ROR

KnottyBuoyz

Active member
Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2006
RO Number
20406
Messages
1,584
I'm sure both of these captains could have benefited from Pascal's RoR quizzes!

"http://www.youtube.com/rafalek333"
 
Ouch! I saw no attempt by either vessel to avoid the situation.

"Every vessel shall at all times maintain a proper look-out..."
I'd suspect autopilots were involved, too.

(or maybe they were just trying to figure out who had the bigger boat)
 
Perhaps the larger give-way vessel was defending her tonnage (see "Rule of Tonnage" in Chapman), while the smaller stand-on vessel was defending her right-of-way (see "right-of-way" in Chapman). Both, naturally, are totally illegitimate, and contradict the actual Rules, to the detriment of safety, though Chapman couldn't care less.

As to look-out, the person recording the incident was certainly aware of the developing collision, if only mutely so.
 
...and it's not like visibility and sea conditions were really poor that day.
 
They both deserved the damage they got for each being to stubborn to move no matter who had the right of way.

2 Captains risking the lives of others who trust them just to play chicken and then both lose.

I don't think I heard any horns....

Both captains should loose their licenses.

JMHO of course.

JLC
 
A case of someone not having any common sense. A 5 year old would know at some point to turn, stop or something ?????
 
And the stupid people standing at the port rail never even moved an inch before the impact.
 
Both captains were either on auto-pilot, sleeping, eating but neither could have been in control of thier boats. This looks totally avoidable if either captain was at the wheel. It would be really lucky if no one was seriously injured, ouch! Regards Bill
 
When it comes to "right of way", graveyards are full of people who had the right of way.
 
Cant believe what I just saw! Un believable that that actually occured.

You can hear small children in the backround screaming, I just hope no one was hurt.
 
quote:

Originally posted by cwms

When it comes to "right of way", graveyards are full of people who had the right of way.






That's why it was taken away from pleasure boaters over 25 years ago.
 
It's ironic there would be 2 vessels named "Beagle" occupying the same small spot in a big ocean.
 
"Perhaps the larger give-way vessel was defending her tonnage (see "Rule of Tonnage" in Chapman), while the smaller stand-on vessel was defending her right-of-way (see "right-of-way" in Chapman). Both, naturally, are totally illegitimate, and contradict the actual Rules, to the detriment of safety, though Chapman couldn't care less. "

let's not give people the impression that Chapman's is otherwise inacurate... that would be a disservice to those who need to learn and could use a copy.

call it what you want... right of way, give way or stand on, both vessels are at fault here and the exact wording is completely irrelevant.

frankly, i don't care if the guy approaching on my port side thinks i have the right of way or he is the give way vessel, either way he will know he has to take action.

like it or not, Chapman's is still the best book out there to teach new boaters the basics of boating.
 
Boating basics.

Tonnage has it's privileges. It might save your life.

I wonder if either vessel sank ????
 
I think it was staged, both are in shallow water, and at least one capitain is at the helm, no horns, little screams.........D.........
 
I don't think it was staged. The boat that got hit was flying the Egyptian flag; the video said it was filmed in the Red See (sea). From my experience that's probably the way they drive there; I've been there and there are wrecks all over the place.

Wouldn't be any horns anyway if there was no-one at the conn... but you could see some of the passengers running.
 
it was prayer time... the captains were on their knees facing Mecca...
 
Back
Top