Single Engine vs Twins

Chris_P

Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2007
RO Number
28295
Messages
18
Hello all,

I've decided to trade in my 21' Jet Boat for a cruiser. We plan on doing weekend trips etc and needed something on which we can sleep when travelling.

After looking at the various offerings out there, I'm leaning towards the Rinker 280. This boat seems to offer a ton of features for thousands less than the competition.

My only concern is that this boat seems to be right at the size where other manufacturers offer twin engines. I'm not sure why Rinker does not offer it with twins, but my dealer insists that the 496 MAG Bravo 3 / dual props will be more than enough power for this boat.

Is that true? Also, are there any significant benefits in maneuverability to be gained from twin engines in a boat of this size? Their website lists the boat at 31 feet with a 9 foot beam (I believe the 31 ft includes the swim platform) and weight of 7640 lbs.
 
not sure about the power but from personal experience you will find it a challanging boat to dock with one screw and no bow thruster .... at least with any kind of current or breeze.

if it were me i would at least inquire about a thruster or get a boat with twins.

i would also think about resale value down the road. i am sorry but i would not consider that boat with a single motor at all.
 
I agree, a 28' foot with singles can be handled but it will be much more stressful. The power is not the issue but ease of close qtrs maneuvering.
 
I guess no one wants to learn how to really operate a boat anymore. I operated a single screw 28 ft. inboard for years, no bow thruster, no problem, dual props would have taken the prop torque problem away any made it easier. Sure my 36 twin is easier to dock, no bow thruster in it either.
I too think that is plenty of power for that boat unless you have a go fast need.
 
Having owned a 29ft single engine boat previously and now a 32ft twin engine boat, I highly recommend twins. Jim, I totally agree with your statement about learning to operate a boat, but if I had the choice I'd go with a twin engine boat every day of the week and twice on Sundays. Now, if $$ is a concern and the single engine boat is in the budget, but a twin engine boat is not, then go for it. The 496 mag is plenty of power for that boat and a Bravo 3 drive certainly helps the maneuverability quite a bit. I am a big fan of Rinker boats. You get a lot of boat for the money. Either way, good luck finding your next boat. ;)
 
I upgraded my single engine 26 to a 28 with twin 4.3's last year . I love having the twins and found docking much easier . I guess it cost's a little more for maintanice but I'm don't think it would be double. I only need to buy 4 more spark plugs than a V-8 and my two Alpha drive don't take a lot more oil than the Bravo 2 in the old boat. I keep the boat on a trailer when not using it and I thinks zinc's should last a long time. As far as fuel goes the 4.3's use only slightly more than the old single . On our last trip out I ran 12 hrs clocked 174 miles and used 90 gal . Now it sounds like you are buying new so mechanical break downs should not be a problem but if you plan on Ocean trips I think Twins are a must.
 
a friend of mine has a Rinker 278 vista 9'4"beam with a single 454,310hp. It has plenty of power with a top end of 40mph. Manuevering is another question.It can be handled in close quarters but does require more skill. If your looking for best fuel economy the single will be the way to go. If you want good manuevering, dependability that only comes from twin engines,than go a little bigger in boat size and go with the twin setup. He wishes he did. Tom
 
If it comes down to handling as the only issue for you, go with the single. With practice you'll become very good with it and there won't be a thing anyone can do with a twin that you can't do with the single regardless of conditions.

Fuel consumption, maintenance, and work space in the engine compartment are all things to consider. It's always nice to have the back up of a twin engine but Boat US can help with that issue. Unless it's speed you're looking for I can't imagine needing twins or thrusters on a boat that size.
 
There are lots of thing that you can do with twins that you can't do with a single, most people don't know how to operate a twin either, to make it do the extra. You can make up alot by knowing how to use spring lines and doing it.
 
i agreee you can learn to operate a boat with a single and no thruster...try docking a 40' dorado with a tunnel and a broken thruster ....it does not step sideways in reverse it leaps....but if you start backing up 2 slips down you are ok....

the point is the twins will be much much easier then the single and as much as i run i want to be able to get to the dock as easy as possible. short of a tropical storm i leave the dock and run to my destination. i have docked more then once with a 25kt cross breeze...u will have big issues doing that with a single screw..
 
I will add my personal experience to all of the good advice posted here. I had an impeller fail while away from homeport, and was easily able to get home on one engine. A month ago I had a complete failure of the port Velvet-drive transmission while underway and very far from home (150 miles). After local inspection revealed the need for a haulout and rebuild, I was able to get back to my slip on one engine.
As this is written the boat is out and being worked on, but at least it is at a local shop where I can check progress.

Safe and Happy Boating!
ColonyCove
 
quote:

Originally posted by JimPend

There are lots of thing that you can do with twins that you can't do with a single, most people don't know how to operate a twin either, to make it do the extra.





No, the real problem is many people don't know how to operate a single.
 
