WiFi

TMcCann

Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2004
RO Number
15880
Messages
51
Has anyone purchased or used the Syrens onboard WiFi system and is it worth the $500.00 to $600.00 to purchase.
 
You can get a Verizon Air Card, among others, almost free with a monthly of $59.00. Why would you want to spend 5-6 hundred on a WiFi rig when an air card will give you Internet almost anywhere including underway?

Maybe I need more info on your particular situation.
 
TMcCann

I had a syrens light installed with a big bay mini computer last year. The software is simple to use. It finds all open and protected wireless access points in the area and it is fast. Every so often it will take its time hooking up to a network but overall, it gets my approval. In Canada's North Channel we had wireless access almost everywhere and it is very remote. The only drawback is that you may find yourself without the ability to hook up to a network - unlike the verizon card. Most of the time, you will also find a pay for network which allow you to purchase daily, weekly, monthly and annual subscriptions. A great number of the ports on Lake Erie offer one provider so I am just starting to look into them, but I have found many open networks in the same ports, so I am not sure if I will subscribe. Lexington, MI offers pay for network and one of marina owners opened up his wifi for free - hopefully this trend will continue.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Doc

You can get a Verizon Air Card, among others, almost free with a monthly of $59.00. Why would you want to spend 5-6 hundred on a WiFi rig when an air card will give you Internet almost anywhere including underway?






I would second this comment. There is much more flexibility in that it works everywhere, not just on the boat. I often work from the boat and the Verizon card has been just fine for a number of years now.

I'm guessing you already know this, but the vast majority of WiFi hot-spot's charge $9.95/day or some such so layer that on top of the exorbitant price of $500-$600 price of this gear. Personally, if you really want to go with WiFi try some of the off the shelf range extenders and such as the cost is much lower. You can always return it to the store if it's not doing the trick.
 
I use Syren's in front of my LinkSys Sprint router, this way if and when I find an open access WiFi connection I use it over the Sprint 1-RTT (60-80k) or EVDO-revA much faster. I have the best of both worlds. The Linksys router is the Wireless "G" model it's actual model# is WRT54G3G-ST Sprint sells them and they can be found on-line it allows the Sprint data card (a Novatel S720) to be plugged directly into it, then gives you on-board WiFi as well as 4 wired ports. It also runs directly off of 12 volts DC a big plus to me but it comes with a wall plug in power supply for those that like to run their devices off of 110VAC. It also has a "internet" CAT5 port this is where I have the Syren's plugged in. I am using the Syren's "lite" but with this set-up it allows me to go completly wireless if needed. The Sprint card has a cable that connects to an external dual-band Shaksphere amplifier and a Digital (4') 9db stick on top of my radar arch, the Syrens antenna is on my hardtop and I use the built in whip off the Sprint router for on-board WiFi distribution. I find this combination to be extremely flexable and reliable in central/southern New Jersey my main area of boating. Once my wife and I start cruising I will be able to report on the overall reliability and connectivity of the system. Regards Bill
 
Actually as far as Verizon goes if you are unlucky as we are to have poor reception in your area you are stuck if you commit to them. So like cell phone service goes so does wifi of that sort.
I have been thinking along the lines of a bridge router via ether net to a laptop that would handle the surveys. From there I was going to ethernet to another router that would handle wifi to the rest of the computers on the boat.
I was planning on an omnidirectional antennae on the radar arch, cabled up to an outdoor router such as air802 manufactures which would ehternet to a wifi router that the computers on the boat could access. So our laptops connect to the wifi router, and then to the outdoor router via ethernet. I believe one could also access the internet via an ethernet directly connected to the outdoor router.
Confused? If so buy a kit like Syrens or a packaged version of the air802 through someone like bbxpress. If you look really closely at the bbxpress system (800 bucks) they are using the air802 bridge router (around 250 bucks). Add in cables a second wifi router and you can see that one could beat the Syrens price and have separate units that are all replacable where as the Syrens unit would be complete replace. We can beat the bbxpress price also.
But it looks like a neat package the novice (believe me I am no expert and crawling through this stuff can be a pain) can pick up. Note Syrens suggests professional installation. To get the equivelent "punch" of the air802 APG300 I think you are talking about the Syrens ECAP not the Lite which sells for all sorts of prices.
 
I do have Syrens Lite, and do hook a computer directly to it for the initial survey. I have found Cellular based internet access good in my area. But I know there are vast areas of the country without the service. That is why I installed the Syrens hoping if I don't have cellular we may find an open network. I can also do simple e-mail (no attachments) through my TracPhone 252 but I am limited to 9.6k with acceleration software. I can't get any work related projects done while I am away at that speed. I will be installing a WiFi system at my marina and in speaking with the owner we will probably leave the system open unless it gets abused. My marina is small only about 120 boats about 30% are larger than 35'. It will be a nice real world trial and test of WiFi at a marina.
Regards Bill
 
bill

do you really find more usable networks with Syrens or other boosters / antenna ? Seems to me that more an more people are locking their networks and fewer are avaiable.

I use cingular/att, they have near DSL like G3 service around here it's very reliable. my helmcam is up with almost no disconnects.
 
I too use the Verizon air card and HIGHLY recommend it. I opted for the PC5750...
 
