Who's responsible?

dazeoff-wy

Member
exMember
Joined
Jun 22, 2007
RO Number
26934
Messages
72
Are not the operators of the vessel responsible for navagation and avoiding things like large bridges. NOt the Cosat Guard

After reading this story I see another case of political grand standing. Someone trying to make a name fopr themsleves buy looking for blame somewhere other than the responsible parties.

Coast Guard admiral grilled over spill

By SCOTT LINDLAW
Associated Press Writer

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- The crash of a cargo ship into a bridge tower in San Francisco Bay that spilled 58,000 gallons of toxic fuel was solely the ship operator's fault, a high-ranking Coast Guard officer told a congressional panel.

Rear Adm. Craig Bone on Monday told the panel investigating the crash that human error aboard the Cosco Busan led to the Nov. 7 crash, which contaminated miles of coastline around the San Francisco Bay and killed hundreds of birds.

"Something tragic must have taken place on board the ship," Coast Guard Rear Adm. Craig Bone said. If the pilot and master "had carried out their responsibilities, we wouldn't be sitting here today."

Ten lawmakers questioned Bone about whether the Coast Guard could have done more to warn the ship it was in trouble. They asked Bone why the agency waited hours to inform city officials of the spill and why it did not press fishermen and volunteers into service sooner.

Mayor Gavin Newsom told the lawmakers that the first hint the city got of a major problem was when a part-time fire boat operator radioed that "something was going on" - about 12 hours after the crash. The Coast Guard never informed the city, which could have mobilized forces including volunteers, Newsom said.

"Notification was lax," he said. "In fact, arguably, there was no notification, even of 140 gallons of oil being spilled."

Bone acknowledged that the Coast Guard was too slow to inform city officials.

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, who represents San Francisco, said she planned to ask the Department of Homeland Security's inspector general, Richard Skinner, to conduct his own investigation.

That would be in addition to ongoing probes by the U.S. attorney's office here, the National Transportation Safety Board, California government agencies and Maryland Rep. Elijah Cummings' House Subcommittee on Coast Guard and Maritime Transportation.

The Coast Guard said Monday it was initiating a nationwide "incident-specific preparedness review" to ensure its personnel in other regions would be ready for such a disaster.

The pilot, Capt. John Cota, has told NTSB investigators there were indications of problems with his two radars and his grasp of electronic charts before the ship left its berth. But Bone said the pilot reported no such problems to the Coast Guard's Vessel Traffic Service that morning.

"If a pilot tells someone that his radar doesn't work, then gets under way, then he basically puts himself in a position where he's already placed the vessel at risk on his own accord," Bone told The Associated Press by telephone.

Bone also rejected criticism that the traffic service should have done more to warn the ship it might be in trouble. The service had asked Cota his intentions less than two minutes before the crash but had gone silent after that, the NTSB reported.

Service personnel are trained "not to distract the pilot with interruptions during any critical maneuver," Bone told lawmakers.

Bone told lawmakers the cleanup was "one of the most successful cleanups" he'd seen. Almost one-third of the 58,000 gallons of the spilled fuel has been recovered, the joint command overseeing the response reported Monday.

"As oil spills go, five to 20 percent is what you see" typically recovered, Bone said.

Rep. George Miller responded that if a 20 percent recovery rate is considered good, a new emphasis must be placed on prevention.

"That's just not going to work," Miller said.
 
Remember when you and your brother broke the Jim Beam "Elvis" decanter? You both pointed at each each other and said, "He did it" Same thing here. The only thing missing is someone saying like your mother, "I guess we just can't have nice things."
 
In this case there is no doubt that the two brothers were responsible for the broken JB decanter. However, mom was late in cleaning up the mess and the cat and dog got their paws cut up. Dad found the mess when he got home and now everyone is shouting at each other. Some are even blaming JB for the fumes.
 
Pelosi will do anything to get in front of the camera, even trashing our USCG!

I guess she has forgotten about the 30 thousand people the CG saved from rooftops, etc immediately after Katrina! They didn't sit around waiting for a Congressional Hearing; they did what they do best and saved thousands of lives, even while their homes and families were in peril. To me, they are heros!
 
Pelosi & San Francisco.
Nothing more need be said, or is of importance.
 
Just think, a $100 hand held GPS from boatfix could have avoided this incident (hard to call it an accident). If I was a harbor pilot, I'd own one or two.

Non working radar is bad but it isn't as if the bridge was moving was it?
 
NTSB determined last week that the redundant radar systems on Cosco Busan were working properly. Either the ship's bridge crew didn't understand the pilots instructions or they made an error with navigation equipment. Maybe some of both.

Things were so messed up on the Cosco Busan that day they probably couldn't have operated a hand held GPS correctly. The equipment is no better than the people using it at the time.
 
who cares how many hours it took the USCG to notify the politicos of the exact amount of fuel that leaked... it's irrelevant... what matters is that the USCG responded in a timely manner, and they did.
 
Here is a timeline for the Cosco Busan incident.

http://www.mercurynews.com/healthandscience/ci_7513587

OK, you can see that USGC and Office of Spill Prevention and Response (a department of CA state government) learned the true size of the Cosco Busan spill at the same time. USCG acted in timely manner and passed along the best information they had at the time.

This accident is unprecedented in San Francisco history. Nobody: not the USCG, the State of California or the local Bay Area communities were prepared to react fast enough to control this spill during the first couple of hours. That's when there is chance to contain the spill before it wanders across the entire bay. The oil clean up crews mandated by state law were too small and too poorly equipped to do the job. That’s a failure of state government. Our elected state officials are doing a fine job of blaming USCG and deflecting any questions regarding their own shortsightedness.

This was just a fuel leak. Think what could have happened with a loaded tanker.

Responsibility for the spill itself lies with the shipper and the SF Bay Pilots who acted as their agents.

With a half-dozen loaded oil tankers crossing SF Bay every day, you'd think someone would have set up a way to independently assess spills quickly and get them under control. Nope. It takes an accident like this to get everyone on the same page. Society rarely learns from foresight when trial and error will suffice.

Other questions that need answering:

Why does SF Bar Pilots have the authority to remove their people from an accident site before USCG investigates?

Why were USCG and local authorities not trained to recognize potential spills from the water and the damage evident on the ship?

Why would anyone re-elect to a mayor who didn’t know if he was talking about a tanker or a cargo ship?

There are some other threads here on this subject.

http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=108672

http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=108498

http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=108514
 
Back
Top