Kenny
Not sure if this helps you or not...
Last year I used a foam pad with Buff Magic, then followed with foam application of ProPolish. Both using a Milwaukee rotary buffer. I did not like the results. This year I am using a wool polish pad with BM, and then foam pad for the PP, and so far liking it.
1st lesson for me... Since my boat is older, I found wool helps at getting the oxidation off first (but don't apply pressure, just work it until you're happy with the depth), and foam does a nice job with the polishing (step 2).
The second learning experience for me is having extra clean pads to stay ahead of the buildup aquired with BM. Despite spurring the pad, I reach a point where the pad seems less effective (shine tends to haze, or cloud) at giving me the look I want unless I change it.
I would imagine everyone has to learn what works for their situation. I would try again. refining some part of your process this year. Rotary can be work too, but by hand sounds pretty painful. I'll look you up again this summer before heading over to the Point - we can swap stories over a cold beverage.
Don