When to stop looking...

mbr760

Member
exMember
Joined
Feb 21, 2007
RO Number
25277
Messages
13
I just sold my boat so I'm back in the market for a new one. Given the conflict between my desires and available dollars, I'm considering some early 90's models and was wondering....given changes and advances in technology is there a cut-off point at which I should stop considering boats? Like before 199X they didn't do this or used this material instead of the newer, better "that" material. I fell in love with a 2000 Cruisers 4270 and then started considering a 2002 3870, but now I've found a 1993 Sea Ray that I like that's considerably less money and...anyway, it just got me thinking that there might be an age beyond which I might be better not considering. No point in being penny wise and poud foolish.
 
IMO it all boils down to brand and condition. A 25 or 30 year old boat that was well made and properly maintained will always demand a high price. OTOH, I've seen some 3 year old boats that you couldn't give me.
 
That was a great question, and I think you are on to something... sorry to say I can't offer you any advice in this matter, really looking forward to the guys or gals that will answer this.

Walter
 
quote:

Stop looking at 2006 and lower.




Most of us would be out of boating or driving a 18 foot bowrider if we followed that advice. My boat is 22 years old and is well maintained. It's alot more boat than I could ever afford at 2006 or newer.
 
I have a 1993 40 Sedan Bridge Mainship. I love the boat. I have spent a pile of money replacing "everything" it didn't need to be done. I just wanted to modernize a 13 year old boat I love and intend to keep. The list is to large to post here of the replacement components and upgrades (and boring). I would do it again if you ask. My major point is most of what I had replaced didn't need to be done the boat ran great as it was.
Take care. Bill
 
No cut-off, depends on the brand, condition, maintenance history, and build quality.

I have seen 1-3 year old boats that could not hold a candle to my old Blackfin.
 
I sold my 1993 Sea Ray in 2004. You should look for a newer boat as the maintenance gets to be something else after 10 years. That was a very high maintenance boat from 93 until I sold it in 2004. Ate sparkplugs, ignition wires and leaked. The leaks simply could not be fiixed.
 
There are multiple facets to this question. One problem which crops up is the fuel tanks--and 15 to 20 years you are very likely looking at replacement. This is invasive and expensive. Another issue is engines. If you are looking at gas engines--at 10 years you may be (depending on care) looking at replacement. Diesels--depends on the type and degree of output/displacement.

Also style. I personally don't like the style of many of the newer boats, and would not consider them.

Any boat will also depend on the survey--and you really want to find the very best hull and equiptment as well as separate mechanical/engine surverys you can find.

If I was looking at a boat older than 10 years, I would put aside considerably more money for "restoration"

The other way to go, is a boat you really like--at the best price--and do a restoration. Just figure that you will replaec all of the systems and price accordingly--Assuming you find a good hull, with no soft deck or water/core intrustion problems.
 
What type of boat and year did you have?
I will stress the point of upkeep on older boats. How handy are you, and/or how willing are you to do the work yourself.

I have a 1988 silverton 34C - I absolutly love the boat - but it comes at a price of my sweat and labor, somthing that I also enjoy, its my out from the daily grind. I have newwer engines, a solid hull, no leaks, and she shows very well.

Its the "little" things that come up ALL THE TIME. Old 12 volt lighting, water pumps, hoses, worn hinges, old appliances, old wiring, old electronics, worn "soft" components like interior blinds, curtains, cuchions and such. Bad breakers, fuses, shore power receptacles, coroded haws pipes, cleats, rod holders. Worn out snaps, foggy gauges, squeeky bridge chairs, leaky helms, stiff cables, anoying stress cracks (cosmetic), worn port hole screens, broken hatch levers.............

Notice I did not mention, replacing enclosures, impellers, filters, refinishing teak, replacing clamps, packing glands, weather striping, pin striping, out door carpet and seat cushions, exhaust risers - these items will always be an issue even on newer boats (5 years +)

The items I listed - I replaced myslef, over time and at my leasure with minimal cost (all things considered)However, If I hired out the replacement (constant work) I would need a second mortgage.

As far as fuel tanks, I know of many boats of my aera with the original tanks, not sure if that would be an issue for you. I have basically replaced most of my systems in the last 18 months (as long as I have owned her). I have more boat than I could afford if the boat was even 10 years newer, and at this point a good portion of the work is done and she is "worry free" - however there is alwayas something to be done. As I stated, it's part of the enjoyment of owning a boat - for me, not everyone will agree.

