law enforcement problem. He wants to be the one that says when and and wether or not deadly force can be used. Whereas if we consider pirace an act of war then deadly force commitment can be made by lower lever commanders.

In my book piracy is an act of war and should always meet immediate deadly force. I have no time to wait for someone is Washington to make decisions.

However, I guess that Lyndon Johnson started the trend for the President to be involved in day to day decisions on how to run a war.

G

G
 
quote:

Originally posted by gcolton

....However, I guess that Lyndon Johnson started the trend for the President to be involved in day to day decisions on how to run a war.

G

G






Or how not to.
 
quote:

Originally posted by saltysam

I don't like the idea that the US would somehow be responsible for funding any new task given to any part of the UN. The Blue Hat guys have a bad reputation for any type of efficiency. I also believe that the US shipping in that area is a drop in the bucket when compared to other nations. It seems reasonable to me that the longterm design of a protective scheme should fall on those who use the area and who should be most interested in saving their own skin. But in recognition that we really are the preminent naval power (Ha!) we should be willing to fire off some shells if that is part of the necessary support of others.It all boils down to money, doesn't it.






Bill, I guess what I see coming is, this activity can only expand, and while most of the ships may not be US flagged, there are too many US citizens out there in harm's way. If not as crew, then as officers. So we will have more ordeals like this one, and they will not be so easily solved since the pirates will get smarter.

All the solutions so far discussed involve doing something about Somalia, (did you hear Gates play the "poor guys have no other way to make a living card" yesterday?) and absent an Iraq style invasion and nation building (which is not happening) that's not going to get better. There's either a solution out on the water, or there's not a solution other than keep paying big bucks to criminals. And a solution on the water involves some sort of defense strategy which we will need to drive since no one else is doing anything except the French. It should not be necessary to invent anything new. Piracy was solved once, and the U boat threat was pretty much solved once. The answers are in the past.
 
They can't watch the entire ocean area.
I don't understand why they can't watch the coast line.
When a ship leaves the coast follow it.
Or offer armed security boats for every boat transiting the area.
Make the shipping companies pay. Its certainly cheaper than paying ransom.
 
Piracy is a lucrative business model especially for a third world economy. Even if the world's navies kill 20-25 pirates monthly by disrupting an act on a weekly basis the business model will remain sound. There is an estimated 1500-2000 active pirates on the coast of Somalia and their lucrative business is attracting more. There is only one way to stop piracy. The only way is to quit paying ransoms and just sacrifice the ships, cargos, and hostages when necessary. Paying the ransoms should be declared an illegal act as it is totally the sponsor of the pirates.
 
Run the probable cost numbers. Routine Overhead surveillance by satillite is usually booked a long time in advance by the commercial and military birds of the world's powers. Drones must operate off mother ships of some type. Mucho resources to have perhaps 8-hrs coverage on daily basis. I suspect each drone comes in at a millon bucks or so. Then there are operator salaries. Not a small deal by any estimate. Who pays the freight ?

Then there is the fact that we are just now learning how many small pirate skiffs and larger boats are involved. Several Hundred. Did you take a look at the charts of Somalia? Take a look at GOOGLE. A very long coastline. Piracy has become the single best industry for hundreds of miles of poor folk.
 
I've been chatting with some other interested persons and pass on a consideration I had not considered.

This Mersk ship was not the first that has been hijacked. In other cases the USN did not have many ships in the area and the official position was to not get involved directly but to make some effort to get the pirate spokesman and the ship's owners conected. No further involvement or responsibility. All further details of conditions of captivity, ransom and payoff details were not followed. This process has worked to ensure that all captives were released unharmed, even though several hundred crew are still in captivity in a few Somalian coastal towns while waiting for shipowners to come to terms.

For some reason, perhaps the widespread identification of the Mersk ship with the Stars and Stripes or an American officer in command, the Mersk ship was handled differently. (I'm pleased that it was!) Forceful action was taken by the US Navy and the ship and crew were returned to normal operations, delivering relief material to the area. Now the pirates have been reported as threatening violent action in reprisal. We may have stirred up a hornet's nest. And the shipping world thus far has no suitable response. Must we standby for a large scale excallation in pirate behavior? Will today's heros be turned into yesterday's bad guys?
Not a simple situation.
Are we ready to handle violent assault by these brigands?
 
Back
Top