VHF's

November Charlie

Moderator
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
824
Messages
2,407
Okay, here we go....

First up: Radio Checks!!!!

Yep, if it worked last time, unless you've changed something, it probably still works. But if in doubt (and the boats I run have radio checks done every morning, there's nothing wrong with it), and you feel more comfortable checking before you get underway - DON'T DO IT on 16. Channel 16 is, indeed, the international hailing and distress frequency. If you know of a boat that's on a working channel, you could use that. If you know of a boat that's on 16, hail them and switch to a working channel to conduct your radio check. If you don't know of anyone with a radio, call a marina, harbormaster, et cetera, and ask them if they have a minute to switch and answer on a working channel for a radio check. If people aren't getting reprimanded when they do this on 16, it's not because it's okay, nor because there's a local variance to federal law (we'll not touch blue lights here). It's possibly, oh, maybe, because it clutters up the air even more to do so, and maybe because it encourages the idea that someone in a known position will answer up - even though it's not to say "Yeeeeeah, buddy, I gotcha five by five", it confirms transmission to and reception from a known position - id est, a radio check, encouraging more persons to do the same stupid stunt, until SOMEONE's ready to pull out the hair they don't even have!

Next: They can hear me, I can't hear them -or, more likely-, I can hear them but they can only hear me if I'm close:

Switch the channel set back to "USA" (presuming you are, indeed, in the USA. This may not serve you well if you're boating in Uzbekistan). 99 times out of a hundred you don't need the new radio, just need to use the old one right, though new electronic toys are indeed really cool. Nothing wrong with that. We're boaters, we like new toys. That's how it is.

***IMPORTANT one here: Distress communications.*** Okay, this one presumes you know where you are. Cool thing to know, especially since if you need real help real fast, you generally need it where you are. If you need it somewhere else, you should know where that is, too, but how important could it really be to you if you're not there but elsewhere? Friendly people coming to help you NEED (as in, NEED, MUST, IMPERATIVE, SHALL, MANDATORY, NOT OPTIONAL, all caps, must be important):

01- Position - refer to above paragraph. Or not. This one can really explain itself.
02- Number of persons on board - okay, this is total number of persons on the boat. Not how many people besides you, your wife, and brother in law. How many people are they coming for.
03- Nature of Distress - Motor Lifeboat crews will probably want to know what they're getting into, even though it usually turns out to be something totally different. Nota Bene: If there are further problems - such as, ohhh, I dunno, when the boat started sinking one guy went into cardiac arrest and is unconscious, unresponsive, pulseless and apneic, please, DO TELL. Don't wait until they get there to let them figure it out. It's not a surprise birthday party. (if it, in fact, is, better have ice cream cake. Someone's bound to be unhappy.)
04- And, of course, Description of Vessel. Not the time to call your 15' tri-hull a luxury sportsfisher. A real boat fire, this is easy - "it's the third roiling, dense black smoking pyre from the Morse Alpha Buoy, with the scorched white hull - can't miss it", but one taking on water or experiencing some other distress in a busy area, or one that might be sixty fathoms true south whenthe boat gets there, or any situation where size and style both matter (of the boat, that is) - which, if the boats in trouble, is all situations...

For example: "MAYDAY MAYDAY MAYDAY, Pleasure craft Forgotthegarboardplug-again, by the number 13 buoy in Nowhere Channel, 42-40.55, 071-33.24, with three persons onboard, taking on water through the empty drain plug hole, Forgotthegarboardplug-again is a 20 foot White on White Sea Rat with a blue bimini top"

Pretty sure there was more I wanted to cover, but it's late and I don't remember what right now. So, what am I forgetting here?
 