I had a Searay 290 Sundancer for 5 years with a single 454 in it (Bravo II drive). While I was "okay" maneuvering it at docking speeds, there were always times that caused a few more gray hairs to sprout from my head.

Since I've gone to a twin engine boat (with separate shifter/throttle controls) I've never once gotten tense while maneuvering in the marina.

Yes, it's a HUGE FREAKIN difference and everyone that I know, on my dock, that has a single, wants to trade up and get into twins.
 
That boat should be able to be handled with a single, no problem. Have you taken it for a demo ride? For comparison, my 270 Amberjack has roughly the same dimensions: 30' long; 7500 lbs; 8'6" beam; with a 350 MAG 300 HP Bravo III engine. So far I have never wished I had a twin engine setup in my boat. I think the BIII's dual props significantly contribute to it's easy handling, and find it very easy to maneuver around the dock. Of course each boat is different.

I'm not a big fan of twin engines just for the sake of twin engines. When looking for a boat, I specifically wanted a single engine setup because of fuel costs.

You said you want to do some weekend trips and sleep aboard. That says to me you don't plan (at this time) to be cruising extensively. I would say that further reduces the need for twin engines; and in fact many larger cruising boats (trawlers, etc.) still have a single engine. If you have and engine problem and are far from home, you still probably can't get home on the one left. Best you can do is limp to another port.

Consider this: how far do you want to go, and how deep are your pockets? Additional maintenance aside, a twin setup will roughly double your fuel costs. High fuel costs will likely reduce the number of trips you'll take.

I was talking to a guy a couple weeks ago about this subject. He was lamenting his twin engines because of the fuel use and a resulting reduction in trips he's taking. He used to go from the south shore of long island to Montauk and Block Island. Now by the time he gets to Montauk or 1/2 way to Block Island, he's burned $600 of fuel and still has the return trip. He's considering downsizing his boat to a single engine to cut back on fuel costs but take more trips.

Brad
 
My boat is 29'--weighs about 9000. I have a single 7.4 w/ Bravo II. I don't even have the Bravo III which also helps close quarter maneuvering.

I simply don't find it a problem. I back stern-in into my slip and just don't have problems. On Sunday night, we came in under a fairly stiff breeze. I started my turn a few slips up and just eased it in and out of gear all the way in. Using forward as needed to straighten the stern. It also becomnes a timing issue. Once I get any part of the boat to the slip (usually the starboard stern), I can power-pivot in.

I have no options other than what I have, so I don't miss thrusters or twins. When I move up to my next cruiser, I will have learned from the ground up.

One of my dockmates has a new 340 Sundancer. He has thrusters on it. We're pretty good friends now and we like to trade barbs. I told him one day to quit relying on those sissy training wheels (aka--bow thrusters). Well, it worked. He never uses them anymore. He likes the confidence of knowing that he has them, but he never uses them anymore.

Anyway, the Rinker you're looking at, and my boat, are very comparable. You'll have a slight edge with the B3. I don't find the single an issue whatsoever. I agree with your salesman-- it will do perfectly fine. If I lived on the coast, I might like to have the backup of twins. If I were in an area with frequent strong currents, I might feel differently. Me? I'm on an inland freshwater lake.

EDIT: FWIW, my boat was available with twins (4.3s), but I think the people who got those tended to be on the coast). My beam about 10'.

Paul
 
Wasn't this very same question posted in the "Men's Only" forum a few months back?? I sure enjoyed those reponses. lol
 
Wow at first I thought people were talking about single screw inboards being a problem to maneuver. But no, were talking about a single inboard/outboard and a dual prop to boot!!!

Hell no, a boat like that is not a problem to dock at all. Sure twins are nice if you like double the maintenance, but the advice you are being given is being done so by the, oh so typical, mentality of not wanting to learn how to drive the boat. That's just irresponsible.

Twins are nice, but I wouldn't shy away from an outdrive powered single in that size range at all.

bp
 
I have a Rinker 250EC with the 350Mag/BIII and its great. Very economical and good handling. My LOA is 27'1" and there are times I wish I had twins for docking on those very windy days with strong current, but that's a big expense just for easier docking. The single BIII is great and it just takes some practice to maneuver with a single in less than perfect conditions. I would ask the dealer to take you out on the boat on a windy day and watch him dock it. See how he does. Yes you give up some close quarters maneuverability with a single, but your fuel and maintenance expenses will be so much less. Unless you take long trips way out in the ocean and need twins "just in case", I wouldn't hesitate with the single I/O.
 
Twins are not the be all and end all that some make them out to be. Since Time and memorial sailors have traveled the open ocean with less than 2 engines.
 
I used to own a boat with twin I/O Volvos. (23' Formula) There was not a significant difference in handling with the extra engine even with counter rotating props. I alway docked the boat with one engine in neutral even in a cross wind as it was simply easier than fussing with an extra engine that didn't add much value other than redundancy and speed.
 
Back
Top