Quality depth finder

MrsRobinson

Active member
Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2005
RO Number
19626
Messages
1,074
While our boat is on the hard I would like to replace the depth finder. The current one works inconsistently. We have never owned a boat where the depth finder works consistently, so before I go out and buy a new one I am checking to see which one(s) you have had good results with. Current one is a Lowrance, previous boat had a Uniden. Both work(ed) 50% of the time.

I do not need bells and whistles, just quality and reliability.

I like the look and feel of the Raymarine ST40: http://www.raymarine.com/ProductDet
ECTION=2&PAGE=225&PRODUCT=407
 
I'd think it's more of a problem with the installation than the depthfinder. Transducer location is critical. If you install a new one and put the transducer where the old one was; there's a chance you still have the problem.
 
I agree with stmbtwle. On my first boat the transducer was located in a poor condition and I could not get a correct reading if I was going over idle speed. The bubbles created by the prop turning created the interference. On my next boat, the transducer was placed in the proper position to avoid interference and my DF reads accurately after 16 yrs.
 
I've had no less than 5 depth sounders w/ different 'ducers on my boat. The one that is far and away the best is the Garmin GSD21 w/ dual frequency transom mounted 'ducer displaying on my GPSMap 478. It reads down to 12" and keeps a lock on even at WOT (38mph).

https://buy.garmin.com/shop/shop.do?pID=368

g-r.jpg


IMG_2602.jpg
 
If you want the best, go with Furuno. FCV 620 is a 5.6", the FCV 585 is an 8.4", You also want to put in a high quality transducer: AirMar 260M gets very high marks.

However,I agree with the transducer installation as being a major issue. I have Lowrance Depthsounders, get excellent bottom tracking at up to 50 knots and read down to max depths, with good resolution. One of my other boats has a Garmin depth sounder--and I would say that it is adequate--but not as good as the Lowrance. The Garmin also holds the bottom.
 
The ST40 Bidata works fine for me. It display the depth on the unit itself and on the C80 with sonar. The ST40, other that a transducer is a computer trip, measures distance, water temperature, depth and more. It's a good unit for me so far. There may be better ones on the market for sure, but the ST40 is a unit I can rely on.

Just my 2 cents.

Find a pic of the ST40 on top of my C-80

1473631_5.jpeg
 
you need to be a little more explicit... what do you mean by it works inconsistently or 50
% of the time ?

does it loose the bottom when it gets too deep ? does speed affect the readings? do you loose signal when on plane or above a certain speed ?

i dont' think there is such a thing as a bad sounder... the location of the transducer is usually the issue. I have a very basic garmin, it works great... my previous boat had a interphase forward looking sonar with a transom mount transducer, it would work well even at 30kts (37' inboard boat).

the key is too make sure the transducer doesn't get any air or bubles, on the 37', it was about 6" from the center line, well inboard of the props and not behind any turbulence inducing things like intake scoops.

since sea ray tends to jam teh engines fairly close to center line, you may have some issues with finding clean water at the transom.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

you need to be a little more explicit... what do you mean by it works inconsistently or 50
% of the time ?

does it loose the bottom when it gets too deep ? does speed affect the readings? do you loose signal when on plane or above a certain speed ?

i dont' think there is such a thing as a bad sounder... the location of the transducer is usually the issue. I have a very basic garmin, it works great... my previous boat had a interphase forward looking sonar with a transom mount transducer, it would work well even at 30kts (37' inboard boat).

the key is too make sure the transducer doesn't get any air or bubles, on the 37', it was about 6" from the center line, well inboard of the props and not behind any turbulence inducing things like intake scoops.

since sea ray tends to jam teh engines fairly close to center line, you may have some issues with finding clean water at the transom.




True, the engines are jammed together, no argument there Pascal, and true they are a biatch to get at to work on. But, since they are mounted witgh V-drives, thru-hull 'ducers can be mounted very near the center line, actually just off the keel line and forward of the props. That's also forward of all water pick-ups and gives a good reading. I won't recommend my devices since they're so old they're no longer available. They are due to be replaced VERY soon.
 
Yeah I'm curious about the "..50% of the time"
Did the screen just go blank?
Did you get 'clutter' or 'rabbit tracks' over the screen?

If your out in rough water or High swells, you'll have some 'lost bottom' moments.
Also if the water is rising or your boat is rolling and your near the transition areas of one Range to another range, you'll have some 'lost bottom' moments.

I had a cheap Garmin (I've never had anything that wasn't cheap) that was only good for 300' and when I put it on automatic I got good results out at 300' and more.

But in closer at lesser depths, where I was trying to find shelf's and slopes down there, I'd lose the bottom under the conditions above.
Also it would spend a lot of time going from one range to another. Sometimes I'd have to put it in gear to get the pitch n' roll smooted out in order to get a stable reading.

I was always dissapointed in the Bottom echo. I wanted to see the Halibut!

Sometimes you cant tell hard bottm from Muddy bottom with Seaweed if you are in deeper waters.
My cheapo always showed fish all over the spectrum. Sea Clutter, stuff, especially after a stormy period or some really high tides would bring some crazy readings.
A lot of that I gave up to Cheap electronics but those good bottom readins I expected to be bang on and most of the time they were.
 