Nah, I think I post this every summer, and every summer I see why I post it - time after time after time. I'm always on the boat that's not sinking and generally not on fire, so I'm okay with just about anything. I just see too many situations made worse by panic and lack of foresight, planning, planning, and foresight and planning. And panic. For instance, beaching the boat will indeed keep it from sinking - but if there's ANYTHING breaking on the beach, even a foot or so, beaching it WILL fill it with sand as the tide comes in, so it can't be towed off. At least not floating. And I've never seen a small boat sink. Seen lots of them swamp, or swamp, roll and go bow up, but never go to the bottom ('true south'), least not for a while. If there's a boat with a real pump, a damage control expert, two EMT's, and another one right behind it with two more real pumps (real meaning at least 250 gallons per minute a pop), within a hundred yards - I'm not saying what's right or wrong, just that some things should be considered before committing the boat to a total constructive loss and a long day on a beach you weren't planning on spending the day at. Especially without snacks. Get hungry sitting on the beach all day.

Knowing what can happen, will happen, and what can be done about it and what effect it will have is not an optional thing if you want to get away with the inevitable. All it takes is a little brain energy. Don't even need little charts or checklists or stickers, just a few minutes of thought. Thought is cheap. Unless you're a lawyer or a politician, in which case your thinking costs too much and causes too much trouble anyways.
 
I've heard exchanges between Station MIA and boats that had called to report being in distress or aground and unable to give their position. sometimes took the CG a few attempts to get them to find their position on the GPS and read it correctly. hard to believe but true.

now, what i'd like to know is if the CG stations are equipped to receive positon data if i press the emergency button on my VHF (yes, it is connected to the GPS) ? I thought the system was not operational yet, is it ?

and.. if only the Miami station coudl broadcast reports on 22A slow enough to understand... most of the time they spit out the position numbers so fast there is no way to jot them down... and no, it's not my radio or my ears, I can understand everybody else just fine ! :-)
 
The GPS positions are only good for the Coast Guard, not good for me. I'm at the helm on the boat, don't have time to punch the GPS up, it could be right next to me and I would not know it, the CG's have people next to them to punch it up. That is what's wrong with not using charts. You dumb guys use GPS, not charts, I don't know where 41.xx.xx, 83.yy.yy, is, I do know where 1 mile SW of South Bass Island is.
I was on the lake (Lake Erie) Sat. morning, it was bad, I have a 36 ft. no real problem for me 4-6 footers, but there were a bunch of 19-22 footers having problems. They should not have been there, the driver did not know how to handle the boat, if they did they would not have been there. I would bet they had GPS, no charts and really did not know where they were. I rest my case.
 
Mike, I'm glad guys/gals like you are out there for us and that you take the time to post these kinds of things!

Jim, sometimes I just wish you would go ahead and type away to your hearts desire and then just forget to hit that submit button. Is there anything out there that doesn't piss you off? How can we all make your life better?
 
Don't know if they're set up for MMSI down there - give them a shout, though, I'm sure they wouldn't mind the questions. Fast talking on the radio might be from having a few things going on the radio and a few on the phone - been guilty of it myself. Sometimes you forget you're the only one doing 90 in a 55, so to speak.
 
Jim, hit the "enter" button once (or twice some models) while on map mode on the GPS and a interface box will pop up with the lat/long coordinates. Might as well learn how to use modern tech in conjunction with charts.

On edit: I'd like to also point out that even with the DSC red "panic button" that most VHF's carry these days where they are interconnected to the GPS...the CG still recommends following up with a conventional "mayday" call on 16. Don't rely soley on the red button!
 
Jim, the newer radios interface with your GPS and automatically transmit your co-ordinates, that said, I'd still say, "Coastie Coastie coma sava my boat,,,"
 
The dumb guy is the one who can be found because he gave a lat and long instead of a vague geographic? Doesn't follow reason to me. But I'm dumb - I keep an updated fix.
 
Mike, I in there with ya. You do not need to know a lot to "meet the minimums". And knowing how to transmit a Mayday message on VHF is one of those "You need to know how to do this" things.

( Mike and Pascal already know this one... )

Don't forget that often it is a -nearby neighbor- who is first on the scene. And while it is unlikely that they carry one of those really cool pumps, it IS likely that they can provide support and fish you out of the water if required. They may be able to help stabilize things enough that things do not get worse while professional help is in transit. So STATE YOUR POSITION and VESSEL DESCRIPTION clearly. Boat to boat communication is line-of-sight, so if a neighbor actually hears you , he is pretty close, often 6 nm or less!
 