So again, if you are willing to donate your time and sweat, go for a well made and well maintained boat with the layout and lines you like, and get to work!
 
Bravo, I agree as a 1985 carver owner.. I have aluminum tanks and they look great !
 
From what I've read, the biggest change in boat technology in the last few years is to the engines. Most boat makers now install EFI type engines or redesigned diesels. This has caused the cost of new boats to skyrocket. In fact, if my boat were totaled, I would not be able to afford to replace it. I'd have to find a good older boat or get out of boating altogether. You may want to consider whether or not you want the older carbed engines or the new more efficient EFIs.
 
I did exactly what Britanic mentioned replaced everything from motors (now MPI computer controlled), transmissions, V drives, shaft bearings and seals, props, generator, all appliances, installed all new LED lighting, both Air Conditioning units and pump, new seat covers, combing pads, all water tanks and replaced the waste system and converted to a VacuFlush. All my electronics are now circa 2006-7. I rewired the entire boat, installed a large all AGM house bank and inverter. I have no leaks on my boat. Just finished having all the cracks repaired and gelcoated (all cosmetic). I could go on and on. Most of the interior has been recovered or replaced. There isn't an old hose, hot water heater or pump in the boat, even all the faucets are new. I installed a secondary 13 position DC breaker panel for all the new entertainment and communication equipment.
All the navigation equipment has been upgraded to the latest Garmin 4212 chart plotters networked to the Garmin support devices. I have new electronic shift/throttles, rope/chain windlass and a nifty bow thruster system. The top and Eissenglass have been replaced. I had a new radar arch built last year to accommidate all the antennas. I have internet and cell service 8-12 miles off shore with amplifiers and external antennas as well as a sat-phone. The boat has a DC 7-8GPH watermaker installed. But I will stress this point most of what I had done did not need to be done I did it as a project. I'm not done the refurb/upgrade I'm in the process of adding a custom hardtop with solar panels and AC/Heat unit for the bridge. I really can take this boat anywhere within her limits without fear of a major failure. Take care. Bill
 
Another thing to consider. Much of the newer technology being applied to boat hulls is directly related to the task of "removing" glass and resin from the build. Those materials are expensive. It makes the boat lighter and therefore easier to push. But...its not all good news. Tradeoffs of course. A lighter boat gets tossed around more. While, pound for pound the thinner laminate is stronger, it may not be so in comparing the old hull to the new hull. The older, thicker hull laminate very often is in total (not pound for pound) much stronger. Better or worse? That depends. Personally, I like the thicker hulls. Older boats tend to have wood coring. Wood is usually lighter and stronger than alternatives, but will rot and fail if it gets wet. Often it does. Depending upon where the coring is located, it is either fixable or sometimes cost prohibitive (hull coring).

There is no perfect answer.

Personally, I tend to like the styling of older boats. I take tylenol for headaches, not for styling. But boat refurbs are not for the faint of heart or those who are not hands on.

The most true principle of most serious boat owners is that we look at everything. Fifteen minutes after closing the deal on the "last one", were still looking at anything from an 8 foot dingy on up. Boats, they are all different, all fun. While there certainly are the turnkey cocktail crown that buys boats but knows nothing of them, most of the serious guys will get off their 65 foot million plus sportfish and walk over to discuss the merits of my 1980, cost less than his dingy boat. Happens all the time.

Look at everything. Eventually something "pops" and you know exactly what you want....right now.

bp
 
We fell in love with the 2000 Cruisers 4270 too.

My cut off for the next boat is 1997. No real reason other than we seem to like the styles post 1996 better.
 
I have heard from more than 1 mechanic that after 10 years you will start throwing more maintenance $$$$ at a boat as that's about the time things start breaking. Kind of a blanket/general statement, but I think it's a good rule of thumb. We replaced quite a few things on our boat last year (some broke, some replaced just for peace of mind) and thus far this year it's been just the regular maintenance.

Now one could argue buying a new boat costs more and all else is equal.
 
My boat is 24 to 25 years old. The *only* mechanical issue I've had with it was having to replace the AC raw water pump. Every other system on the boat is still running, original stock and performing quite well.

