Chart chips

Scottath

Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2007
RO Number
26640
Messages
159
Iam in disbelief that these chart plotter chips have such poor charting charactoristics. To load them up with geneal information and pictures of places 100s or maybe even a thousand miles away from where a person typically boats doesn't make sence. I mean really How many people traval in therir boat on a regular basis a 100 miles away? IMO they should have detailed charts for your area and for the handful % wise make a traval chip.I'm sure these people who take off for months at a time and do the 100s or thousand mile trips would rather have a chip just for that anyway. Maybe they can keep some of that info up to date. I just saw a brand new chip with a marinalisted that closed 5 years ago. They kept that but removed alot of soundings that is "usefull information" to boaters. OOOps i can't go in there anymore because the soundings are gone and I might hit bottom.......what the heck are they thinking!!!Hey, some of those pictures of harbors from a birds eye veiw that I'll never go to do look nice.....
 
"How many people traval in therir boat on a regular basis a 100 miles away? "

I do, just about every trip.

The data on the chip comes from various sources. Not all sources care to respond to annual "data verification" postcards. Remember, that there are far fewer boaters than drivers, so those features that seem up-to-date for roar trips ( Ah, I see there is a Stuckey's up ahead! ) are not as current on the water. And the cost... The cost to update that info is high, spread over fewer buyers. More accurate would certainly raise the price of the data.

The soundings are based on the data provided on the underlying chart. If the chart does not have them, neither does the chip. But I seriously doubt that they removed the soundings. More likely, they simply are not displayed, based on your current plotter settings.
 
Soundings not being displayed is possable ??? I don't have the old chip anymore to see but all I did was remove the old chip and a week later put in a new chip. Some areas are as detailed as the old chart but some areas just has a lack of data. I'll go down the boat and see if I can change the depth settings to see if any more soundings pop up.
 
i agree with radioactive.

i was on my neighbors boat last week as he was complaing of exactly the same thing. for whatever reason the detail settings were different from old chip to new chip.

i could only imagine the detail getting better as time goes on...with technology and everything.

oh yeah...100mile trip...not uncommon for me at all.
 
I agree, the vector charts i look at have eliminated a lot of detail in shallow areas, exactly where i want more detail, in ports and harbors.
 
well, maybe you want to be a little specific... which chips ?

memory is getting cheaper, cramming more data doesn't cost much. some system allow you to set what you want displayed at various res. have you tried that ?

"OOOps i can't go in there anymore because the soundings are gone and I might hit bottom......." well, if you have up to date paper charts on your boat, as you should, you woudl be able to check water depth and then decide if you can get in that marina...

and what's with the ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ in the thread title ? jsut trying to get more attention to your rant ?
 
P: i havent seen any chips that show bottom detail as well as paper or raster charts.
 
Bruce, i find the blue charts from garmin to be extremely accurate, including bottom, as detailed as paper charts.
 
I just looked at the garman chart ad and links a week ago or so and while the PC version looked very good the plotter version was significantly less detailed. They have the data but seem to decide other wowie stuff is more important than bottom detail. I don't get it.
 
I'm with you pdecat.I know many people as a number make long trips but as a %of all boaters it is a very small number. These chips with general basic info on them must be great for them. I am sure Ive never been more than 25 miles from my port on my own boat or anyone elses boat I've been on. I know I've been alot further that 95% of they people I know. I probably go out on my boat well over a 100 times a year but yet am uncomfortablte within 1/4 from the shoreline as soon as I leave my harbor. So IMO 90to 95% of the local boaters suffer for poor local chart charactoristics for the 5% or 10% of long trip boaters.

Knowing what I know about my area and what is on those chips I would prefer a more detailed chip when I'm traveling. If I had the time and money to ride from Maine to Florida I would be more willing to buy 3 or 4 chips so I knew I had the most information available for my boating safty. I'm on the water enough to know safty first,safty first safty first saftyfirst.....
 
on my 2006C 3 or 4 year old, i can set the level of detail I want at each range... i haven't changed the setting since i got it but i know that some soundings can be shown or not. maybe that's why you dont' see some soundings on the plotter.

as too showing charts 100, 200 miles away, they usually go by regions... South Florida includes the Keys, the SE coast up to Stuart or a little higher and the SW coast up to Ft Myers. that's a good package... while i've only been to Ft Myers once, it's there...
 
pascalg, I use the Cmap. It still has the most chart soundings from what I could tell. I go out all the time so I already have a idea what the bottom looks like. Some of these new machines are doing 3d. The sales persons at the marine stores were very excited to show it to me. The 3d is configed from the info available on the chart sounding...... which is alot less than the real thing! so realistically ,its useless.
 
As Pascal said, you shouldn't be dependent on your GPS and should have paper charts on board. It's a good idea to have a depth sounder on board as well to verify depths. Every boater should also know how to plot courses on a paper chart and take a fix with a hand held compass.
 
I went down to the boat for a while to see if I could change setting to get more soundings to pop up.. I couldn't. I'll look through the instructions tonight but everything is really self explainitory after very little exploring or the cp1000. but I'll look anyway.
 
thanks Les and pascal. I have problems with a so called water proof plotter. Can you imagine those 100/150 trips a year with a paper chart. My paper chart is in a baggy for showing the coast guard or police so I don't get fined for not having a legdable chart. I did that because they turned to mush to many times.
 
i have never heard of a law requiring a chart, is this new?
 
Yes, Bruce, new law. You need one chart for the boat and a throwable chart in case someone falls overboard and doesn't know where they are. The throwable chart must be in a USCG approved plastic tube with a pointed end so you can throw it like a javelin at the person in the water.
The power squadron offers a course in chart throwing so check your local squadron for dates and times.
 
I make many longer trips than you describe but at the end of each trip is shallow water and I want every possible detail. I keep paper charts but IMO the plotter should show the same detail. That they dont is why I am still waiting to send my order to Les.
 
hummmmm.... I think so???? I get those insection stickers on my boat from the coast guard every now and then and they won't give you one unless you have all the required equiptment. I am under the inpression all that stuff is required reguardless and if you get boarded and they feel like writing you for not having whatever they can. Actually ,,, I have alot of hours on the water and a chart plotter would be one of the top 5 things I would suggest for anyone to have on their boat.

1) PFD for each person
2)GPS chart plotter
3)anchor
4)fire extinguisher
5) cell phone
 
Ah, Scott, I can see we've got some work to do here. 1 and 4 are required by law. Now, do me a favor and check the boating laws of NY (Google) and the required equipment section

http://www.uscgboating.org/

then come back and see if your list needs to be a tad longer.
 
Back
Top