Fun Question

  • Thread starter Thread starter CW
  • Start date Start date

CW

Member
exMember
Joined
Nov 30, 2004
RO Number
15825
Messages
92
You are going to make a trip up the river to fish in your favorite fishing hole. The fishing hole is 60 miles upstream and you plan on fishing for one hour and then return home. Your boat will cruise at 20 MPH. Question: Will this trip take the same amount of time if there is no current in the river as it would with a 10MPH current?
Answer later.
 
Who wants to fish in a 10 MPH current???
 
nope...

7 hours if no current.
9 hours with the current.
 
Need to know the length of the boat. [:-captain]
 
What if you go to the candy store and you want to pay a total of $12.79 for a pound of candy. You want some candy that cost $3.99/lb, some that costs $5.78/lb and some that costs $7.99/lb. How much of each would you get?

CW, what type of fish are you going for?
 
No current: 3 hours going and 3 hours returning

10 mph current: 6 hours going and 2 hours returning

G
 
In the Hudson, we have current, PLUS tide to deal with...
 
Many more questions here...

Did you catch fish, what did they weigh and did you keep them on board, adding to the boat's weight?

How much fuel did you burn and what did it weigh, subtracting from the boat's weight?

How much beer did you drink and did you recycle it into the head or go off the swim platform?

Did you eject the admiral over the side because she kept complaining about the beer consumption and how much did she weigh (or were you afraid to ask)?
 
If I'm going to travel 60 miles to go fishing, I sure won't return the same day! Drop the hook until tomorrow and relax. even if you don't catch anything, you'll have a great time!
 
I am disappointed. Nobody has thought to ask whether the captain in question has taken a safe boating course or what kind of PFD he's wearing.
 
All very interesting. The correct answer is no.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Bliss

All very interesting. The correct answer is no.






But what if the boat itself is 60 miles long?
 
Because the element of time has to be considered, no is the answer. This trip with current will take longer because the current working against headway will affect the vessel longer than the current working for headway.

How about this one..... A boater has two bullets. He puts one in his gun and fires it off his bow perfectly parallel to a dead calm sea. The other bullet is dropped overboard from the same height, and at the exact same time the trigger is pulled on the gun. Which bullet hits the water first?
 
They both hit at the same time, next question...
 
No difference. If your boat will cruise at 20MPH, it will do so regardless of the current. Granted, your RPMs may be higher and you will burn more fuel when going against the current, but if your boat maintains the 20MPH there will be no difference.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Chris_P

No difference. If your boat will cruise at 20MPH, it will do so regardless of the current. Granted, your RPMs may be higher and you will burn more fuel when going against the current, but if your boat maintains the 20MPH there will be no difference.






Chris, are you assuming that the 20mph is a GPS reading or "speedometer" reading. Big difference. I assumed "speedometer" reading for my calculations. It wasn't stated that the 20mph was a true speed over ground.

G
 
PASCALG has the right answer as usual. To clarify the twenty MPH was read from the speedometer not the GPS. To help as a memory aid, remember going into a current hurts you more than going with the current will help you. In this question the current hurt us 3 hours going to the fishing hole but the current only helps us 1 hour coming back. We had to run upstream for 6 hours and down stream 2 hours. Happy New Year
 
everyone miseed the key words "fishing trip" the trip will last as long as the beer holds out speed of boat only delays when the drinking starts.
 
Back
Top