When we got this boat 4 years ago, the plan was to repower it, new gen, etc, etc, etc. The problem was (and still is), the original Chrysler Marine engines are still running strong, still have the compression ratings of a near new engine and just won't die! I have a hard time ripping out such a trooper as these engines have been.

Other than that pump I've put in new electronics and stereo. That's it! Of course when this boat was made, it was a very high quality boat. The hull is all hand laid, solid fiberglass, no coring, and built like a tank. (thus also as heavy as one ;)

Cosmetically we *did* put new foam in the seat pads on the upper decks and next year we're replacing all the canvas and eisenglass but that's it.
 
Be wary of older Bravo III drives. I don't think Mercruiser fixed the corrosion problem until 2002.
 
quote:

Originally posted by GaryMartin

My boat is 24 to 25 years old. The *only* mechanical issue I've had with it was having to replace the AC raw water pump. Every other system on the boat is still running, original stock and performing quite well.

When we got this boat 4 years ago, the plan was to repower it, new gen, etc, etc, etc. The problem was (and still is), the original Chrysler Marine engines are still running strong, still have the compression ratings of a near new engine and just won't die! I have a hard time ripping out such a trooper as these engines have been.

Other than that pump I've put in new electronics and stereo. That's it! Of course when this boat was made, it was a very high quality boat. The hull is all hand laid, solid fiberglass, no coring, and built like a tank. (thus also as heavy as one ;)

Cosmetically we *did* put new foam in the seat pads on the upper decks and next year we're replacing all the canvas and eisenglass but that's it.




I totally agree with this. My current boat is a '92 Wellcraft 2600 (about a 29' cruiser). It has been meticulously maintained throughout it's life. For that reason, and that it seems to be a well made boat, it has been 100% trouble free for us. As of today, I think the only thing I would change on it would be to get a new top made for it--and that's just to make to look more current.

I am going to sea trial an '88 Portofino. It has had upkeep and a few replacements over the years (new water heater, some lines, etc.). Based on my own experience, what I have heard about the owner, and what the surveyor said (surveyed it a few years ago), I feel very comfortable with its age. I am getting a TON (several actually!) of boat for the $$$. This boat had new stringers put in it a few years ago--even though the original ones were fine. Apparently, that owner, a pilot, wanted to play it extra safe. So it's better than new now in the stringers dept.

I will build in a fund for major repairs-- head, engines, trannies, genset. Once I have completed upgrades, I should be good for many years. The 7.4s are not expensive to replace--as compared to other items.

I'm not at all scared of older boats that were well made to start with and well maintained throughout. I'm also with the camp that doesn't care for the styling of the newer cruisers.

Here's what I am going to look at and sea trial this weekend---It doesn't look dated to ME in the slightest.
'88 Portofino
1761495_1.jpg
 
I bought my 89 - 280 SeaRay last year. A little more than I wanted to spend, but got twice the boat that I was originally looking at. Low hours, new transom, and I also budgeted for doing some more annual repairs etc. I'll probably spend another 5-10K over the next couple of years on some minor delamination issues, but I'm still a whole pile below what I would pay for new. SeaRay made a hell of a boat back then and she holds up very well when we get pounded about once in a while. My slip neighbor has a newer 280, narrow beam, but nice boat - I would say his is more like a Beamer, and mine more like an old Chevy.
There are some great deals out there right now on old and new. (buyers market)
 
I once bought a boat about 20 years old. It was the exception rather than the norm! The electronics were beyond what the normal person would install in that type of boat. The condition had been upgraded beyond what a new model would have been. I was impressed and I bought it. Four years later I wanted to sell. There was no way the average broker would list that boat for anything beyond what the average book value called for. It did not matter that I had maintained the boat and it showed well. They had their standards and this boat was priced way out of line. The cost of the electronics had no value as far as the average condition of the boat. The morgage company has a standard range they will finance on a given model and the only way they will loan more than that value has little to do with the value of the boat but more the ability of the borrower to pay. I sold that boat for $100,000 less than I paid for it!
There reaches a point in the life of a boat that it makes no sense to continue to spend on it unless it is for your own ego or convience. Expect no return on that investment. Would I do it again? Only if I have a extra $100,000 lying around!
 
Back
Top