Speed?

drpete3

Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2006
RO Number
22165
Messages
176
Just got a new boat and I am wondering if some one can give me some input.

New to me baot wot 4800 speed 57mph prop pitch 21 bravo out drive

old boat wot 4800 speed 37 mph prop pitch 19 alpha one outdrive

how can there be such a differnce in speed with only a 2" drop in prop pitch and the same rpm's?

Is it the gearing in the out drive?
 
Different gear ratio's in the outdrive for one coupled with higher horsepower.
 
It could also be the speedometer. Unless it is a GPS or a GPS coupled speedometer both were likely inaccurate.
 
Different size engines?? Different boats (LOA/beam)?? Lots of reasons the speed could be different.
 
All boats are designed to be different in the water. Some designs are better than others.
 
For example, Stingray builds a 20 footer with a 4.3 220HP in it that will hit 65mph on a GPS. My 20 footer with a 5.0L 220HP will just barely get over 50mph on a GPS.
 
Lets see

Different gear ratios

Different engines

Different on water conditions

Different boats

Different hull designs

Different boat weights (see previos item)

Different horsepower
 
You failed to tell us what kind of boats, engines you have/had.
 
"My 20 footer with a 5.0L 220HP will just barely get over 50mph on a GPS."

But his Speedometer was more accurate so the boat really was going faster.
 
Wait guys some of the answers are irrelevant to the situation and are frankly incorrect.

Differnt horsepower and different engines....No because that is one of the factors that turns the prop to 4800 rpm.

Hull design that was one thing I didnt think of but that must relate to prop slip.

Both were on similar load, 2 kids my wife and I, and water conditions with best possible trim conditions.

Mostly I am thinking in terms of thrust and the princlple of If one prop is turn at 4800 rpm there is a theoretcal speed it should reach. So in my example 2 differnt props are going with the engine at 4800 rpms why would there be such a big differnce in speed? Hull design and gear ratios are the only 2 answers that make sence to me. At least so far.
 
Drpete.

As the caveman said to the therapist, "say what?"

The prop never turns 4800RPM the ENGINE turns 4800RPM. The transmission/outdrive will reduce the prop speed down to different speed. For example a 2 to 1 reduction means the prop will be only turning 2400RPM

Alpha drives have the following gear ratios
Available Gear Ratios 1.47, 1.62, 1.81, 2.00, 2.40:1

Bravo 3's
Available Gear Ratios 1.81, 2.00, 2.20, 2.43:1
 
quote:

Originally posted by In the know

Lets see

Different gear ratios

Different engines

Different on water conditions

Different boats

Different hull designs

Different boat weights (see previos item)

Different horsepower






drpete,
what part of ALL THE ABOVE don't you understand?

Also, sounds like you are trying to equate the number of revolutions a car engine/wheels turn and the speed of the car with the number of revolutions a boat engine/propeller turns and the boats speed.
The 2 are so different, you can't begin to compare. It's like comparing apples with potatoes.

My boat with twin 454's turning 4400 RPM's will only get you about 25 mph.
 
Don't make me explain this with jello and a bathtub.

Anyway, here's a neat site where you can enter RPMs, gear ratio, slip% and pitch to get a theoretical speed. Play with the gear ratio, and you'll get a better feel for why two boats' engines running at equal 4800 RPMs will give you different speeds.

http://www.boatramp.com/prop_applet/PropAnalyzerAppletG.html
 
Any one happen to know what the gear ratio would be on my 1989 bravo?

The Boat i am comparing to is my 1987 Fourwinns Horizon 210. It has 305 v-8 200 hp. Still a v hull design and 500 pds less than the Baja.
 
Not trying to give you a hard time about this, but what is the need for this info. What are you trying to accomplish?
Is this just a "I'd like to know" or are you planning some changes based on the info?
 
No changes, just trying to understand this a little better. I am a man of physics.

Really the question I should ask is why does my new boat go so much faster than the old?

If you answer hp well yea but my initial thought was this engine is turning 4800 and so was my old. So is it the gears in the outdrive? 2 inches of prop pitch doesnt come close to that. Thay are both v hull desings and one 3500 pds the other 3200pds one 24 ft the other 21. Looking at those factors they are very similar. BTW speed was with gps. The gears are my big unknown.
 
Let's see, 4800 rpm in low is going to result in a different speed than 4800 in overdrive...
 
Drpete

So we are comparing a 305 v-8 200 hp to ??????

I think your explanation is excellent JD.
 
drpete,
You have no idea how much just the slightest difference in boat shape and weight will have on the speed of a boat. 2 identical boats with 3 degrees difference in deadrise will give you several mph difference. Now throw in the difference in weight, prop design, gear ratio, length of hull, motor size and HP, the difference between an inboard and an outboard and the speed differences can be dramatic.
When it comes to boats moving thru water, sometimes 2 + 2 does NOT equal 4. That's the nature of the beast.
 
The other factor which is implied but not directly mentioned, is prop slip. Theoretically a 21" prop should move the boat 21" thru the water in each revolution. This does not happen, and the amount of difference between theoretical and actual is the prop "slip". A prop slip calculator is at:
http://www.go-fast.com/Prop_Slip_Calculator.htm

A good book to read is David Gerr's "Nature of Boats" and Propeller Handbook--if you really want to understand the "physics".

Even same "V"'s will have different resistance. There are multiple factors--but it is a good idea to know--and understand.
 
Back
Top