From my Marina I have found anywhere from as little as 2 open networks to a dozen. Only 2 are locked. If find most wireless routers are on channel 6, Linksys's default setting. Cruising the back side of Long Beach Island I find similar numbers of open networks. It's amazing how many people do not enable security on their wireless routers. However I do not advocate stealing other's service at least not for any extended periods of time. I'm an RF engineer by trade and into playing with communications systems so I have fun playing with all this stuff. Take care. Bill
 
Getting internet from an open network is not stealing (courts have ruled it's not theft of service). Many people intentionally leave there network open as a service to others. I have 15MBPS FIOS at home and leave it open (i'll never use all that bandwidth). If FIOS goes down I can use my neighbors Comcast cable network. We all just share in the neighborhood.
 
I use both my Verizon PDA with a cellular booster and a Hyperlink Tech WiFi booster & external antenna. I can usually get signal on one or the other depending on where I'm anchored.

The WiFi boosters do work. Mine is a 500mW amp paired with an 8.5dBi antenna. At my home slip the difference is between "seeing" 2 networks without the booster and 10 with. Of the 10, about 6 are open. WiFi is quite often a faster connection than cellular networks.
 
I leave my home network open for others to use as well, now my business network is closed and if we get a visitor that needs access they are given the key. I'm not sure the courts have all ruled the same.

I agree that my speeds on the boat are better through a good quality WiFi signal than my Sprint set up where the tower is EVDO-rev.A enabled.
Take care. Bill
 
I have a Verizon wireless card and works great. I have the USB "free" modem from Verizon and I have used it on three laptops and a desktop....quite flexible. I have also been able to "get on" to open wifi networks while away from the homesite.

As an aside, and I don't know the answer to this, but with more and more folks becoming wireless savy, and so many hackers just looking to cause havoc, would it be possible for some hacker to set up a Trojan horse so to speak by letting you onto his network (leaving it open) and then somehow getting into your files on your machine?
 
For those of you paying for the cellular cards, don't forget that most carriers do have tethering options for PDA's and some smartphones. Not that a card isn't easier and may or may not work better, but if you're going to be paying those monthly fees, why not have it with you all the time? I rely on my PDA's wireless connection to my office in my daily life. I can then tether it to my laptop when I need. Verizon charges $45/month for PDA access and another $15 (if you want to play by the rules) for tethering. I think that combined price is the same as the cards? Sprint is MUCH cheaper for PDAs at $15, but I don't know their tethering rules.

As for Dominic's very good concerns, yes, there's always a risk that some jerk will try and do something evil. Make sure you have a firewall turned on (there are usually built-in versions with most recent operating systems). Make sure you're running good and up to date anti-virus/spyware software. And only maintain your connection while you need it.
 
quote:

Originally posted by TMcCann Has anyone purchased or used the Syrens onboard WiFi system and is it worth the $500.00 to $600.00 to purchase.






BTW, there are much cheaper ways to do this. You need an amp for around $160. An antenna for around $100. Misc. cables for maybe $50 and a wireless card for your laptop for also around $50 (this is needed as the amp has to physically plug into the laptop). Thus the price should be around $360-ish.
 
quote:

As an aside, and I don't know the answer to this, but with more and more folks becoming wireless savy, and so many hackers just looking to cause havoc, would it be possible for some hacker to set up a Trojan horse so to speak by letting you onto his network (leaving it open) and then somehow getting into your files on your machine?





Everyone should be running a firewall regardless og wifi, cable or dsl.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Billylll

From my Marina I have found anywhere from as little as 6 open networks to a dozen. Only 2 are locked. If find most wireless routers are on channel 6, Linksys's default setting. Cruising the back side of Long Beach Island I find similar numbers of open networks. It's amazing how many people do not enable security on their wireless routers. However I do not advocate stealing other's service at least not for any extended periods of time. I'm an RF engineer by trade and into playing with communications systems so I have fun playing with all this stuff. Take care. Bill






I'm one of those that leaves their wireless open for the boats in the harbor. My house is on the harbor in my town, and when I check in the summer I frequently notice that there are people piggybacking on it - I'm sure from boats out in the harbor or in the marina across the way. I don't really mind - I have 1MBPS DSL, and don't find it to affect my access speed in a noticable way. Sometimes I think about locking it down, but then it would be a hassle for houseguests that bring their laptops. So I'm leaving it open for now. I do have a firewall set up to my satisfaction to prevent anyone from doing any harm.

Regarding using cell phones to get on, Sprint Blackberries have a great deal where you can use your phone as a modem for no additional charge if you're using the BB for email.
 
Thanks all for all the info. but I have one other question. the verizon service for $59.00 is the on limited air time.
 
Not to be a commercial for Sprint but they do have a great data roaming agreement with Altel. Altel serves many rural markets. But there is a hitch with rural usually comes 1-RTT and in many cases no EVDO services. I-RTT is still fairly fast about the equivalent of running 1/2 a DSL circuit. Sprint has no policy against tethering again you can buy a 4 port wireless router from them that uses a single data card. I also tried the Kyrocera KR-1 cellular router/modem, this is what the KVH TracNet 100 marine internet product is based around and that will accept a tethered phone and either Verizon or Sprint's networks, the Linksys only supports Sprint's data card. Just some more information about various cellular based routers. One note about Verizon they have been around the longest so they probably have more towers than any other carrier I just don't know how aggressive their data roll out plan is. Take care. Bill
 
Back
Top