Repairs on whose dime?

4roys

Member
Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2002
RO Number
7262
Messages
115
Have a 2004 Chaparral with a Volvo-Penta and the nutra salt system. Earlier this year the solution would empty itself after use. I thought there was a leak, couldn't find one and refilled. Again, after one use it emptied. Spoke to the marina who does any engine work (because it's a Volvo). They guessed either the switch at the dash or the solenoid after the tank. Since they were going to haul and wax, I asked them to fix. They tested, said solenoid after tank and replaced. I think by time of dignosis, fix, valve and solution it was about $200. (I know, I should have done myself). But they had the boat out and I wasn't going to be around for a few weeks.

Only problem was same thing happened again. the were good about it, said must be defective valve and replaced. The good news is it worked. Down this weekend and no more loss of the solution. The bad news is I got home last night and there was a bill for $123 to replace the defective part. Am I wrong or should that be on them? Why should I pay to do something twice, when it wasn't my fault? I do most things myself so I don't usually run into things like this. The marina has typically been fair with what they have done and charged, so I don't want to overreact, but am I right? Wrong? Thought I would ask before I said anything.
 
They didn't charge you for the replacment part. But the labor to replace the part was not part of the guarentee.
You may have some re-course with Volvo over the costs to replace one of their defective parts.
 
If I am following the history, it appears to you that they replaced the wrong part the first go around, and since you paid once to have it fixed, that you should not have to pay a second time, because they guessed wrong. Unfortunately, if you are going to keep using them and have a good relationship with the marina service, I would probally pay the $123 and not risk damaging the relationship. Getting a prompt repair that keeps you on the water vs boat sitting on the hard next time for days, would be worth the $123. However, I would also have to decide if I trusted their work enough to use them in the future, since they apparently replaced a part, without properly testing their repair work.
Just my thoughts,
Gary
 
You should pay twice because they fixed it twice. It's not their fault the part was defective, is it? If the error was with the labor, you should have some recourse but it's not.
 
Maintain the good relationship with the shop and be thankful you have one available nearby! I'd pay a $123 per month retainer fee if I could find that!
 
Your worrying about $123 on a boat? Good gawd, even when I owned a 1977 23' I didn't worry about that and nothing but change when talking about mechanic rates.

If I'm a mechanic, it's not always possible to know precisely what is wrong. You think I'm going to come down to your boat and do things for "free" because it was not possible to know between 2 or 3 components which was defective? Not a chance. If I did something wrong, that's one thing. But, if it was simply a job that you would not be willing to pay me to do without taking any chances, then its your dime.

bp
 
If I'm reading your post right, they diagnosed the problem, replaced parts and charged you once. That didn't solve the problem, right? Then they diagnosed it *differently* and replaced a different part that did fix the issue.

Is that right?

Now as many have said, if you want to maintain a good relationship with them for future concerns, then just buck up and pay the bill. If it were me though, I would pay the bill, but politely inquire as to why they replaced the first part if it wasn't the issue? Heck, ask them for the replaced part back as it's obviously good. ;)

If they don't appreciate the concern you have over this, then I'd suggest you find a different mechanic to work on your boat. One that doesn't just "shotgun" the problem to try and fix it by replacing parts willy nilly until the issue is resolved.

Money is money, regardless of the amount. It's more important IMHO that they charge for fixing the problem, not just charge you for *GUESSING* about what the fix is.
 
What ever happened to guaranteeing one's work?
 
Thanks for all the replies. I was a bit surprised at the general consensus to just pay the bill (which is what I was likely going to do anyway) but that's why I asked.

To clarify, they identified the problem correctly the first time, and I paid them the cost of the diagnosis, the cost of the part and the cost of the labor to replace the part. No questions asked. I don't think they were doing it "shotgun" as even after talking to Volvo they spent 1.5 hours diagnosing the problem. The problem was the new replacement part was defective, so they had to replace it a second time. My only question was if it was fair to pay twice. And I think Thudpucker was correct, except it sure looked on the bill like I was paying for a second valve.

Now the good news. I called just to let them know that the problem seemed to be fixed and I appreciated them getting it taken care of. Believe me, I know the value of a good relationship. Casually did a "Oh, did I have to pay for the defective part?". Turns out although they sent me an invoice, it was only for information (doesn't say that anywhere). They are trying to get Volvo to satisfy it becasue as far as they are concerned if the Volvo part wasn't defective there would not have been a second repair. If Volvo won't pay, I was told we'll figure something out. Which no doubt we will, and if I have to pay the full amount to keep them happy I will. I'm just glad to know they are at least trying.

And no, I don't expect anyone to work for free. I don't. I must have good taste in mechanics, because in 8 years through three boats I don't think I have ever questioned a bill for work on my boat. And I realize in the big picture, $123 is not a great deal. But it really would have ended up at like $350 by the time all was said and done. Still not a lot in the big picture, but not nothing, either. I just expect to be treated fairly. And Rommer's thought did cross my mind.
 
I got the wrong idea. Based on your last post, Volvo should pay. Like the time Volvo shipped us the right part # bolts for a drive plate, but in fact they were too long and the bolts did some custom machining and caused some damage. Volvo got to pick up the tab for that one, just as they should for this one.

bp
 
Back
Top