Jim
while i agree with you to some extent regarding GPS vs chart, i don't know where you can safely keep a chart on an open 20 footer in crappy condition... GPS is actually more practical, although obviously charts should be kept handy.

as to being dumb, most GPS out there show the lat/lon on the main page and if you move the pointer it will show you the pointer location. When I hear the notice of upcoming info on 22A, I either grab a pen or I scale out the chart plotter and start moving the cursor as they give the position. this way i see right away where the problem is...

Now, i would imagine that someone with the superior intelligence to use paper charts instead of GPS coudl quickly locate coordinates on a chart... you know.. those vertical and horizontal lines...
 
You guys don't understand basic boating, you can use 16 on a new install, not everyday.
Anyone that reads off GPS cords, I know that no charts were used if that is all the say, if they say 1 mile sw of South Bass, 41.xx.xx, 83.yy.yy,. That is great. I can punch GPS with the best of you, and I would do it, if I thought I was near them.
Really didn't much care that day, you really don't belong on Lake Erie in anything less than 24 ft. fishing, the wakes alone could sink you.
 
quote:

Originally posted by JimPend

Really didn't much care that day, you really don't belong on Lake Erie in anything less than 24 ft. fishing, the wakes alone could sink you.






That's pure crap. I've safely boated Superior in an 18 foot bowrider as well as my current boat in 4 foot plus. It just takes longer to go from point A to B. It's up to the operator to know how to handle his rig.

I'm pretty sure that Capt. McSorley knew his rig's limitations as well...and it's still on the bottom in 550 feet of water. (Fitzgerald)
 
actually Jim, the CG always ask for a GPS position... whether or not the vessel has given an actual fix. i don't think anyone will argue that reading the position on screen is more accurate than triangulating a fix off some landmarks... how do you know you're 1 NM southwest of South Bass unless you get at least another fix... yeah... and SW is accurate, right ? if you're looking for a small boat in 4 footers, you'd better have something more accurate than SW of xxxx !!!
 
PascalG, you don't have to have the chart with you, you should have known where you were going, before you left, using a chart. You should have checked a chart before you moved much.
You have to understand where I boat, you can be 10 miles out in the lake and be in 3 feet of water, maybe where you are you can be a mile off shore and be in 100 feet.
I like the GPS cords, but give me an approx. if I'm close then I'll go with GPS. Charts are basic, GPS is good. Just tired of people trying to use chart plotters where navigation is very important. We just had 7 people hurt hitting a jetty, problem, not navigating, just using a chart plotter. Only missed by 20 feet.
 
Jim, I realise that you are promoting good navigations skills. Fine.

But in the event that, for example, you are the person disabled, would the person handling the VHF be able to sort out the charts effectively, or give a GPS reading. The accuracy of their fix would almost certainly be less accurate using charts and landmarks than using the GPS, especially in the event of a lack of readily visible ( and readable ) navigation marks or other landmarks.

I do truly understand the case you are trying to present, but for most boaters ( and unfortunately, those most likely to have a problem ) the GPS lon/lat is the best answer.
 
Having spent my share of time during the 8 years I was with Sea Tow out looking for boats, I can tell you that lat/lon coordinates save hours of time. (Jim, I thought paper charts had latitude and longitude on them. I seem to recall numbers along the tops and sides of the charts.) I can't even count the number of times that I was told "I'm five miles out directly off the inlet" only to eventually find the guy about two miles out and a mile north of the inlet. Of course, the guy will say, "We are in a 22' white center console." A look seaward on any weekend afternoon will reveal that there are no less than 100 22' white center consoles on the horizon.

We even installed VHF RDFs in the boats just because the position reports were so unreliable. The difference between people being plucked off a boat and pumps being set up to save the boat and fishing people out of the water with the boat on the ocean bottom can be minutes. If you need help, there are resources available - but they have to be able to find you. Mike speaks with straight tongue.
 
Back
Top