When we bought the boat it did not work at all, just flashed 8's all the time. I took it apart, did nothing but reinstall it (at the dash only) and now it works for a while then locks on a depth, usually "2". If I shut it off, then back on it will work for a while and then lock on a # again. Sometimes it will start flashing 8's again.

At the slip it never works (just displays "2") until we are in motion for a minute or two. At low speeds it works better, but it will still lock on a depth or start to flash "2". It is worse at higher speeds.

Boat is on the hard so I can find out where the transducer is. I think I recall seeing it forward of the props on the starboard side, close to the center.
 
Too bad you dont have some stuff to swap parts with.
It sounds like your processor is bad or the cable is shorted.
If you've had more than one processor go bad, you may have Voltage supply or grounding problems.

One time I hit a bad wave so hard the top of the boat seperated from the hull.
When they all came down in a pile, the Transducer cable had been squished to death and it made the Sounder read one Depth all the time.
I was able to fix it.

If your not Electrical troublshooting experienced you may not find a bad cable without some help.
You'd need a "Dummy Load" you can vary to test the processor.
 
Mrs. Robinson,

From what you just said it seems you are seeking advice on a pure depth finder with a digital readout. If so you can ignore most of the brand and model advice you have been receiving.

Do you have a GPS? Surely you do given the size of your boat.

You should have a decent sized GPS/Sounder combination for excellent results. Just about any Garmin or Lowrance unit will do just fine. Just get a combo unit with enought screen size to be user friendly. BTW, a lot of excellent advice on marine electronics is available on thehulltruth.com electronic forums. Give it a look.

Install the transduce in the bilge to "shoot through the hull". It's very, very easy to do using a good caulk to hold the transducer in place.

You can then set up your GPS to show your depth in about any size numbers you prefer right on the top center of your GPS screen. You can select both the size and position of the depth reading on the GPS screen while showing the mapping screen along with your position.

If you now have a GPS you may be able to add depth finding capability to it.

I've been following your posts for some time now. How long have you been a boat owner?
 
Mrs Robinson, what model is your Lowrance? If you are removing it, I may be interested in the unit for parts. Thanks, Bob
 
Greg,

Unless the hull changed drastically between 95 and 99, the transducer is almost desd center just forward of the engines, and aft of the A/C raw water pump. The Raymarine in my 330 works fine. It's an older version of the current ST 60 that I leave in depth mode. I like the large digits. The ST40 should do you well and may retrofit into the existing dash cutout. The one Littlepage has in his go fast read spot on at well over 50 MPH.
 
quote:

Originally posted by RMS

Mrs Robinson, what model is your Lowrance? If you are removing it, I may be interested in the unit for parts. Thanks, Bob






in-dash 3500 Lowrance
Lowrance originally agreed to rebuild it for about $50 then later said no.
 
did you check the manual to see if the flashing 8 or 2 maybe error code ?

check the connection and the cable, make sure it's not chaffing somewhere

have you tried adjusting the sensitivity / power ? in shallow waters if your signal is too strong it may cause problems (used to have that issue on the interphase).
 
quote:

Originally posted by Butch Davis

Mrs. Robinson,

From what you just said it seems you are seeking advice on a pure depth finder with a digital readout. If so you can ignore most of the brand and model advice you have been receiving.

Do you have a GPS? Surely you do given the size of your boat.

You should have a decent sized GPS/Sounder combination for excellent results. Just about any Garmin or Lowrance unit will do just fine. Just get a combo unit with enought screen size to be user friendly. BTW, a lot of excellent advice on marine electronics is available on thehulltruth.com electronic forums. Give it a look.

Install the transduce in the bilge to "shoot through the hull". It's very, very easy to do using a good caulk to hold the transducer in place.

You can then set up your GPS to show your depth in about any size numbers you prefer right on the top center of your GPS screen. You can select both the size and position of the depth reading on the GPS screen while showing the mapping screen along with your position.

If you now have a GPS you may be able to add depth finding capability to it.

I've been following your posts for some time now. How long have you been a boat owner?






Been boating with the Mrs for 8+ years, grew up around boats too, mainly sailboats and oyster/crab boats though.

We own the color version of this Garmin GPS: https://buy.garmin.com/shop/shop.do?pID=171 and from what I can tell there is no depth finder that integrates with it.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

did you check the manual to see if the flashing 8 or 2 maybe error code ?

check the connection and the cable, make sure it's not chaffing somewhere

have you tried adjusting the sensitivity / power ? in shallow waters if your signal is too strong it may cause problems (used to have that issue on the interphase).






No manual on the boat, but you made me think about looking for one on-line, which I just found:
http://www.lowrance.com/upload/Lowrance/Documents/Manuals/3500.pdf

So, once she is back in the water I will take the manual with me to the boat and see what we can do. Thanks
 
Greg,

It appears that the GSD-21 is an accessory to your GPS. It is a sounder module. In addition to the GSD-21 you would need a transducer. Please call Garmin to be certain but it looks very much as though for the cost of a GSD-21 and an inexpensive transducer you can have a guality sounder viewable on your GPS screen and or with depth numbers apperaing on your mapping screen.

Boatfix would be a good source for the two items plus definitive advice on compatibility.

Good luck.
 
Back
Top